If we were doing a redraft of the rookies for a dynasty league, here is what I think it would look like. In parenthesis, is the Bloom 100 post draft ranking.
1. Cam Newton(13)
2. A.J. Green (2)
3. DeMarco Murray(17)
4. Mark Ingram (1)
5. Julio Jones (3)
6. Denarius Moore (34)
7. Greg Little (6)
8. Torrey Smith (19)
9. Vincent Brown (10)
10. Kendall Hunter (11)
11. Stevan Ridley (56)
12. Andy Dalton (36)
13. Delone Carter (15)
14. Daniel Thomas (5)
15. Randall Cobb (8)
16. Shane Vereen (9)
17. Taiwan Jones (21)
18. Christian Ponder (39)
19. Bilal Powell (18)
20. Von Miller (53)
21. Jon Baldwin (16)
22. Roy Helu (50)
23. Jacquizz Rodgers (13)
24. Titus Young (31)
25. Mason Foster (37)
26. Lance Kendricks (23)
27. Jake Locker (28)
28. Alex Green (42)
29. Ryan Williams (4)
30. Colin Kaepernick (27)
31. Mikel Leshoure (7)
32. Leonard Hankerson (26)
33. Greg Salas (14)
34. Blaine Gabbert (25)
35. Julius Thomas (47)
great exercise.should be higher: salas, hankerson, rodgers (much higher), cobb, brown, dthomas
should be lower: ridley, agreen
Good stuff.Assuming dynasty, I would move Ponder up significantly and bump Hankerson. Ponder will most likely get more help next year and Hank will more than likely get a legit QB prospect to work with.
Gil Brandt over at nfl.com recently did an NFL re-draft article, not fantasy but interesting to compare with the above.
Go to link for full story.
LINK TO: Gil Brandt's 2011 NFL draft re-do article
Newton still would be top pick, but other QBs rise in re-draft
By Gil Brandt NFL.com
Senior Analyst
Published: Nov. 2, 2011 at 01:26 p.m
... 1. Carolina Panthers--Actual pick -- Cam Newton
Adjusted pick
-- Same: Newton has exceeded all expectations and should set multiple rookie passing records. With Newton at the helm, the Panthers have scored just nine fewer in points through eight games than they did all of last season.
2. Denver Broncos Actual pick -- Von Miller
Adjusted pick --
Andy Dalton: There's no doubt that Miller is a good player. He has six sacks, but the Broncos are a quarterback away from being a potential playoff team in that division. Despite being 2-5, Denver has talent and Dalton gives them a better chance to win. He's another rookie QB playing above expectations. Dalton's not flashy, but is smart and steady.
3. Buffalo Bills Actual pick -- Marcell Dareus
Adjusted pick --
Same: Dareus is the primary reason the Bills are giving up nine fewer points per game this year. At this time last year, they were 0-7 and now they're 5-2. He played really well against Washington (2.5 sacks) and is starting to assert himself in Buffalo.
4. Cincinnati Bengals Actual pick -- A.J. Green
Adjusted pick --
Same: The Bengals lost their three top receivers from last season and Green has provided a go-to option in the passing game. He has 33 receptions and five touchdowns. They have five wins already after finishing with four last year. Green and the rest of the draft class have played a major role in that accomplishment.
5. Arizona Cardinals Actual pick -- Patrick Peterson
Adjusted pick --
Christian Ponder: History says it's far easier to find a corner than a quarterback. Ponder has played really well in his two starts and his lack of arm strength would be mitigated by the fact that the Cardinals play indoors. He's very smart and recognizes things quickly. Peterson has started seven games and taken back two punts for touchdowns, but when you have continued issues under center that has to be your top priority. This also would have allowed the Cardinals to bypass the Kevin Kolb trade.
6. Atlanta Falcons Actual pick -- Julio Jones
Adjusted pick --
Same: Jones is still the guy here. You could very easily flip Green and Jones. Even though Jones has been hurt, he leads the Falcons in average yards per catch (14.3 yards). He's also a good blocker, which is important in Atlanta's run-based offense.
7. San Francisco 49ers Actual pick -- Aldon Smith
Adjusted pick --
Same: Smith is a pass rush specialist. He looks like Jevon Kearse when he came into the league and had 14.5 sacks as a rookie. If Smith was a horse, the way he runs make him look like Secretariat compared to going up against a bunch of plow horses.
8. Tennessee Titans Actual pick -- Jake Locker
Adjusted pick --
Patrick Peterson: With Matt Hasselbeck playing well and the team in the playoff race, the Titans can afford to bypass a QB for the future and go after the best player still on the board in Peterson. The LSU product is a solid corner and gives Tennessee someone to pair with Cortland Finnegan. Peterson also brings another dimension with his ability in the return game.
9. Dallas Cowboys Actual pick -- Tyron Smith
Adjusted pick --
Nate Solder: The difference is Smith will be good, but Solder is ready to play right now because he was a five-year player and has more experience. Solder's stronger and more polished.
10. Jacksonville Jaguars Actual pick -- Blaine Gabbert
Adjusted pick --
Same: He's started the bulk of their games and moved the team well at times. He's mobile and has a good arm but needs to work on accuracy. The Jaguars also have to get him some more weapons.
11. Houston Texans Actual pick -- J.J. Watt
Adjusted pick --
Von Miller: Miller falls here. It's not necessarily because of anything he's done wrong, but he's a great fit for the 3-4 in Houston as opposed to the 4-3 in Denver. He's an excellent pass rusher and can make plays after dropping back.
12. Minnesota Vikings Actual pick -- Christian Ponder
Adjusted pick --
Jake Locker: The Vikings still go with a potential QB of the future. Locker's the guy they really wanted all along and he would be playing now on a struggling team and learning on the job. No one realized he played hurt last season, which hurt his stock. Locker has good poise and arm strength.
13. Detroit Lions Actual pick -- Nick Fairley
Adjusted pick --
J.J. Watt: Watt is probably better suited for a 4-3 defense because he's a more effective rusher with his hand on the ground. He shows good effort and is one of those guys who never quits. Fairley is talented but has struggled to make an impact due to injury.
14. St. Louis Rams Actual pick -- Robert Quinn
Adjusted pick --
Adrian Clayborn: Quinn had a good game last week in the win over the Saints, but hasn't done much else. Clayborn has seven starts and is a good pass rusher (three sacks) who gives effort on every play.
15. Miami Dolphins Actual pick -- Mike Pouncey
Adjusted pick --
DeMarco Murray:While Pouncey has been good, he's a center and Miami needs someone to put some juice in the offense. Reggie Bush was supposed to be that guy, but Murray is capable of having a big game every week. Murray's not only a runner with quickness and acceleration but is also a good receiver.
16. Washington Redskins Actual pick -- Ryan Kerrigan
Adjusted pick --
Same: No need to change here. Kerrigan has seven starts playing a new position, 3-4 linebacker as opposed to defensive end. He has taken to the position naturally, making plays in space.
17. New England Patriots Actual pick -- Nate Solder
Adjusted pick --
Tyron Smith: So Solder and Smith flip positions. Smith is 20 and is going to be very good. But he lacks the strength and experience to be successful at this point. Eagles DE Jason Babin killed him last week with a few spin moves.
18. San Diego Chargers Actual pick -- Corey Liuget
Adjusted pick --
Phil Taylor: This is a breaking point as far as the talent level dropping a bit. Everybody before this point has Pro Bowl potential off what we've seen so far. The Chargers opt to go for Taylor over Liuget because he could be a nose tackle, which is a bigger priority in the 3-4. Taylor has seven starts and three sacks. He's played above expectations and is more powerful than Liuget.
19. New York Giants Actual pick -- Prince Amukamara
Adjusted pick --
Same: He's still trying to come back from a broken foot, but has the potential to be a solid starter when he gets healthy.
20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers Actual pick -- Adrian Clayborn
Adjusted pick --
Jabaal Sheard: With Clayborn already off the board, Sheard is another solid 4-3 end option. He has seven starts and gives you good effort and is an excellent pass rusher.
21. Cleveland Browns Actual pick -- Phil Taylor
Adjusted pick --
Nick Fairley: The Browns would be without their top two draft picks in this scenario. Fairley is another guy who has been limited due to injury, so I'm basing this off his play at Auburn as an inside pass rusher with good quickness.
22. Indianapolis Colts Actual pick -- Anthony Castonzo
Adjusted pick --
Same: Quarterback would have to be a consideration, but the top-tier options are all gone. Castonzo is right where he should be. He had four starts before he got hurt and played well.
23. Philadelphia Eagles Actual pick -- Danny Watkins
Adjusted pick --
Stefen Wisniewski: Wisniewski's been a big surprise. He has blocked well in both run and pass and is one of the reasons why the Raiders have the second-ranked rushing attack. He's a strong, tough football player and has more experience than Watkins.
24. New Orleans Saints Actual pick -- Cameron Jordan
Adjusted pick --
Same: He doesn't have any sacks, but has started every game for the Saints. Jordan plays on the strong side, which limits his chances to get sacks. He's been very solid vs. the run.
25. Seattle Seahawks Actual pick -- James Carpenter
Adjusted pick --
Same: He's been playing right tackle out of necessity, but his best position is probably guard. He could be moved to the interior at some point and be a Pro Bowl player.
26. Kansas City Chiefs Actual pick -- Jonathan Baldwin
Adjusted pick --
Same: He had a breakout game vs. the Chargers. His broken hand slowed him down to start the season. Baldwin's a big guy who runs good routes and has excellent speed for his size (6-foot-4, 228 pounds). He doesn't look that fast until he runs right by you. There's very little difference between Green, Jones and Baldwin.
27. Baltimore Ravens Actual pick -- Jimmy Smith
Adjusted pick --
Same: He's been hurt, but from what we saw in preseason and some limited action is a good cover corner. Smith's going to be a starter and has Pro Bowl potential.
28. New Orleans Saints Actual pick -- Mark Ingram
Adjusted pick --
Same: I almost took Stevan Ridley here. Ingram is a solid power back and a nice option on the goal line. But with little flash to his game, he will never be a star.
29. Chicago Bears Actual pick -- Gabe Carimi
Adjusted pick --
Same: Carimi has been out since Week 2. In his brief stint as a starter, he made a difference on that offensive line. He's really strong and has really good hands. He's best suited to stay at right tackle and should be a strong starter going forward.
30. New York Jets Actual pick -- Muhammad Wilkerson
Adjusted pick --
Same: He's started seven games and exceeded expectations. Wilkerson has good size and athletic ability, which should make him a viable part of that defense for years to come.
31. Pittsburgh Steelers Actual pick -- Cam Heyward
Adjusted pick --
Corey Liuget:Liuget is strong and shows flashes of being able to make big plays. Consistency in his game hasn't been there yet and that needs to improve. Heyward hasn't gotten on the field, and I like Liuget better.
32. Green Bay Packers Actual pick -- Derek Sherrod
Adjusted pick --
Danny Watkins: Sherrod has upside but doesn't have a lot of experience or strength. Watkins is a tough, hard-nose guy. See what the Eagles did against the Cowboys as proof of that.
Players dropping out of the first round
Robert Quinn (originally drafted 14th), Mike Pouncey (15th), Cam Heyward (31st), and Derek Sherrod (32nd).
Players moving into the first round
Andy Dalton (35th), DeMarco Murray (71st), Jabaal Sheard (37th), Stefen Wisniewski (48th).
-----------
Brandt wrote that on the 2nd of Nov so things have changed a bit since then but this provides a good snapshot of how some of the rookies have fared so far this season.
He may end up being more of a full time RB rather than just a 3rd down back, buy now cheap before it's too late.
