What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

You Don't Know What You've Got Until You've Traded It Away (1 Viewer)

JGalligan

Footballguy
If I had to pick between my fantasy team and my two cats, I'm pretty sure I'd do everything in my power to convince the rest of my family that the cats were expendable and definitely wouldn't be able to win us money every year. Is this normal? Probably not. But do I care? Of course not. And I'm certain that none of you do either.

We play fantasy football because, as responsible, mature adults (most of us, at least), there's just some things we can't do anymore like back when we were little, young hellions. Since actually doing these things now would probably get us thrown out, fired and/or arrested, we play fantasy football. It's like our grade-school recess all over again but now with beer, big screen TV's and more cussing. For many of us, it's our only release. For others, it manages to keep us sane. For still others, it proves as a necessary stress-reliever. And for those of us with more leagues each year than we can even keep track of, essentially causing us to root for the entire National Football League offenses all at once, it's just the final step before joining a money league. Or getting a girlfriend.

Sure, the Musical Roster Spots (formerly known as Tony Cromartie's Son earlier this year) are fake, but they're not fake to me. I can't be certain, but I'm pretty sure I put more thought, time and research into who to start in my flex spot each week than the many politicians who put key policy decisions into place governing the state and nation.

Ultimately, the point I'm trying to make is that, since these teams are so important to us, unfortunately, sometimes there's a downside. Trading away a player or even failing to accept a trade only to have the player involved become the next superstar stud can literally leave you acting like the frigging Grinch for weeks on end. As such, this thread shall be dedicated to any stories of trades you've made or even trades you decided against accepting that you've regretted to-the-maximum ever since. Perhaps by making fun of ourselves we can feel somewhat better...

I'll start, obviously. Two stories:

Following Week Two of this season, one of my Uncle's (I'm in a money-league with like, half my family -- and yes, this has naturally caused many a long-lasting grudge-rift between many of us, but we always make up in the end... sometimes) sent me a trade that I literally couldn't accept fast enough. You see, my drafting strategy of stocking up on RB and WR value and taking a QBBC later on backfired completely in my face in the absolute worst-case-scenario. Since it's a 12-team league and we need to start two QB's each and every week, everyone presumably needed three QB's throughout the draft (one for the backup). That multiplies out to 36 QB's per team, and since there's only 32 teams in the league... you get the picture. Instead of realizing this beforehand and heading into the draft with a proper, simplified strategy, I was forming multi-tiered strategical plans and researching stuff like predicted targets and grouping receivers into groups of whether or not they'd receive at least 110 targets or not.

Long story short, I was stacked up the whazoo with great RB's and WR's from top-to-bottom, but unfortunately, as a result, I was stuck with the fearsome starting QB duo of... Jake Delhomme and Trent Edwards. Yes, seriously.

Anyway, heading into Week 3, Jake Delhomme had been injured for two weeks and Trent Edwards was benched after two weeks of... playing like Trent Edwards plays. I had managed to pick up Shaun Hill, thankfully, who surprisingly did a pretty decent spot-start job for me for a few weeks. Suffice it to say though, I needed a quarterback quite badly. So, the Carson Palmer and Dez Bryant for Darren McFadden and Byron Leftwich trade offer I was sent looked like a steal. The pure joy I felt at the time has only made looking back on the whole thing even worse. I wish I could go back in time and smack myself upside the head but, alas, I cannot.

As we all know, Darren McFadden has averaged 3.4 receptions (it's a PPR league), 142.7 yards from scrimmage and just under 1 TD per game (in the 7 he's played this year). :yawn:

Next on tap, and thankfully this is the only other story I have for this year, I could have gotten Peyton Hillis in a trade for Mike Incon-SIM-stent Walker back in Week 3 or so. I'd heard of him before when he was in Denver, but at the time the Browns running roster had some other mediocre talent I thought would steal carries from him. I can't think of them off-hand right now, but I'm pretty sure James Davis was one of those backs who some people were pretty high on. The fact that he was white didn't help matters, either, to be completely honest.

Of course he's obviously had an incredibly year so I've naturally regretted the trade for the last 4-5 weeks or so. However, things were taken to a new level on Sunday when Hillis decided to have his elite-fantasy-running-back breaking out party against my beloved Patriots. Precisely 220 all-purpose yards and I felt every single one of them in my gut. Two touchdowns scored Mack Truck-gracefully didn't happen matters, either. Commence the short-tempered, grumpy week!

Who else wants to make fun of themselves tell a story? :lmao:

 
In my start 2 qb league, I traded away Rivers instead of Brady after week 3.

Ouch.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
If I had to pick between my fantasy team and my two cats, I'm pretty sure I'd do everything in my power to convince the rest of my family that the cats were expendable and definitely wouldn't be able to win us money every year. Is this normal? Probably not. But do I care? Of course not. And I'm certain that none of you do either.

We play fantasy football because, as responsible, mature adults (most of us, at least), there's just some things we can't do anymore like back when we were little, young hellions. Since actually doing these things now would probably get us thrown out, fired and/or arrested, we play fantasy football. It's like our grade-school recess all over again but now with beer, big screen TV's and more cussing. For many of us, it's our only release. For others, it manages to keep us sane. For still others, it proves as a necessary stress-reliever. And for those of us with more leagues each year than we can even keep track of, essentially causing us to root for the entire National Football League offenses all at once, it's just the final step before joining a money league. Or getting a girlfriend.

Sure, the Musical Roster Spots (formerly known as Tony Cromartie's Son earlier this year) are fake, but they're not fake to me. I can't be certain, but I'm pretty sure I put more thought, time and research into who to start in my flex spot each week than the many politicians who put key policy decisions into place governing the state and nation.

Ultimately, the point I'm trying to make is that, since these teams are so important to us, unfortunately, sometimes there's a downside. Trading away a player or even failing to accept a trade only to have the player involved become the next superstar stud can literally leave you acting like the frigging Grinch for weeks on end. As such, this thread shall be dedicated to any stories of trades you've made or even trades you decided against accepting that you've regretted to-the-maximum ever since. Perhaps by making fun of ourselves we can feel somewhat better...

I'll start, obviously. Two stories:

Following Week Two of this season, one of my Uncle's (I'm in a money-league with like, half my family -- and yes, this has naturally caused many a long-lasting grudge-rift between many of us, but we always make up in the end... sometimes) sent me a trade that I literally couldn't accept fast enough. You see, my drafting strategy of stocking up on RB and WR value and taking a QBBC later on backfired completely in my face in the absolute worst-case-scenario. Since it's a 12-team league and we need to start two QB's each and every week, everyone presumably needed three QB's throughout the draft (one for the backup). That multiplies out to 36 QB's per team, and since there's only 32 teams in the league... you get the picture. Instead of realizing this beforehand and heading into the draft with a proper, simplified strategy, I was forming multi-tiered strategical plans and researching stuff like predicted targets and grouping receivers into groups of whether or not they'd receive at least 110 targets or not.

Long story short, I was stacked up the whazoo with great RB's and WR's from top-to-bottom, but unfortunately, as a result, I was stuck with the fearsome starting QB duo of... Jake Delhomme and Trent Edwards. Yes, seriously.

Anyway, heading into Week 3, Jake Delhomme had been injured for two weeks and Trent Edwards was benched after two weeks of... playing like Trent Edwards plays. I had managed to pick up Shaun Hill, thankfully, who surprisingly did a pretty decent spot-start job for me for a few weeks. Suffice it to say though, I needed a quarterback quite badly. So, the Carson Palmer and Dez Bryant for Darren McFadden and Byron Leftwich trade offer I was sent looked like a steal. The pure joy I felt at the time has only made looking back on the whole thing even worse. I wish I could go back in time and smack myself upside the head but, alas, I cannot.

As we all know, Darren McFadden has averaged 3.4 receptions (it's a PPR league), 142.7 yards from scrimmage and just under 1 TD per game (in the 7 he's played this year). :shrug:

Next on tap, and thankfully this is the only other story I have for this year, I could have gotten Peyton Hillis in a trade for Mike Incon-SIM-stent Walker back in Week 3 or so. I'd heard of him before when he was in Denver, but at the time the Browns running roster had some other mediocre talent I thought would steal carries from him. I can't think of them off-hand right now, but I'm pretty sure James Davis was one of those backs who some people were pretty high on. The fact that he was white didn't help matters, either, to be completely honest.

Of course he's obviously had an incredibly year so I've naturally regretted the trade for the last 4-5 weeks or so. However, things were taken to a new level on Sunday when Hillis decided to have his elite-fantasy-running-back breaking out party against my beloved Patriots. Precisely 220 all-purpose yards and I felt every single one of them in my gut. Two touchdowns scored Mack Truck-gracefully didn't happen matters, either. Commence the short-tempered, grumpy week!

Who else wants to make fun of themselves tell a story? :goodposting:
Yeah DMAC fooled a lot of people. Keep enjoying the game. Must be really cold where you live!
 
Got offered Hillis for Lynch right when he was traded to Seattle. Passed on it.

I did manage to get Steven Johnson and Fitz in all three of my dynasty leagues.

 
I like cashing in on waiver wire pickups that I really think have little value long term and moving them for future picks that I can toss in later to finish off future deals...so I gave up Hillis for a 3rd round rookie pick in a 12 team PPR dynasty. Now i'm hanging on for dear life to 1st place with just Mendy, Addai, and Beanie at RB.

 
Sat in front of my pc last Tuesday morning w/Jacob Tamme sitting on the FA market staring me in the face. I already had a waiver claim in L. Blount. Didn't want to risk my position on that so I left him there.

I knew he would be gone before I got home from work, but I already have V. Davis, figured I could do fine w/o him. Then find my league's leader (in record and points) grabbed him.

 
I traded Lesean McCoy for Beanie Wells early last year in my PPR dynasty. Had huge traders remorse right after I did it, still do.

 
Traded TO, Santonio, and Heath Miller for Roddy White bout a week and a half ago (during Roddy's bye week)..Since then, Roddy got knocked out of the game momentarily with a knee injury, and TO has 125yds and 3 TDs in 1.5 games, Santonio has 158 in 2 games.

Still not totally mad about it, but TO has looked almost too good to trade since then

 
I drafted Ocho and TO and wanted to move one. I thought I was trading "Robin" but I gave away Batman instead. :/

 
In my 14 team 4 player keeper league. In 2007, I drafted Aaron Rodgers and carried him on my bench all season. I can not remember who my QB1 was at the draft, but I ended up dropping him and grabbing Derek Anderson on waivers. I rode the 07 Anderson wave all the way to my only championship.

As our 2008 draft approached and I had to make a decision on my 4 keepers I kept drinking the Brown kool-aid and kept Anderson instead of Rodgers. Makes me hate myself whenever I think about it.

 
In dynasty traded away foster for a 5th after Tate was drafted. Was going to cut him because I had too much depth at RB. Yay that hurt.

 
Eve of the season opener, got offered Foster & Mason for Best. I said, nooooo....

What was I thinking?

:thumbup:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Before the season, I was offered

Arian Foster, Kenny Britt, and Sam Bradford

for

Cedric Benson, Josh Freeman, and Bernard Scott

or

Arian Foster and Kenny Britt

for

Cedric Benson and Bernard Scott

I just didn't believe in Arian Foster and thought I could get better value for a proven #2 RB. Oops. I'm not upset having Freeman instead of Bradford and I ended up dealing Benson a couple weeks ago for good value, but not THAT kind of value.

 
I feel like every move I have made this year I've gotten burned on:

Traded Drew Brees and Brandon Jackson for Pierre Thomas and Greg Jennings. Sort of a wash if Jennings keeps it up but he's hit or miss in that offense w/ all of Rodgers' turnovers.

Traded T.O. and Heath Miller for Visanthe Shiancoe and Johnny Knox.

Dropped Visanthe before this weekends game for Seyi (but I didn't start Seyi so if he isn't a good start the rest of the way I'll really be bummed because Kellen Winslow is my only TE now.)

I'm still in first place, but if I never made a move, my team would be so much stronger now.

 
If I had to pick between my fantasy team and my two cats, I'm pretty sure I'd do everything in my power to convince the rest of my family that the cats were expendable and definitely wouldn't be able to win us money every year. Is this normal? Probably not. But do I care? Of course not. And I'm certain that none of you do either.

We play fantasy football because, as responsible, mature adults (most of us, at least), there's just some things we can't do anymore like back when we were little, young hellions. Since actually doing these things now would probably get us thrown out, fired and/or arrested, we play fantasy football. It's like our grade-school recess all over again but now with beer, big screen TV's and more cussing. For many of us, it's our only release. For others, it manages to keep us sane. For still others, it proves as a necessary stress-reliever. And for those of us with more leagues each year than we can even keep track of, essentially causing us to root for the entire National Football League offenses all at once, it's just the final step before joining a money league. Or getting a girlfriend.

Sure, the Musical Roster Spots (formerly known as Tony Cromartie's Son earlier this year) are fake, but they're not fake to me. I can't be certain, but I'm pretty sure I put more thought, time and research into who to start in my flex spot each week than the many politicians who put key policy decisions into place governing the state and nation.

Ultimately, the point I'm trying to make is that, since these teams are so important to us, unfortunately, sometimes there's a downside. Trading away a player or even failing to accept a trade only to have the player involved become the next superstar stud can literally leave you acting like the frigging Grinch for weeks on end. As such, this thread shall be dedicated to any stories of trades you've made or even trades you decided against accepting that you've regretted to-the-maximum ever since. Perhaps by making fun of ourselves we can feel somewhat better...

I'll start, obviously. Two stories:

Following Week Two of this season, one of my Uncle's (I'm in a money-league with like, half my family -- and yes, this has naturally caused many a long-lasting grudge-rift between many of us, but we always make up in the end... sometimes) sent me a trade that I literally couldn't accept fast enough. You see, my drafting strategy of stocking up on RB and WR value and taking a QBBC later on backfired completely in my face in the absolute worst-case-scenario. Since it's a 12-team league and we need to start two QB's each and every week, everyone presumably needed three QB's throughout the draft (one for the backup). That multiplies out to 36 QB's per team, and since there's only 32 teams in the league... you get the picture. Instead of realizing this beforehand and heading into the draft with a proper, simplified strategy, I was forming multi-tiered strategical plans and researching stuff like predicted targets and grouping receivers into groups of whether or not they'd receive at least 110 targets or not.

Long story short, I was stacked up the whazoo with great RB's and WR's from top-to-bottom, but unfortunately, as a result, I was stuck with the fearsome starting QB duo of... Jake Delhomme and Trent Edwards. Yes, seriously.

Anyway, heading into Week 3, Jake Delhomme had been injured for two weeks and Trent Edwards was benched after two weeks of... playing like Trent Edwards plays. I had managed to pick up Shaun Hill, thankfully, who surprisingly did a pretty decent spot-start job for me for a few weeks. Suffice it to say though, I needed a quarterback quite badly. So, the Carson Palmer and Dez Bryant for Darren McFadden and Byron Leftwich trade offer I was sent looked like a steal. The pure joy I felt at the time has only made looking back on the whole thing even worse. I wish I could go back in time and smack myself upside the head but, alas, I cannot.

As we all know, Darren McFadden has averaged 3.4 receptions (it's a PPR league), 142.7 yards from scrimmage and just under 1 TD per game (in the 7 he's played this year). :sadbanana:

Next on tap, and thankfully this is the only other story I have for this year, I could have gotten Peyton Hillis in a trade for Mike Incon-SIM-stent Walker back in Week 3 or so. I'd heard of him before when he was in Denver, but at the time the Browns running roster had some other mediocre talent I thought would steal carries from him. I can't think of them off-hand right now, but I'm pretty sure James Davis was one of those backs who some people were pretty high on. The fact that he was white didn't help matters, either, to be completely honest.

Of course he's obviously had an incredibly year so I've naturally regretted the trade for the last 4-5 weeks or so. However, things were taken to a new level on Sunday when Hillis decided to have his elite-fantasy-running-back breaking out party against my beloved Patriots. Precisely 220 all-purpose yards and I felt every single one of them in my gut. Two touchdowns scored Mack Truck-gracefully didn't happen matters, either. Commence the short-tempered, grumpy week!

Who else wants to make fun of themselves tell a story? :bag:
Can you give us a brief synopsis, or is this it?

 
3 weeks ago I traded Gore and Bowe for Austin and MJD. I probably wouldn't do that again.

 
Sat in front of my pc last Tuesday morning w/Jacob Tamme sitting on the FA market staring me in the face. I already had a waiver claim in L. Blount. Didn't want to risk my position on that so I left him there. I knew he would be gone before I got home from work, but I already have V. Davis, figured I could do fine w/o him. Then find my league's leader (in record and points) grabbed him.
I can't believe I passed on Steelers for Demaryious Thomas and that I left Tamme sitting on the WW while I tried to decide which Colts to pick up and who to drop. Dumb.
 
That would be trading away LaDanian Tomlinson for Tony Romo in the week Romo broke his collarbone.

I regretted trading LT2 in that instance.

 
5th round of the draft. Had a choice between Justin Forsett and Arian Foster (this was just a week after Tate got hurt). I was more worried about Steve Slaton stealing carries then Leon Washington so I took Forsett. Foster went a couple of picks later.

I'm 3-6 and the Foster owner is leading the league in points.

 
Right after the news of Moss getting cut, I was offered MJD & Megatron for Chris Johnson & Randy Moss. I accepted.

Moss is in a good situation in TEN and should relieve the 8 in the box that Johnson has been getting. On the flip side, Megatron went to Revis Island, dropped 1 and lost his QB for the season.

pft. I think I'll be ok, but still.

 
I've traded McFadden, Hillis, and Torain all this year to try to find an elite WR2. I'm rolling okay in 2nd place with Gore, Charles, and Best (Flex). I got DJax in one of those deals who is filling in great when healthy, but i sure would like to have DMC and/or Hillis still. I lost both Romo and Stafford and could use one of them to get a top QB going forward. Captain hindsight..

 
Grimace59 said:
In dynasty traded away foster for a 5th after Tate was drafted. Was going to cut him because I had too much depth at RB. Yay that hurt.
I think I win the bad Foster trade award. Before the season started, I traded Foster for Leinart, straight up, because I needed a backup QB to Brees and had a ton of RB depth. Leinart was cut 3 weeks into the season. At least you got a 5th.
 
I traded away Arian Foster and my 2009 1st for Chris Johnson and a 2009 2nd. Wish I had that one back.

 
Traded Big Ben and Nicks for Favre and Marshall just as the Moss trade was developing and Ben was coming back. :goodposting:

 
4th round of our draft, time to pick a QB because all that's really left is Schaub, Rivers, Romo, and Eli. I narrowed it to Schaub and Rivers, and decided on Schaub only to watch Rivers slide to the last pick of round 5. Now I'm having to trade away Benson to get Matt Ryan just because I can't rely on Schaub to give me more than 6 weekly pts.

Sure wish I'd have gone with Rivers...

 
Couple weeks ago I had the chance to trade Jeremy Maclin & Ryan Mathews for T.O. & NYG DST.... I know there were reasons I turned it down, but they escape me right now.

 
Late in the pre-season..like the day after Hardesty was IR'd.... Dynasty league needing a viable RB3....was offered Steve Smith South and Jerome Harrison for Roddy White.

Didn't take too long to convince myself that Smith had a bunch of productive years left (not much of a downgrade, if any) and Harrison was touted by many as a legit RB2 (although I had never formed a clear opinion on him, a couple people I trusted had). Who the F is this Peyton Hillis character anyway!?

I'm likely to make the playoffs in that league...but I would have dominated without that trade :thumbup:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Last offseason in a dynasty. We had a rookie/FA draft. Well in that draft i picked M. Austin in the 2nd, Collie in the 3rd, and Hillis in the 5th. I had convinced myself that these guys were gonna be FF surprises. Well when cut downs came I decided to trade Collie/Miles for future 2nd. Then turned around and traded Hillis and K. Jones for a 4th. AND THAT FREAKING GUY KEPT HILLIS FOR A YEAR and is now reaping the benefits.

These trades really hurt because I'm know as the owner who keeps players well after they bust. ie I rostered J. Walker and M. Jones for 5 years.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Traded away Hillis/Harrison for Ronnie Brown the week before Hillis had his monster game @ BAL and never looked back. Figured Brown was a good buy-low with a nice schedule to end the year, but I could have really used that Hillis production since the deal.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top