Which RB to keep? (1 Viewer)

[wlwiles]

12 team, standard scoring, 1QB 2WR 2RB 1F.  Just need to choose one of the following to keep:  

DeMarco Murray (4th round) - is it worth a 4th if Henry starts to eat into him more this yr?
Melvin Gordon (4th round) - is last year sustainable?  Will the move to LA change anything?
Paul Perkins (15th round) - would be a huge steal if he emerges this year.  But big risk of wasting a keeper if he doesn't.

Leave a link and I'll be glad to help you...
 

 

[RC94]

I would keep Gordon.  I do think he can keep it up and 4th round is good value for a player who can put up the points he can and did.  Perkins is a consideration because of the round value, but I think Gordon is the better and safer player and is also a good round value since he will probably be a 1st round pick or early 2nd round pick this year.

 

[mozzy84]

I would keep Gordon for sure, perkins has value obviously at that price but I feel a lot safer with Gordon.

 

[fightingillini]

Gordon is an easy choice.  Late 1st round value in round 4....sign me up.

 

[Gally]

I will hop on the bandwagon with another vote for Gordon.  His value is good in the 4th round and you have no trust that Perkins is going to be a starting fantasy caliber player.  The hype is there but I would rather go with a little more proven role. 

 

[wlwiles]

thanks guys for the responses.  Interesting that everyone said Gordon. I figured Murray would be a worthwhile consideration but I'm just afraid of Henry eating into his workload too much.  Thanks again!

 

[travdogg]

Last year went pretty perfect for Murray, and Gordon was still better. Now one could argue that things went perfect for Gordon too, but that is where the Henry concern comes in.

 

[blindside blitz]

I'm all in on Gordon!  Murray is getting pushed and is aging.