I don't know if the numbers you're posting are making the case you think you're making. Typically, any pass over 15 yards is labeled "deep" in the play-by-play (iirc). By that definition, 80% of his scores are on deep passes. Also, in the two games you brought up, Smith averaged 16.1 and 17.6 ypc- again, not exactly making a compelling case that he's not just (or, at least, primarily) a deep guy when those are the best you can find.
Wow, ok, I guess my interpretation of “one-trick” was much more narrow. I suppose under your very broad definition of what is included in that one trick, Torrey Smith does qualify. For me though, I associate one-trick ponies with players relying on long bombs to generate fantasy points, an all-or-nothing proposition. It didn’t occur to me to that to you, a one-trick play might include 15 yard strikes.Players popularly referred to as one-trick ponies here have been Desean Jackson and Mike Wallace (and more recently, Josh Gordon) - Not that I agree with the designation (in case the Josh Gordon police are watching).Desean’s TDs in 2009 (when the designation really flourished) were 85, 71, 64, 67, 57, 54, 48, 35, 72, 60, 19, 2. Now that is indicative (but not necessarily conclusive) of a one-trick pony. Mike Wallace’s TDs in 2010 and 2009 (when his designation came about) were 47, 40 24, 60, 19, 54, 46, 41, 29, 53, 39, 15, 33, 52, 43, 56. Not as severe as Desean, but still much deeper TDs as a whole than Torrey’s in 2012. Josh Gordon’ TDs, 62, 20, 71, 33, 44. Again, much more indicative of a one-trick pony than Torrey. Take some other players being discussed here:Cecil Shorts 39, 80, 42, 4, 67, 59, 5Pierre Garcon (last 2 years) 87, 59, 6, 67, 33, 12, 88, 59, 8, 11All of these TD lines look, to me, a lot more one-trick than Torrey’s 25, 5, 18, 19, 19, 47, 20, 6, 59, 32 (which to me, doesn’t look anything like a one-trick at all). Again, I am not saying any of these players are “one-trick ponies”. By your very broad definition, even Vincent Jackson’s 29, 7, 19, 17, 17, 20, 24, 13 (fairly pedestrian TDs as a whole to me) looks awfully “one-trick”. Clearly, people can look at the same numbers and conclude two very different things.