Which Rb to keep? (1 Viewer)

[tdr65]

Hi all 

  Our league is a ppr league fairly high scoring tooo much to list 1Qb, 2Rb, 2Wr, 1Te, K, Dst,  2 flex anything but Qb. We do a 3 year cycle 1 keeper then 2 keepers then 3 keepers and this year back down to 1 keeper.

I have to choose one

David Johnson

Alvin Kamara

Kareem Hunt

and  no I didn't win our league I didn't even make the playoffs It would seem simple choice but Johnson as good as he was had a year off,and  now is holding out and has a different offense, Kamara (who I am leaning towards) great year  hopefully no sophomore slump but losing Ingram for those first games more of a big deal than people saying? I am leery it could be. Then Mr Hunt has a new Qb  so defenses gonna stack the box  until he is proven?  I like him but he really killed me last year  in those games he disappeared in . So any thoughts or misreading on my thoughts?

thanks

 

[beerbuff]

Johnson, simply because he will be the dominant piece of the Cardinals offense. Kamara has Ingram and a good QB who likes to throw the ball to vulture his numbers and as you said Kareem has a new young QB but also one that will not be afraid to use his great receiving corp. Johnson only has an aging Fitzpatrick and a rookie WR who is playing in an unfamiliar position,  his carries/catches should easily exceed the other guys.

 

[msudaisy26]

I would go Johnson too. He has the highest ADP, and what pick do yo uhave? There is a chance you could get back one of these other guys in the draft

 

[TheKillerBrees]

DJ

(But Kamara is close)

 

[JPeso]

DJ by a hair.

 

[tdr65]

well  Johnson has Bradford, Fitzpatrick is in Tampa I get your point  i still worry with his hold out and rustiness (am thinking inj more than ability) I do pick 3rd but I am pretty sure kamara would get swiped by one of the first 2 they both were on me all year for trades with him.. will b a coin flip I think at keeper deadline.

 

[Pwingles]

I think you could make arguments for DJ or Kamara based on preference. I think I lean DJ slightly because ive seen him do it more than once, and i dont suspect his role to changge much even with the new staff.

I think some of this depends on where you are picking and who is being kept as well.

Do you have an idea of who the other keepers are and who will be available?

 

[fightingillini]

I would go with Johnson as well.  He has 1300/1000/20 TD upside.  Kamara is great, but when Ingram returns, he limit's Kamara's upside.

 

[RoninJT]

Johnson, but Kamara is worth an honorable mention.