Warrior
Footballguy
Just going through some of the redraft rankings, I have to really question the legitimacy of a few staffers' rankings. For the record, overall I think they're great. And most of the FBGs obviously really know their stuff. But there are a couple that I just can't get over.
One in particular has James Jones ranked higher in PPR than Jordy Nelson and Montee Ball. In fact, both of those two aren't even in his overall top 60. The one that put me over the edge was the ranking of Logan Paulsen over Rob Gronkowski. Those are just a few examples.
My question is this...does anyone on the staff look at the results of these rankings year over year and judge performance, then decide whether or not certain staffers even deserve to be included? I know subscribers can filter them in whatever way we choose, but seriously? What value is added when equal default weighting is given to a staffer that really puts forth effort in their rankings and a guy who is advocating that you place a higher value on James Jones and Fred Jackson than Montee Ball and Jordy Nelson? To me, it really dilutes the value of the collective FBG "expert" rankings.
Seriously...Logan Paulsen over Gronk.
One in particular has James Jones ranked higher in PPR than Jordy Nelson and Montee Ball. In fact, both of those two aren't even in his overall top 60. The one that put me over the edge was the ranking of Logan Paulsen over Rob Gronkowski. Those are just a few examples.
My question is this...does anyone on the staff look at the results of these rankings year over year and judge performance, then decide whether or not certain staffers even deserve to be included? I know subscribers can filter them in whatever way we choose, but seriously? What value is added when equal default weighting is given to a staffer that really puts forth effort in their rankings and a guy who is advocating that you place a higher value on James Jones and Fred Jackson than Montee Ball and Jordy Nelson? To me, it really dilutes the value of the collective FBG "expert" rankings.
Seriously...Logan Paulsen over Gronk.
Last edited by a moderator: