Wink-wink: Smith, Westbrook say they practiced
By DANA PENNETT O'NEIL
oneild@phillynews.com
If an athlete is limited in a limited practice, did he really practice?
That is the riddle wrapped in an enigma cloaked in Eagles' secrecy that the reassembled football team posed yesterday. The bye week completed, the team reconvened for a 10-10-10 practice (10 offensive plays, 10 defensive plays, 10 special-teams plays) and both Brian Westbrook and L.J. Smith said they practiced.
Well, sort of.
Not required to provide an injury report until tomorrow, injured Eagles players - clearly told to guard their health status as if it were the key to ending the Iraq war, curing cancer and ending the reality-show phenomenon - played coy when pressed about their participation in the closed session.
"I was out there," Westbrook said with a grin.
Of course, so were the water boys.
Smith wasn't terribly effusive, either, refusing to elaborate on his injured groin except to say that he, too, was a limited practice participant . . . in the limited practice.
"I didn't do too much, just went out there and did a couple of things," Smith said. "I'm really not allowed to talk [about playing this week]. That's passed down [from the coaching staff]."
Still nursing an abdominal strain suffered against Detroit - he later emerged from the training room with his midsection wrapped in an ace bandage - Westbrook said he was getting better but wasn't willing to make predictions about his status for Sunday's game at the Jets.
"I'm not sure yet," he said. "It depends on how it goes this week in terms of progress with the rehab."
Smith, who had surgery to alleviate scar tissue on his previously repaired sports hernia, hasn't played since the Redskins game. On Sept. 21, the day of the second procedure, the Jets' game was offered as a reasonable target date for Smith's return.
"I'm pretty much on schedule, I think from what they told me," the tight end said. "They told me it wasn't a long, continuous rehab process, it was fairly quick."
Westbrook and Smith spent their bye week here in town, trying to get better. Both also know they really need to get better now if the Eagles are going to right their listing ship.
What most people remember from the Giants' game is Winston Justice's ignominious debut in the NFL, but the fact is, Justice was just a small portion of a problematic offense. Without Westbrook, this becomes a very defensible offense. Without Smith, this becomes a very inept blocking offense.
"It will boost the morale, put confidence back in Donovan [McNabb]," Smith said. "Once you've made a name for yourself, the defense, they don't know if you're 50 or 75 percent. As long as you're on the field, they have to respect you. Now it helps if you're 100 percent."
The easy and perhaps most honest assessment of the debacle against the Giants is that the Eagles were without far too many of their best players to win. No Westbrook, no Smith, no William Thomas, no Brian Dawkins, no Lito Sheppard.
Players, however, know that a ready-made excuse masks a deeper problem. This team was just OK against Green Bay, not very good against Washington, unstoppable against Detroit and anemic against the Giants. The injury list wasn't that extensive until New York.
Not surprisingly, then, the buzzword flying around the locker room yesterday was consistency.
As in the Eagles need to get some.
"We play football. We know how to play football," Sheldon Brown said. "The team that showed up against Detroit needs to show up all the time. It's not hard to do. It's putting your mind and your effort to it, putting your foot down and doing it.
"I'm not saying we're not doing it. We're not doing it well enough, to the caliber we're used to doing it. Right now we're average and we have great people. Our great people need to be great."
And two of them simply need to get on the field.
"I'm trying to get better," Westbrook said. "I'm doing everything I can to get out on the field. It's just one of those things that takes time to heal." *