Who should i keep (1 Viewer)

[Cs33]

I am playing in a 10 team PPR leage.  In the league u can keep anybody that u drafted after the 3rd round and it will cost u the round u drafted them in and anybody u pick up in FA costs a 16th. I drafted Demarco Murray in the 5th and I acquired Demaryius  Thomas in FA after someone dropped him.  So i can keep Murray for a 5th or Thomas for a 16th.  What do you guys suggest?

 

[Gandalf]

I am playing in a 10 team PPR leage.  In the league u can keep anybody that u drafted after the 3rd round and it will cost u the round u drafted them in and anybody u pick up in FA costs a 16th. I drafted Demarco Murray in the 5th and I acquired Demaryius  Thomas in FA after someone dropped him.  So i can keep Murray for a 5th or Thomas for a 16th.  What do you guys suggest?

Thomas for a 16th is what I would do. Better value by far. 

Can you answer mine? Thanks!

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/758764-trade-advice/

 

[rustyman]

Demarius by far. Not even close IMO.

 

[Avery]

I'd like to know where your starting requirements and where pick in the draft but in a vacuum, I'd probably Thomas because you should be able to get a decent RB1 considering only 10 players are kept and the 5th round pick, since it's only 10 teams, seems pretty valuable.

If you could, please take a look at my dynasty trade question.  I'd love your opinion! 

 

[travdogg]

I agree Thomas in an amazing value, but I couldn't pass up an RB1 for a 5th rounder. A WR2 for a 16th is very nice, but ultimately Murray makes the team better in my opinion.