parrot said:
Just finished Blood Song. I wasn't that impressed for a good part of the book, particularly given some of the reviews here. The story is solid but he doesn't do a great job of developing his characters or settings. Also I felt like some of Vaelin's motives and rationalizations were a little flimsy. Just a little lazy on the writing in some instances. The story really grew on me though and I was fully invested by the end. I even thought the writing got better as the story progressed. Looking forward to reading book 2.
Starting Heart Shaped Box by Joe Hill.
Blood Song was originally self published I believe from a first time author so it would help explain some of the inconsistencies within it.
Good point on the self publishing thing - the first run of
Blood Song probably didn't have much outside editing, if at all. But I don't think it was his first novel, though, because I read a couple of other sci-fi books he'd put out (the Slab City Blues series).
Possum said:
as previously posted, I recently read the Memory, Sorrow and Thorn trilogy by Tad Williams. I liked the series overall - the first two books held my interest a little more than the last one, but it was a very good epic fantasy type series. I can absolutely see where this series influenced George R. R. Martin, too - there were a lot of plot/character similarities between MST and ASOIAF that jumped off the page at me while I was reading it. Williams' writing isn't quite as hard-edged as Martin, though, and he definitely doesn't kill off his characters nearly as often - in terms of style, I felt like he had nearly as much in common with Tolkien or CS Lewis as he does with modern guys like Martin or Abercrombie (and I mean that in a good way).
other recently read stuff:
Lexicon by Max Barry - a thriller about a guy who gets unwittingly caught up in a war between groups of "poets", people who can use spoken language in specific patterns to control and manipulate regular people and each other. The two groups are fighting for control of an ancient word that's a million times more powerful than anything in modern language. The premise is pretty cool and the first 2/3 or so of the book was really well done - fast-paced, lots of action, solid dialogue/characters, but I felt that the last part of the book started to veer into cliche territory a little bit. Still, it was a good read overall (and goes by quickly, too). Three and a half out of five stars.
The WInd-Up Girl by Paolo Bacigalupi - sci-fi novel about a future Earth where seed corporations have destroyed the majority of the world's crops through bioengineering controls gone wrong. It's set in Thailand and reads a bit like an agricultural version of Blade Runner (I've also heard people make comparisons between TWUG and Graham Greene, which I can see too). The novel follows an undercover "calorie man" from one of the American corporations who's in Thailand trying to gain access to a one of the world's last unmodified seedbanks held by the Thai government so that his company can find new foodstuffs to exploit. Along the way he falls in love with an illegal android, the "windup girl" of the title, while working his way through shady politics and espionage in the post-energy crisis and famine-wracked future. This book had some plot flaws here and there, but Bacigalupi is a hell of a talented writer and this is definitely worth a read imo. Four out of five stars.
currently reading The Grim Company by Luke Scull, another sword and sorcery modern fantasy in the mold of Joe Abercrombie's First Law series. It's been pretty good so far - nothing all that original (stylistically it reminds me of a mashup of Abercrombie and Scott Lynch) but it's very well written, the characters are engaging, and there's a good bit of humor in it. Looks like this is the first book of a series, so there's yet another set of books I'm going to be waiting on over the next few years.
Oh I absolutely loved Windup Girl! I wanted to read more about that world, and I believe there are more books in taht world, one of which is YA. He also has a collection of short stories called Pump Six and Other stories that is on my Goodreads wishlist.
And as far as comparing to Abercrombie...that a bold statement. Can you let me know you thoughts when you are done? I love Abercrombie, and someone trying to follow in his footsteps is facing quite an uphill climb in my view. However, I will usually give someone a chance if I hear a good opinion on them.
yeah man,
Pump 6 is an absolutely awesome collection - if you liked
Windup Girl then I definitely recommend it (my favorite story in there is
The People Of Sand And Slag). PB is a really talented author and I think his take on scifi, the way he comes at it from an environmentalist point of view, is really fresh and interesting (and I'm not even an environmentalist type, I just like his writing). The other two books of his that I've got that are set in the same world as
TWUG are
Ship Breaker and
The Drowned Cities - I haven't read
Ship Breaker, but I read
TDS and liked it a lot. It's set in North America instead of Thailand, but same deal - it's after a worldwide famine/energy collapse that destroyed the majority of civilization as we know it and completely wiped out the East Coast. Both of those two books are classified YA - I can't speak to
Ship Breaker, but I think
The Drowned Cities is a great read for adults too. It's a lot more gritty and violent than your typical YA novel.
the Abercrombie comparison is just that a lot of aspects of the world in
The Grim Company reminds me of the world of
The First Law/Heroes/Red Country etc., and some of the characters in
TGC have very comparable appearances/personality traits with Abercrombie's characters (i.e., Brodar Kayne is really reminiscent of Logen and Curnden Craw, the Halfmage Eremul reminds me a lot of Inquisitor Glokta, Davarus Cole is similar to Jezel dan Luthar). Plus, Luke Scull's writing style is very much in the same vein as Abercrombie and Lynch - lots of dark, gritty characters, black humor, emphasis on human failings/frailty/selfishness/greed rather than heroism, that kind of thing. That's not to take anything away from
The Grim Company - I'm about 2/3 of the way through the book, and I really like it. It's not super original, but it's done well and it's a fun read (it's also the first book in a series, so it's entirely possible that the character arcs of the guys I mentioned will change and go in completely different directions).