Who to take #1 Overall in Superflex (two QB) league (1 Viewer)

[rustyman]

12 Team PPR with Superflex. #1 pick - Aaron Rodgers or David Johnson

 

[Avery]

I don't play in a supeflex, so although I understand how valuable QBs are I haven't done it, but I would still think David Johnson gives you such a positional advantage over everybody else (but maybe the Bell owner) that I think you still have to go with Johnson.

Please see my dynasty trade question.  I'd love your advice! 

 

[fightingillini]

While it might be tempting to take Rodgers #1 overall, you have to take DJ at 1.  He gives you such an advantage at RB that even Rodgers at QB can't match.

At the 2/3 swing, you can go QB-QB if you have to and still get 2 decent ones.

 

[Sunny26091991]

In a two QB league i proably would take Rodgers first since he is basically his own Tier1. Usually you might say "QB´s replacability is big" but in a 12 man , 2 QB league i would consider to Rodgers > DJ 

Help me as well please: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/758735-non-ppr-3-keeper-league-help/

 

[travdogg]

I'd still take Johnson, RBs drop off so much more than QBs. 

 

[UofMAce]

I'd take Johnson as well.  Truly a game changer and potential league winner. Pickings are slim in 2 QB but I think Johnson gives you a slight advantage versus picking Rodgers. 

 

[Gally]

In a two QB league i proably would take Rodgers first since he is basically his own Tier1. Usually you might say "QB´s replacability is big" but in a 12 man , 2 QB league i would consider to Rodgers > DJ 

Help me as well please: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/758735-non-ppr-3-keeper-league-help/

I am not so sure about this statement.  Rodgers is in the top tier for sure but I wouldn't put him there by himself.  I don't think he ends up as the top QB but it could be anybody in the top 8-10 QB's (see Ryan last year).  What Rodgers does give you is consistency in that he will be top 5 almost guaranteed barring injury.

However, DJ gives you a RB1 and WR3 all rolled up into 1 player.  That is a huge advantage over everyone else.  You have to go DJ at the top of the draft.