Which players should I keep for my dynasty draft? (1 Viewer)

[wheeleke]

I play in a 12-team keeper league. We can keep anywhere from 4-6 players each year. My roster is as follows:

QB - Russell Wilson

RB - Lamar Miller, Eddie Lacy, LeGarrette Blount, Duke Johnson

WR - DeVante Parker, Kelvin Benjamin, Julian Edelman, Tyreek Hill, Marquise Lee

TE - Jimmy Graham, Jordan Reed, Hunter Henry (picked him up before season's end in hopes of unloading Reed or Graham via trade)

Which 4 to 6 players would you keep and why? Thanks!!!

 

[fightingillini]

I play in a 12-team keeper league. We can keep anywhere from 4-6 players each year. My roster is as follows:

QB - Russell Wilson

RB - Lamar Miller, Eddie Lacy, LeGarrette Blount, Duke Johnson

WR - DeVante Parker, Kelvin Benjamin, Julian Edelman, Tyreek Hill, Marquise Lee

TE - Jimmy Graham, Jordan Reed, Hunter Henry (picked him up before season's end in hopes of unloading Reed or Graham via trade)

Which 4 to 6 players would you keep and why? Thanks!!!

What are your keeper rules?  Is is 4-6 straight up or do you lose some round where they were drafted last year?  That is very important information.  Also, where do you draft in the 1st round?

 

[Gally]

Without knowing any keeper restrictions I will assume that there is no penalty or limit on the duration you can keep a player.  That being said with no other contributing information (starting requirements or scoring system)  I would keep the following (I am keeping six because I am assuming there are no restrictions or penalties so you might as well keep 6) 

Wilson - Good QB so now you don't have to worry about getting one.

Miller - solid RB2

Blount - I like him over Lacy as I think he does well with Philly

Reed - Too good when healthy not to keep

Edelmen - might as well as he should still be a solid WR2/3

Benjamin - slightly over Lacy & Hill because I think he has a higher floor 

 

[msudaisy26]

Wilson, Miller, Hill, Reed, Henry, Parker

 

[travdogg]

Reed, Hill, Wilson, Miller if there are draft pick costs for keeping more than 4, if not, add in Parker and Henry.

 

[fightingillini]

Without knowing any keeper restrictions I will assume that there is no penalty or limit on the duration you can keep a player.  That being said with no other contributing information (starting requirements or scoring system)  I would keep the following (I am keeping six because I am assuming there are no restrictions or penalties so you might as well keep 6) 

Wilson - Good QB so now you don't have to worry about getting one.

Miller - solid RB2

Blount - I like him over Lacy as I think he does well with Philly

Reed - Too good when healthy not to keep

Edelmen - might as well as he should still be a solid WR2/3

Benjamin - slightly over Lacy & Hill because I think he has a higher floor 

I agree with Gally here, but make sure you try and trade Graham and/or Henry and try to get a better WR keeper if possible.

 

[jwsbowler]

my gut...  without knowing anything (scoring, starting requirements, roster penalties)...  Wilson, Miller, Henry, Parker, Reed, Benjamin.   I would be trying to move Reed due to his injury history with another player to get a top type WR...not a bonifide #1 but a #1A-B type.  I would do the same thing with Graham also to see if I can better my keepers.  I would scour teams to see where there is a bit of concern with keepers and look to do deals that gets you the better player knowing you are going to drop a couple.

Edelman now has Cook to contend with and if Gronk is healthier, I see his numbers get cut into.  I have Parker ranked higher than Benjamin and Edelman.  I would see if someone wants to bite on Hill too.  He's too much of a gadget type player.  I see some potential type deals, but not knowing the rosters of others...  

What is the scoring, is it a PPR???  What are the starting requirements?  What are the penalties for keeping players, if any?  These answers will get you better opinions from us

 

[Pwingles]

I play in a 12-team keeper league. We can keep anywhere from 4-6 players each year. My roster is as follows:

QB - Russell Wilson

RB - Lamar Miller, Eddie Lacy, LeGarrette Blount, Duke Johnson

WR - DeVante Parker, Kelvin Benjamin, Julian Edelman, Tyreek Hill, Marquise Lee

TE - Jimmy Graham, Jordan Reed, Hunter Henry (picked him up before season's end in hopes of unloading Reed or Graham via trade)

Which 4 to 6 players would you keep and why? Thanks!!!

you could take or leave hill or miller imo

if there is a penalty to keep a player, it would greatly change my opinion

would you be charged for 4 keepers if you only kept lace and KB?