Would you trade your current NFL team's quarterback straight up for Rodgers? (1 Viewer)

[bostonfred]

KC obviously wouldn't.

I doubt Tampa would either. Seattle might consider letting Russ walk but not for an even older and more disgruntled quarterback. Steelers fans?  The last few years of Ben or the last few years of Rodgers? Falcons fans, maybe you want to lie and say you wouldn't too but come on

What about the younger guys?  Baltimore?  I doubt it.  Chargers fans?  Arizona  49ers fans would you trade those three firsts for him?  Bills fans would you sell high on Allen's big year to get the reigning MVP?  A year ago the Texans clearly wouldn't have... now the jaguars probably wouldn't.

What about Dallas and Cincinnati fans?  Would you trade your exciting young qb coming off injury? 

Jets fans would you give up 1.2 for another Brett Favre?

Browns fans you might not like that I'm lumping you in with the Giants Dolphins Titans and Raiders instead of the mighty Bengals but wouldn't you like to see Rodgers throwing to OBJ?  

Rams fans, maybe more than the Lions and Panthers, might be enamored with your new options but come on

Anyone else?

 

[Anarchy99]

Hmmm. Cam Newton or Aaron Rodgers? Tough call. 

 

[Mr. Peterson]

No.  

 

[Grigs Allmoon]

No.  

 

[dickey moe]

Rodgers for this year's 1.01 would destroy the internet. 

 

[sho nuff]

Yes...i would trade Aaron Rodgers for Aaron Rodgers.  Nobody would see it coming. 

 

[ProstheticRGK]

Philadelphia. Yes and pick #12

 

[travdogg]

As a bears fan, not only would I, I would even if it was a lock Rodgers never played a down for me.

I probably would if I were any team other than Buffalo, KC, Seattle, Tampa, and probably Jacksonville.

 

[voiceofunreason]

KC obviously wouldn't.

I doubt Tampa would either. Seattle might consider letting Russ walk but not for an even older and more disgruntled quarterback. Steelers fans?  The last few years of Ben or the last few years of Rodgers? Falcons fans, maybe you want to lie and say you wouldn't too but come on

What about the younger guys?  Baltimore?  I doubt it.  Chargers fans?  Arizona  49ers fans would you trade those three firsts for him?  Bills fans would you sell high on Allen's big year to get the reigning MVP?  A year ago the Texans clearly wouldn't have... now the jaguars probably wouldn't.

What about Dallas and Cincinnati fans?  Would you trade your exciting young qb coming off injury? 

Jets fans would you give up 1.2 for another Brett Favre?

Browns fans you might not like that I'm lumping you in with the Giants Dolphins Titans and Raiders instead of the mighty Bengals but wouldn't you like to see Rodgers throwing to OBJ?  

Rams fans, maybe more than the Lions and Panthers, might be enamored with your new options but come on

Anyone else?

Tampa Bay wouldn't? No you aren't a patriots homer at all. Get in the real world.

 

[bostonfred]

Tampa Bay wouldn't? No you aren't a patriots homer at all. Get in the real world.

The bucs explicitly brought back their entire team. You think they would trade the reigning superbowl mvp for the reigning NFL MVP?  Maybe, but none of their actions suggest they plan to change anything at all. 

 

[STEADYMOBBIN 22]

No but I admit the idea of Rodgers throwing to Dallas' group of receivers is intoxicating. 

No because of his age and his thin skin. 

 

[Deamon]

KC obviously wouldn't.

I doubt Tampa would either. Seattle might consider letting Russ walk but not for an even older and more disgruntled quarterback. Steelers fans?  The last few years of Ben or the last few years of Rodgers? Falcons fans, maybe you want to lie and say you wouldn't too but come on

What about the younger guys?  Baltimore?  I doubt it.  Chargers fans?  Arizona  49ers fans would you trade those three firsts for him?  Bills fans would you sell high on Allen's big year to get the reigning MVP?  A year ago the Texans clearly wouldn't have... now the jaguars probably wouldn't.

What about Dallas and Cincinnati fans?  Would you trade your exciting young qb coming off injury? 

Jets fans would you give up 1.2 for another Brett Favre?

Browns fans you might not like that I'm lumping you in with the Giants Dolphins Titans and Raiders instead of the mighty Bengals but wouldn't you like to see Rodgers throwing to OBJ?  

Rams fans, maybe more than the Lions and Panthers, might be enamored with your new options but come on

Anyone else?

Tampa 100% would.  Rodgers is a better quarterback than Brady, and 5 years younger.  That's a no brainer.

Seattle makes so much sense for both teams.  When do you ever get to lose a stud franchise QB and get another one in return and stay a contender?  Never.  GB might have to throw a pick in though, so I guess that wouldn't be straight up.

I think every team would except for:

KC
JAX
BUF
CIN
LAC
ARI
BAL

Some of those are maybe's but I'll put there anyways.  Every other team does it for sure.

 

[-OZ-]

Tannehill has been a nice surprise 

But yeah. Of course.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Tampa 100% would.  Rodgers is a better quarterback than Brady, and 5 years younger.  That's a no brainer.

 

Rodgers is also a moody ##### who would probably care more about getting all his money than working a deal to make sure the Bucs could bring back all those players. Yeah, Brady is old, but his teammates always love the guy; I doubt we can say that about Rodgers. The Bucs would be foolish to mess with that in 2021. 
 

That said, as a Broncos fan, I’d take him. 

 

[AAABatteries]

Falcons fans, maybe you want to lie and say you wouldn't too but come on

I would drive Ryan to GB from Atlanta every weekend they had home games for the remainder of his career.

 

[DocHolliday]

I wish the Raiders would trade Carr and a first round pick for Rodgers.  The Raiders choose second round players for their first round picks anyway.   

 

[Grahamburn]

I wish the Raiders would trade Carr and a first round pick for Rodgers.  The Raiders choose second round players for their first round picks anyway.   

The Gruden special.

 

[Desert_Power]

I wish the Raiders would trade Carr and a first round pick for Rodgers.  The Raiders choose second round players for their first round picks anyway.   

But they are grinders