In 2008 Manning missed the entire preseason. He caught on fire at the mid point in the season and still finished the season with over 4k yards, and 27 TD's. But he was not in the elite 5 QB's at that time and fell below the likes of Jay Cutler and Kurt Warner. My question is where do you rank him this year with a deep pool of elite qb's? I have him ranked below: Rodgers, Brady, Vick, Rivers, Brees even Romo. Is Manning ranked at or around Matty Ice this year? What do you guys think, I may be reading into this too much.