Which WR do you like better for this year (1 Viewer)

[mr. rosewater]

If you had both, what would your strategy be? Trade one? Play matchups? Or, would one clearly be your default starter (WR3)?

Right now, I'm personally defaulting to marshall based on his YTD and his chemistry with cutler, however, I'm wondering if I'm just following early season trends too closely. Jackson certainly had a lot of promise entering the year, and is coming off his best (and only decent) week.

Your thoughts are appreciated.

 

[hbkhbk]

Marshall, and this is not even close... 3 games is more than enough to convince me (although not enough for me to start him over Evans ).

 

[FavreCo]

EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!! starts every game for me. Jackson would have to watch.

 

[Sid G]

For now I'd start Marshall regardless of matchup.

 

[mr. rosewater]

Ok, so I guess there's not much disagreement on this issue. be happy to hear from anyone who thinks differently. otherwise, thanks for the opinions guys!

 

[faux_bear]

Ok, so I guess there's not much disagreement on this issue. be happy to hear from anyone who thinks differently. otherwise, thanks for the opinions guys!

I know you want to hear from someone who thinks VJax will produce better numbers than Marshall. That wouldn't be me.

 

[mr. rosewater]

Ok, so I guess there's not much disagreement on this issue. be happy to hear from anyone who thinks differently. otherwise, thanks for the opinions guys!

I know you want to hear from someone who thinks VJax will produce better numbers than Marshall. That wouldn't be me.

actually, it makes my decision easier if there's no disagreement. thanks again for the opinions.

 

[Steeler07]

People are getting too excited about Marshall.

While he may end up with better numbers, there's no way I would make him my default starter as Jackson is starting to improve.

 

[uncleleo]

Brandon hands down!

 

[Two Deep]

From a receiving stand point I'm still unsure, in a fist fight I'll take Jackson. 6-5 241 pounds of Action Jackson.

 

[The Jerk]

People are getting too excited about Marshall.While he may end up with better numbers, there's no way I would make him my default starter as Jackson is starting to improve.

Makes a lot of sense given that Marshall is such a polished, veteran receiver with no room to improve. Marshall is 14 months younger and has one fewer year of pro experience than Jackson. I'm not sure he becomes a default starter either, but you can't help but appreciate how well he has started the season and he appears to have at least as much room to improve as Jackson.