Who is the #15 rookie in FF? (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

1. Darren McFadden, RB 69% (Stewart 25%)

2. Jonathan Stewart, RB 64% (Mendenhall 16%)

3. Rashard Mendenhall, RB 45% (Jones 40%)

4. Felix Jones, RB 65% (Rice 12%)

5. Ray Rice, RB 57% (Charles 15%)

Tie 6. Jamaal Charles, RB 31% (Smith 27%)

Kevin Smith, RB 27% (Ryan 12%)

8. Matt Ryan, QB 20% (Slaton 16%)

9. Steve Slaton, RB 16% (Kelly 14%)

10. Malcolm Kelly, WR 31% (Johnson/Brohm 12%)

11. Desean Jackson, WR 25% (Johnson 19%)

12. Brian Brohm, QB 34% (Johnson 29%)

13. Chris Johnson, RB 32% (Bowman 25%)

14. Adarius Bowman, WR 35% (Manningham 17%)

 

[loose circuits]

i'll take James Hardy's upside here, but just a tad over doucet

 

[browntown]

I like Doucet here, but not by much over Woodson or Manningham. It seems the 13-15 range is where things will start really opening up, and teams could go any number of ways. Once players get drafted though, that'll tighten back up based on draft slot much of the time.

 

[LHUCKS]

Put me in the Ray Rice is overrated camp...tia.

 

[Team Legacy]

Put me in the Ray Rice is overrated camp...tia.

Typical East vs West hate here. Break it down for me seriously. Why the hate?

 

[EBF]

This list is getting a bit stale. Time to add some more RBs and WRs into the fold.

 

[LHUCKS]

Put me in the Ray Rice is overrated camp...tia.

Typical East vs West hate here. Break it down for me seriously. Why the hate?

Mark my words, this guy will not make it in the NFL. Not enough wiggle, not enough speed and not enough burst.Chester Taylor at best...and I wouldn't touch this guy in the first two rounds where there are still potential difference makers on the board.

 

[jeter23]

This list is getting a bit stale. Time to add some more RBs and WRs into the fold.

No problem. Suggestions?

 

[EBF]

This list is getting a bit stale. Time to add some more RBs and WRs into the fold.

No problem. Suggestions?

QB Joe FlaccoQB Chad HenneRB Matt ForteWR Adrian ArringtonWR Donnie AveryWR Earl BennettWR Lavelle HawkinsWR Limas SweedWR Devin ThomasTE Fred Davis

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

I voted SuperMario, but it was bery close between he and Woodson.

 

[loose circuits]

This list is getting a bit stale. Time to add some more RBs and WRs into the fold.

No problem. Suggestions?

QB Joe FlaccoQB Chad HenneRB Matt ForteWR Adrian ArringtonWR Donnie AveryWR Earl BennettWR Lavelle HawkinsWR Limas SweedWR Devin ThomasTE Fred Davis

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

 

[EBF]

This list is getting a bit stale. Time to add some more RBs and WRs into the fold.

No problem. Suggestions?

QB Joe FlaccoQB Chad HenneRB Matt ForteWR Adrian ArringtonWR Donnie AveryWR Earl BennettWR Lavelle HawkinsWR Limas SweedWR Devin ThomasTE Fred Davis

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Wait and see.Henne and Arrington are both going to go higher than where current projections have them.

 

[jeter23]

Bump for a few more. This one is too close to call so far.

 

[LionsFan78]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

 

[loose circuits]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

 

[EBF]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

 

[jeter23]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

With all of the WRs that are closely ranked in the same tier, I would be surprised if Arrington is a 2nd rounder. I could see someone taking a chance in the 3rd, at the earliest.

 

[loose circuits]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

like I said, it will depend on the combine. However, he will have to run much better than a 4.55 in order to jump all the way into the 2nd round, that's just crazy talkshow me one site that has him in the top 10...

 

[EBF]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

like I said, it will depend on the combine. However, he will have to run much better than a 4.55 in order to jump all the way into the 2nd round, that's just crazy talkshow me one site that has him in the top 10...

Plenty of guys who ran 4.5-4.6 have been picked in the 2nd round or higher in recent years. All I can say on this one is wait and see. I think he leapfrogs a lot of the guys who the pundits have ranked ahead of him.

 

[loose circuits]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

like I said, it will depend on the combine. However, he will have to run much better than a 4.55 in order to jump all the way into the 2nd round, that's just crazy talkshow me one site that has him in the top 10...

Plenty of guys who ran 4.5-4.6 have been picked in the 2nd round or higher in recent years. All I can say on this one is wait and see. I think he leapfrogs a lot of the guys who the pundits have ranked ahead of him.

yep we will. it's too bad we can't bet play money like the other site I go to...I'll be bumping this come April

 

[MaddHatter]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

like I said, it will depend on the combine. However, he will have to run much better than a 4.55 in order to jump all the way into the 2nd round, that's just crazy talkshow me one site that has him in the top 10...

Plenty of guys who ran 4.5-4.6 have been picked in the 2nd round or higher in recent years. All I can say on this one is wait and see. I think he leapfrogs a lot of the guys who the pundits have ranked ahead of him.

yep we will. it's too bad we can't bet play money like the other site I go to...I'll be bumping this come April

Urrutia? Why? His production dropped beyond his freshman numbers? Urrutia isn't a lock to get drafted.

 

[awesomeness]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

i can understand why you think his abilities wont translate well in the NFL, but being lanky isnt a very good reason. Plaxico Burress is really lanky, that hasnt stopped him from being dominant.

 

[loose circuits]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

like I said, it will depend on the combine. However, he will have to run much better than a 4.55 in order to jump all the way into the 2nd round, that's just crazy talkshow me one site that has him in the top 10...

Plenty of guys who ran 4.5-4.6 have been picked in the 2nd round or higher in recent years. All I can say on this one is wait and see. I think he leapfrogs a lot of the guys who the pundits have ranked ahead of him.

yep we will. it's too bad we can't bet play money like the other site I go to...I'll be bumping this come April

Urrutia? Why? His production dropped beyond his freshman numbers? Urrutia isn't a lock to get drafted.

I'm not saying Urritia is getting drafted or going high or anything nor am I arguing for him to be added to the polls. I am saying I like him more than Arrington. If I am giong to go with a big possession receiver I'll take the monster with decent hops. I think he may surprise some with his speed, but you're right he may not get drafted. After seeing similar type receivers in Jarrett and M. Williams flop, the NFL may be moving back to the small shifty WR or the Dwayne Bowe prototype. Urritia reminds me of a larger Fitz whenever I saw him on the field. If he can somehow post a decent 40 in the low 4.5's he could raise eyebrows at the combine. He could be a terror in the RZ.

 

[EBF]

Arrington doesn't belong anywhere near this list. Personally I like Urritia more than him and he's even far down on the list

Care to explain your reasons for this?Arrington's flying very under the radar this year. I've watched every game he's played, and I believe him to be a very talented WR. I'm disappointed that we won't have a chance to see him as a senior, but I understand his reasons for leaving early.

I just don't think he's near as talented as a lot of the WR's still on the board. While he has decent height, he's really kinda lanky. Guess we'll have to see how he does at the combine, but if he runs a 4.55 like reported he will likely be around the 20th WR off the board.

No chance.He's a 2nd or 3rd rounder when it's all said and done. You're underestimating him and overestimating the other guys.

like I said, it will depend on the combine. However, he will have to run much better than a 4.55 in order to jump all the way into the 2nd round, that's just crazy talkshow me one site that has him in the top 10...

Plenty of guys who ran 4.5-4.6 have been picked in the 2nd round or higher in recent years. All I can say on this one is wait and see. I think he leapfrogs a lot of the guys who the pundits have ranked ahead of him.

yep we will. it's too bad we can't bet play money like the other site I go to...I'll be bumping this come April

You ever seen Arrington play? He's not a possession WR.
Pundits get their info from speculation and second hand sources. Every year brings us handfuls of guys who go much earlier than expect (Vincent Jackson, Deion Branch, Laurent Robinson, Reggie Brown, Brandon Williams, Brandon Jones, etc).

I'm sticking with my guns on this one. 2nd or 3rd round.