What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Who would you keep ? Jordy Nelson, M Thomas, Ajayi (1 Viewer)

666666

Footballguy
Need to keep 2 of these also we lose the pick in the round we drafted , need to keep 2   Jordy Nelson round 10  (yea I drafted him in 10th round when he got hurt preseason a few years back)  , Micheal Thomas round 11 and J Ajayi round 9   .    Im thinking Jordy for sure and torn between Thomas or Ajayi  both I lose no real draft pick . Thanks for any opinions

 
Need to keep 2 of these also we lose the pick in the round we drafted , need to keep 2   Jordy Nelson round 10  (yea I drafted him in 10th round when he got hurt preseason a few years back)  , Micheal Thomas round 11 and J Ajayi round 9   .    Im thinking Jordy for sure and torn between Thomas or Ajayi  both I lose no real draft pick . Thanks for any opinions
All 3 are great options.  Could you trade 2 of them for a super elite player?

If not I keep Thomas and Ajayi.  Both are younger an I like having a solid RB and a good WR to start my team.

 
thanks- trading not a real option , if I get lets say L Bell then I also get his 1st round lose of pick plus this league is no fun bunch of losers who don't trade.  Thanks again for opinion 

 
Wow this is a tough decision.  All are great and you can't go wrong with any of them at this point.  What are the other keepers going to look like and where do you pick in the first round?  If the owners hoard RB's as keepers then I probably keep Ajayi for sure but if there will be plenty of talent at RB available in the first couple rounds then I would be tempted to keep the 2 WR's and target RB's early in the draft.

My decision would be based on what kind of WR vs RB talent will be available and where I could make up the shortage easier.  I would rank Thomas over Jordy (just barely due to age assuming you can keep Thomas forever at round 11).   So if you feel there will be RB talent available keep both WR's if not keep Ajayi and Thomas. 

 
All 3 are great values. I'd keep Nelson and Ajayi. In this type of league, I don't really value Thomas' youth at all. Its almost a redraft league, and its entirely possible none of these guys would be keep for you in 2018. With that in mind, I'd go with the two that I value most for 2017, and that is Nelson and Ajayi.

 
If you are able to keep players for multiple years with no penalty, I say Thomas and Ajayi are the way to go.

But have to agree with everyone else, there's no wrong answer here.

 
thanks for all the replies. ppr league. Also you can keep 2 each year and lose the round drafted in. Also you can keep a player for only 4 years.  thanks again 

 
If you can only keep a player for 4  years and you got Jordy when he was hurt I'd keep Thomas and Ajayi and get the extra year with them (assuming Ajayi was drafted last year).  Ajayi is scary though when you look at the break down of how he scored his points last year.  Just about everything came in 3 games.  Nelson and Thomas produced on a weekly basis.

 
All 3 are great values. I'd keep Nelson and Ajayi. In this type of league, I don't really value Thomas' youth at all. Its almost a redraft league, and its entirely possible none of these guys would be keep for you in 2018. With that in mind, I'd go with the two that I value most for 2017, and that is Nelson and Ajayi.
To give you an idea of how close this is, its one week later, and I'm thinking Nelson/Thomas is a better play.

 
I would keep Jordy and Ajayi. I think Jordy is a definite here. Proven commodity on a great offense. I take Ajayi slightly over Thomas just to balance the roster and start with two solid players. If your league is PPR, I wouldn't argue with Jordy/Thomas.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top