One of the few instances where I'd say the movie was better than the book.You need to study some history of the 20th century and get back to me. Might I make a recommendation? Modern Times by Paul Johnson.
One of the few instances where I'd say the movie was better than the book.You need to study some history of the 20th century and get back to me. Might I make a recommendation? Modern Times by Paul Johnson.
I think this video is well done.The race-must-be-central-to-everything school of thought has existed for a while
You're saying there's no cultural bias possible in math word problems? What about vocabulary differences for those who have only learned English recently?Yeah, anyone who thinks word problems depend on prior life experience is missing the point of math.
Also, I don't remember any word problems in geometry. Does that mean geometry doesn't require anti-racist reform?
Yes, that's what I'm saying.You're saying there's no cultural bias possible in math word problems? What about vocabulary differences for those who have only learned English recently?
I speak Spanish but I'm not a native speaker. I've also taken graduate level courses in math. I guarantee that I would preform worse on a math test in Spanish than I would in English. Heck, it might even just be in the instructions on how to answer.
or english?You're saying there's no cultural bias possible in math word problems? What about vocabulary differences for those who have only learned English recently?
I speak Spanish but I'm not a native speaker. I've also taken graduate level courses in math. I guarantee that I would preform worse on a math test in Spanish than I would in English. Heck, it might even just be in the instructions on how to answer.
Reminded me of this great quote from Bertrand RussellSometimes, tim, you'd do better with less certainty, especially when there's a primo example of it and the guy I was arguing about it with was you.
One of my heroes. For the most part I’m certain about my uncertainty.Reminded me of this great quote from Bertrand Russell
The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts.
NoOff hand...no. But can you see how cultural differences...economic differences...can lead to different questions being reacted to by different people based on the words used?
Pretty sure I just witnessed 3 years of high school track races in my son’s conference where guys who looked like college WR’s were dusting young girls. That wasn’t an anecdote.The assurances were correct and remain so. What you have here are anecdotes, so extreme that the minute they happen they get wild attention and huge backlash and a lot of play in right wing media. But are they representative of real change in our society or something to truly fear? Not even close.
The heading of the "right answer" section is actually "How can I facilitate deeper understanding?"Under the section "dismantling white supremacy in the classroom" in the toolkit.
We see white supremacy can show up in the classroom when the focus is on getting the "right" answer.
Yes they actually put "right" in quotes.
Not exactly. A disadvantaged kid might not have ever heard the word "yacht" or "fleet" before, and might spend some time or mental energy thinking about what that could mean. Whereas a kid that has a different cultural experience can synthesize the words quickly and move to abstract the math equation without spending energy wondering how to even pronounce the word, "yacht". Could make the difference in finishing the exam and not finishing the exam.Yes, that's what I'm saying.
Obviously, you need to speak English to do word problems that are in English.
But you don't need any special cultural familiarity with anything. "There are five Diana Ross albums, each containing eight songs. How many songs are on those albums in total?" "There are five fleets, each containing eight yachts. How many yachts are in those fleets in total?" "There are five splugicians, each containing eight paitoques. How many paitoques are in the splugicians in total?"
All of those are equivalent. Culture doesn't enter into it.
This is a fake and extreme example but it would be more like saying “Fatguy played nine holes and had one bogey, two double bogeys, 4 triple bogeys, and 5 quadruple bogeys. How many strokes over par was he?”All of those are equivalent. Culture doesn't enter into it.
Are there any non-fake examples along those lines? If so, I agree that they should be weeded out.This is a fake and extreme example but it would be more like saying “Fatguy played nine holes and had one bogey, two double bogeys, 4 triple bogeys, and 5 quadruple bogeys. How many strokes over par was he?”
Actually it’s the exact definition of an anecdote.Pretty sure I just witnessed 3 years of high school track races in my son’s conference where guys who looked like college WR’s were dusting young girls. That wasn’t an anecdote.
you’re right. But it really did happen!Actually it’s the exact definition of an anecdote.
And you keep discounting them as if people's REAL WORLD EXPERIENCE doesn't count. It does.Actually it’s the exact definition of an anecdote.
I think Michael from Good Times was as well.ETA2: Arnold and Willis were onto this word problem stuff more than 30 years ago:
https://youtu.be/q6eajRFCI5U
I believe you. Most anecdotes are true.you’re right. But it really did happen!
I don’t believe that a minority, no matter how small, should be discriminated against. I’m cognizant that the attempts to treat them fairly can lead to some unfair results, particularly in athletics. I’m confident there is a way around this.And you keep discounting them as if people's REAL WORLD EXPERIENCE doesn't count. It does.
For some reason, you think .0004% of the population counts but a bunch of guy son the other end of the spectrum are just anecdotes and therefore are not worthy. Makes no sense.
NO ONE - and I mean NO ONE - is saying they should be discriminated against. So you can throw that right out the window.I don’t believe that a minority, no matter how small, should be discriminated against. I’m cognizant that the attempts to treat them fairly can lead to some unfair results, particularly in athletics. I’m confident there is a way around this.
It is first mentioned exactly where I said it was.The heading of the "right answer" section is actually "How can I facilitate deeper understanding?"
The content says instead of focusing on the "'right' answer" you should focus on "Choose problems that have complex, competing, or multiple answers." and "Engage with true problem solving."
The content is suggesting to teach/grade on how students understand the processes not on getting the right answer. They are addressing the lazy teaching practices of multiple choice questions and teaching to standardized tests.
There are reasons this is included in addressing racism, but those aren't really important to be honest. I don't have any problem with the specific suggestions in this section. Math education in America leaves a lot to be desired, and the policies of Bush Jr. which over time have been stripped down, overturned and thrown in the garbage are a big reason for it.
Please explain to me how telling a biological male that he can’t compete in a sporting event against females is discrimination?I don’t believe that a minority, no matter how small, should be discriminated against. I’m cognizant that the attempts to treat them fairly can lead to some unfair results, particularly in athletics. I’m confident there is a way around this.
I don’t think it is.Please explain to me how telling a biological male that he can’t compete in a sporting event against females is discrimination?
Me tooI want transgendered people to be treated like everyone else
BTW not sure why Rufo isnt a blue check, but here is his bio.The principal of East Side Community School in New York sent white parents this "tool for action," which tells them they must become "white traitors" and then advocate for full "white abolition." This is the new language of public education.
I saw too twitter had a three year freeze that just ended on putting blue checks.Not having a blue check simply means that he has not yet provided Twitter with the information needed to verify or authenticate his account.
It's kind of a good/bad thing. I mean, a LARGE portion of American women support this trans athlete nonsense - mostly because they don't play sports so who cares, right? My wife falls into this category. Most women are at the forefront of this movement because "feelings".How empowering it must be for all these young girls who trained hard for their dreams only to be smashed by some male-bodied female.
Close. You left out a step. Roger Ailes create a network and feedback loop. Yes, someone who died 4 years ago is why all those people died last year.Second video is hilarious as currently Cuomo is blaming the rank and file workers at nursing homes in NY and Trump for all the deaths and his cover ups, and since his brother blames Hannity as the secret voice of power behind it all, it creates a Hannity is the reason everyone who died of COVID19 had to perish storyline.
Absolutely. And when these jackboots #### up and do a jig, their ### winds up on national TV. If you're ever in a confrontation, record it with an app that has automatic upload. Just click your camera and hit record. Stop the ####### steal that is daily life with the government, including encounters with the police. Yes, I used a loaded term I don't agree with for a cause I do. Record, record, record. Just like when they were recording news "reporters" without masks this summer when they'd walk around lecturing but none of the camera crew had masks on.Part of the lesson here is the modern age, you just have to assume you are always on camera, all the time. On the flip side, everyone here should Go Pro everything. In your car, on your body, in your business, everywhere. It might be the only defense you have.
The brewery had to halt service for a bit. They contacted the supervisor to clear up an issue- for on site dining they needed to have a food truck but for carry out they can make it in house (makes little sense to me but whatever.) They had outdated postings that needed to be updated. While they did that the inspector did their little hand clapping dance. Service was halted for about 1/2 hour.Absolutely. And when these jackboots #### up and do a jig, their ### winds up on national TV. If you're ever in a confrontation, record it with an app that has automatic upload. Just click your camera and hit record. Stop the ####### steal that is daily life with the government, including encounters with the police. Yes, I used a loaded term I don't agree with for a cause I do. Record, record, record. Just like when they were recording news "reporters" without masks this summer when they'd walk around lecturing but none of the camera crew had masks on.
Joyous to watch that ####.
Humble the media. Record the government.
Yes, I am. I'm saying to videotape all of these government agents, whoever they are, as they go about their duties, especially cops. It'll help clean up the problem of bad actors that had no authority to answer to previously. Do it to the media members that believe they have control of the narrative with their cameras and tape recorders. Videotape your full interviews with them so they can't take things out of context (like Hannity) and use it against you.and you’re helping.
Are you saying I’m selectively editing? Here’s the link:Yes, I am. I'm saying to videotape all of these government agents, whoever they are, as they go about their duties, especially cops. It'll help clean up the problem of bad actors that had no authority to answer to previously. Do it to the media members that believe they have control of the narrative with their cameras and tape recorders. Videotape your full interviews with them so they can't take things out of context (like Hannity) and use it against you.
I'm glad to see that you agree with me helping out. See what a selective edit can do?
No, I was saying they do and then showing what one can do with a selective edit. I wasn't accusing you at all.Are you saying I’m selectively editing? Here’s the link:
Link
This should not be a national news issue, or even a local news issue. This person could easily be the next person facing death threats from doing their job. Fox News ran with this on pretty much every show, and here you guys are outraged over it. They halted service for 20-40 minutes, and got a day worth of airtime to rile up people about covid regulations.
Yeah, let’s hold people accountable. I’m in agreement. I manage a restaurant; we get inspected. When msu hosts Michigan (normal times), I can count on the police coming through and doing a head count to make sure we’re under capacity. I can count on the health inspector coming every 6 months, and there are consequences if we aren’t doing things correctly. I have had an inspector insist that we install a new hand washing sink where none existed, and the next inspector wanted to write us up for the location of the hand washing station that the last guy wanted installed. That isn’t national news even if it’s a pain in my ###.
"Or C, take the A-train uptown."How about you, you have an example of one of these problem word problems?
Look at my link or the quote I posted- Fox absolutely misrepresented this story in it’s stupid campaign of “coronavirus is no big deal” misinformation. Forget the dancing part and look at the facts around the “closure.” They didn’t make patrons leave or shut down the restaurant, they halted service until it was cleared up (and they updated postings that were outdated, something every restaurant has to do regularly, it’s the restaurants fault here and no some overreach.) I can agree that the need for a food truck for on premises dining is stupid, and that the inspector here was enforcing that code incorrectly (or needed clarification). The whole episode lasted about 30 minutes, during that time the inspector danced a little, heaven forbid.No, I was saying they do and then showing what one can do with a selective edit. I wasn't accusing you at all.
As far as the rest goes, I'm only going by what the description was on this board. It happened to totally agree with my opinion that you should record government agents during their interactions with you, especially if there's a potential for force to be used against you or a property interest is implicated. If Fox selectively edited the information, shame on them, too. I have no way of knowing that, though. So maybe the health inspector should have recorded the recorder. Sort of dystopian, but given that our government and its agents seem to have a firm grip on dystopia, I'm willing to maybe stumble further down that path in order to prevent it.
I see. I take your word for it. I'm not trying to be adversarial at all. If Fox selectively edited, then they should be shamed for it. I'm not arguing their slant nor whether the selective edit was shoehorned into an otherwise faulty narrative.Look at my link or the quote I posted- Fox absolutely misrepresented this story in it’s stupid campaign of “coronavirus is no big deal” misinformation.
Actually this has been a thing in Seattle for a while, from 2019 - https://www.chicagotribune.com/lifestyles/sns-tns-bc-edu-math-racist-20191010-story.htmlI think this video is well done.
I also think that math is pretty much the quintessential subject that it makes no sense to racialize.
The way history is taught, I think a good case can be made that there's generally too much emphasis on Western European stuff and not enough on the rest of the world. That certainly was the case when I was in school. There's no need to frame it in terms of "white supremacy." But there's a real issue there that is ripe for addressing.
With math, though? Come on.
This goes way, way back. I remember Lani Guinier in the '90s arguing that logic and the Socratic Method was a tool of the patriarchy and law schools should abandon it, instead focusing the instruction methods on felt experiences. This is really not new, nor surprising coming from the radical left in education.Actually this has been a thing in Seattle for a while, from 2019 - https://www.chicagotribune.com/lifestyles/sns-tns-bc-edu-math-racist-20191010-story.html
This is your immediate response to GG posting this story. I’m also not trying to be confrontational here, but let’s take a look. What motive does fox have here- I think I’ve pretty clearly shown that this wasn’t a case of “inspector shuts down business and then celebrates” which is how it was portrayed all day long. Here’s the fox portrayal: LinkAbsolutely. And when these jackboots #### up and do a jig, their ### winds up on national TV. If you're ever in a confrontation, record it with an app that has automatic upload. Just click your camera and hit record. Stop the ####### steal that is daily life with the government, including encounters with the police. Yes, I used a loaded term I don't agree with for a cause I do. Record, record, record. Just like when they were recording news "reporters" without masks this summer when they'd walk around lecturing but none of the camera crew had masks on.
Joyous to watch that ####.
Humble the media. Record the government.
I cursed. I get it. I responded to Gekko at face value, assuming the story was true. None of it contradicts my ultimate point, which is to recommend that one record the media and the government whenever one has to deal with them. That Fox messed it up, is, as I keep telling you, irrelevant to how I feel about the issue, and further strengthens the point I was making about doctored media or malfeasance on the part of one of the two entities in question.This is your immediate response to GG posting this story. I’m also not trying to be confrontational here, but let’s take a look. What motive does fox have here- I think I’ve pretty clearly shown that this wasn’t a case of “inspector shuts down business and then celebrates” which is how it was portrayed all day long. Here’s the fox portrayal: Link
One last post and I’ll leave you alone- Fox did not mess it up. They didn’t make a mistake here; this was how they meant to report it.I cursed. I get it. I responded to Gekko at face value, assuming the story was true. None of it contradicts my ultimate point, which is to recommend that one record the media and the government whenever one has to deal with them. That Fox messed it up, is, as I keep telling you, irrelevant to how I feel about the issue, and further strengthens the point I was making about doctored media or malfeasance on the part of one of the two entities in question.
I understand that. They selectively edited the story to create a false impression to suit their own narrative. Got it.One last post and I’ll leave you alone- Fox did not mess it up. They didn’t make a mistake here; this was how they meant to report it.