I have to agree with 80s here.If a league isn't doing this, the league is amateur.
Wow. Rather than saying a league is amateur, I would say it's traditional and follows the NFL style. Following your logic, I should say that if you aren't playing in at least a 16 team IDP, 35 man roster minimum, salary/contract league using actual NFL contracts, then you are an amateur....of course I would never say thatIlov80s said:If a league isn't doing this, the league is amateur.
Defending (or criticizing) any feature of fantasy football by saying it mimics the NFL is pointless.Wow. Rather than saying a league is amateur, I would say it's traditional and follows the NFL style. Following your logic, I should say that if you aren't playing in at least a 16 team IDP, 35 man roster minimum, salary/contract league using actual NFL contracts, then you are an amateur....of course I would never say thatIlov80s said:If a league isn't doing this, the league is amateur.![]()
Agreed. If people want to make their fantasy leagues more "real", then they need to go full IDP, only have 1 QB and then 5 flex spots, only count TDs for points, etc.Defending (or criticizing) any feature of fantasy football by saying it mimics the NFL is pointless.Wow. Rather than saying a league is amateur, I would say it's traditional and follows the NFL style. Following your logic, I should say that if you aren't playing in at least a 16 team IDP, 35 man roster minimum, salary/contract league using actual NFL contracts, then you are an amateur....of course I would never say thatIlov80s said:If a league isn't doing this, the league is amateur.![]()
Otherwise, there would be no such thing as an auction draft. Which most people who try it seem to love.
I prefer blind bid waivers for two main reasons:
It requires more thought and strategy, which makes it more fun.
I'm generally not in favor of any rule that rewards failure, which is what priority waivers does.
The blind bidding should be over well before Sunday so you are just free to add and drop untill the players's game starts.Our league just switched to FAB for this year after many years of debate. For those of you on CBS how do you handle Sunday morning pickups for late scratches etc?
For everyone else how do you have it worded in your bylaws?
Think just about all of them at this point. I know for sure ESPN doesWhat sites offer blind bidding?
I'll keep you in mind when we have an opening. Nobody should be forced to play in leagues like that.I'm trying to convince one of my leagues to change to this. No one seems interested. Instead our genius commish thinks doing a reverse standings waiver order every week is a great idea.
According to CBS it's ether all FAAB or all waivers. There are no add/drop periods with their FAAB system.The blind bidding should be over well before Sunday so you are just free to add and drop untill the players's game starts.Our league just switched to FAB for this year after many years of debate. For those of you on CBS how do you handle Sunday morning pickups for late scratches etc?
For everyone else how do you have it worded in your bylaws?
Correct. In my one league that still insists on using CBS, some of us wanted to do FAAB followed by FCFS, but CBS doesn't have that capability. Ridiculous given how much they charge.According to CBS it's ether all FAAB or all waivers. There are no add/drop periods with their FAAB system.The blind bidding should be over well before Sunday so you are just free to add and drop untill the players's game starts.Our league just switched to FAB for this year after many years of debate. For those of you on CBS how do you handle Sunday morning pickups for late scratches etc?
For everyone else how do you have it worded in your bylaws?
It was... in 1987.I'm trying to convince one of my leagues to change to this. No one seems interested. Instead our genius commish thinks doing a reverse standings waiver order every week is a great idea.
We have the worst system (but it benefits me cause I pay attention on Sundays). FCFS during games and all week on FA pickups. Only locked players are the ones dropped the previous week. Process those dropped waivers Thursday night/early Fri morning. We took a vote to change it. I argued FOR waivers processed for all FAs and either a bidding system or a worst-first (against my own self interest). These guys don't play in other leagues and don't know how crazy our set up is.BigSteelThrill said:It was... in 1987.MattFancy said:I'm trying to convince one of my leagues to change to this. No one seems interested. Instead our genius commish thinks doing a reverse standings waiver order every week is a great idea.
Yeah, that was soooooooo bad.We have the worst system (but it benefits me cause I pay attention on Sundays). FCFS during games and all week on FA pickups. Only locked players are the ones dropped the previous week. Process those dropped waivers Thursday night/early Fri morning.We took a vote to change it. I argued FOR waivers processed for all FAs and either a bidding system or a worst-first (against my own self interest). These guys don't play in other leagues and don't know how crazy our set up is.BigSteelThrill said:It was... in 1987.MattFancy said:I'm trying to convince one of my leagues to change to this. No one seems interested. Instead our genius commish thinks doing a reverse standings waiver order every week is a great idea.
I've in a league for 12 or 13 years now. We are just all friends and family and coworkers. Some have come and gone, but there's a core of 6 that have been in it since the beginning and another 3 that have been in it for 7 or 8 years. You just have to know people that are interested and build the league over time. We just do regular redraft, not dynasty or keeper. I would assume almost every dynasty has a yearly winner and payout. In theory, a dynasty league would never end.I apologize for my ignorance on the subject but last year was my first time being successful at FF but it was on Yahoo.
It seems like many of you are in private leagues. Is this a correct assumption or am I just still wet behind the ears?
If there are private leagues, how do you get in?
I looked at the league section of the forum and most are dynasty. I am embarrassed to say that I really don't fully understand these continuation leagues.
In dynasty, do you win $ each year or at the completion of the dynasty?
I also don't understand how you have the same team but there is seemingly a redraft.
I guess I am getting well beyond my OP but when I posted at the Free for All, the responses were all model candidates for Dateline Catch A Predator.
Currently, we do rolling waivers, which is still dumb. But he thinks going to the reverse standings waiver order will make it more realistic and give the teams in last a better chance. So stupid. So because I know how to manage my team, I should be punished if I lose a player because my team is better than yours?Shutout said:I'll keep you in mind when we have an opening. Nobody should be forced to play in leagues like that.MattFancy said:I'm trying to convince one of my leagues to change to this. No one seems interested. Instead our genius commish thinks doing a reverse standings waiver order every week is a great idea.
BB----auctions---21 century stuff people.
This is the worst! I just convinced my league to go to FAAB system and I have to figure out how to deal with a Free Agent period. CBS gives some roundabout way involving zero bids and the commish checking timestamps as a workaround....ugh, really not sure how to handle this. At least I noticed this prior to wk1!!Pip said:Correct. In my one league that still insists on using CBS, some of us wanted to do FAAB followed by FCFS, but CBS doesn't have that capability. Ridiculous given how much they charge.strykerpks said:According to CBS it's ether all FAAB or all waivers. There are no add/drop periods with their FAAB system.Ilov80s said:The blind bidding should be over well before Sunday so you are just free to add and drop untill the players's game starts.Our league just switched to FAB for this year after many years of debate. For those of you on CBS how do you handle Sunday morning pickups for late scratches etc?
For everyone else how do you have it worded in your bylaws?
My commish found a way to work around this on CBS, not sure how he did it in the background. We are able to bid during the week, but there is an add/drop period as well.This is the worst! I just convinced my league to go to FAAB system and I have to figure out how to deal with a Free Agent period. CBS gives some roundabout way involving zero bids and the commish checking timestamps as a workaround....ugh, really not sure how to handle this. At least I noticed this prior to wk1!!Pip said:Correct. In my one league that still insists on using CBS, some of us wanted to do FAAB followed by FCFS, but CBS doesn't have that capability. Ridiculous given how much they charge.strykerpks said:According to CBS it's ether all FAAB or all waivers. There are no add/drop periods with their FAAB system.Ilov80s said:The blind bidding should be over well before Sunday so you are just free to add and drop untill the players's game starts.Our league just switched to FAB for this year after many years of debate. For those of you on CBS how do you handle Sunday morning pickups for late scratches etc?
For everyone else how do you have it worded in your bylaws?
This is the option CBS gives....seems like a big pain but might be what has to happen...If you can find out what your commish did, it would be very much appreciated...My commish found a way to work around this on CBS, not sure how he did it in the background. We are able to bid during the week, but there is an add/drop period as well.This is the worst! I just convinced my league to go to FAAB system and I have to figure out how to deal with a Free Agent period. CBS gives some roundabout way involving zero bids and the commish checking timestamps as a workaround....ugh, really not sure how to handle this. At least I noticed this prior to wk1!!Pip said:Correct. In my one league that still insists on using CBS, some of us wanted to do FAAB followed by FCFS, but CBS doesn't have that capability. Ridiculous given how much they charge.strykerpks said:According to CBS it's ether all FAAB or all waivers. There are no add/drop periods with their FAAB system.Ilov80s said:The blind bidding should be over well before Sunday so you are just free to add and drop untill the players's game starts.Our league just switched to FAB for this year after many years of debate. For those of you on CBS how do you handle Sunday morning pickups for late scratches etc?
For everyone else how do you have it worded in your bylaws?
pzn - Just talked to my commish, looks like we did the same process you detailed above. The $0 bids were allowed and he manually went through and approved them. I definitely think there should be a better process.This is the option CBS gives....seems like a big pain but might be what has to happen...If you can find out what your commish did, it would be very much appreciated...My commish found a way to work around this on CBS, not sure how he did it in the background. We are able to bid during the week, but there is an add/drop period as well.This is the worst! I just convinced my league to go to FAAB system and I have to figure out how to deal with a Free Agent period. CBS gives some roundabout way involving zero bids and the commish checking timestamps as a workaround....ugh, really not sure how to handle this. At least I noticed this prior to wk1!!Pip said:Correct. In my one league that still insists on using CBS, some of us wanted to do FAAB followed by FCFS, but CBS doesn't have that capability. Ridiculous given how much they charge.strykerpks said:According to CBS it's ether all FAAB or all waivers. There are no add/drop periods with their FAAB system.Ilov80s said:The blind bidding should be over well before Sunday so you are just free to add and drop untill the players's game starts.Our league just switched to FAB for this year after many years of debate. For those of you on CBS how do you handle Sunday morning pickups for late scratches etc?
For everyone else how do you have it worded in your bylaws?
"Can I make a regular add outside of the auction if my league uses the FAAB system?
There is no hybrid format that combines a FAAB period, followed by a period of first-come, first-served add/drops. However, the following alternative could achieve the desired results, provided the commissioner manually processes the transactions.
Using the “Commish approved auction process to do add/drops FAAB “format and checking the box to “Allow Zero Bids” may be a suitable workaround for many interested leagues. By implementing this feature, owners will be permitted to submit bids for players without having to spend any funds from their FAAB budget.
Under the pending approval queue, labeled “Process FAAB Bids,” the Commissioner will be able to review transactions submitted prior to the deadline. For the days you choose, you can dictate to the owners to submit bids for players where the winning claim is decided by the highest bidder.
On days where Free Agents are meant to be claimed on a first-come, first-served basis, have the owners in your league zero dollar bids for free agents. When reviewing the bids, the submission times will be time-stamped – permitting the commissioner to ensure that the first claim put in will be the winning claim.
Be advised that the “Deadline to Submit Bids” will be the same on all days checked off. Your access to the bid claims will be unavailable until your deadline has passed."