Shadowfax
Footballguy
A problem has come up in one of my leagues.
Trade 1 - Team A proposed Ricky Williams to Team B for Calvin Johnson via website. Team B accepted.
Trade 2 - Team C proposed Boldin to Team A for Ricky. Team A and C agreed to a trade via email before Trade 1 is accepted and Team A accepted when proposed on website.
Problem is Trade 1 was accepted on website before Trade 2. Team A communicated to commish his trade preference before the commish approved.
Team A would rather have Boldin/Trade 2 and states that he should have a right to cancel before it's finalized. He argues that since it's his player, he should have had the right to choose either trade before commish approval...and that since Commish has to approve all trades before their final that technically all players are still available until commish approval.
Team B says his trade was accepted first via website and should be the final trade.
Which trade should be approved? What say you?
Trade 1 - Team A proposed Ricky Williams to Team B for Calvin Johnson via website. Team B accepted.
Trade 2 - Team C proposed Boldin to Team A for Ricky. Team A and C agreed to a trade via email before Trade 1 is accepted and Team A accepted when proposed on website.
Problem is Trade 1 was accepted on website before Trade 2. Team A communicated to commish his trade preference before the commish approved.
Team A would rather have Boldin/Trade 2 and states that he should have a right to cancel before it's finalized. He argues that since it's his player, he should have had the right to choose either trade before commish approval...and that since Commish has to approve all trades before their final that technically all players are still available until commish approval.
Team B says his trade was accepted first via website and should be the final trade.
Which trade should be approved? What say you?