I have always wondered and never seen this discussed, so I wanted to get opinions. What do you think are the characteristics of consistently good ff team managers? People who year after year dominate and either make the playoffs or win their league? Obviously knowing your scoring system, and taking time to study player development and news is important, but what else? Are they good with numbers? Intuitive? I don't know because I am not a dominating player, but am curious what people think makes for a dominating ff manager. Thoughts?
1) Not just knowing your scoring system, but truly
understanding your scoring system (and starting lineup requirements, etc.) It's one thing to
know that your league awards 0.5 PPR and has a RB/WR/TE flex position, it's another thing entirely to
understand what that means for the relative values of players. This is partly quantitative, partly intuitive, but it's crucial. 2) Staying on top of news, etc. is important as well. My local league is about half skilled owners and half guys who don't really know what they're doing. The latter half, for example, had no idea who Arian Foster was when I drafted him in the 5th round last year. I know as well as anyone how much real life interferes with following every little development in the NFL, but if you're going to pony up a decent amount of scratch to play in a fantasy football league, you need to stay on top of that kind of stuff somehow if you're going to have any chance to win. This is important not just prior to the draft, but all season long as you proactively pick up free agents the week before they blow up, instead of reactively overpaying for guys after the fact.
3) As a corollary to what I mentioned in point 2, the only people who "year after year dominate" are those who play in leagues with less-skilled opponents. I have fairly consistently dominated that local league I mentioned, but that's less a testament to my abilities than it is to my leaguemates lack of skill and preparation. In another league I play in, everyone is serious about it and no one dominates that league (it's been around for 21 years and there's never been a "dynasty" where one or two owners have dominated for any length of time).