Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
I like the deal but not nearly as much as some of the other replies. RB-biased league though. I have Etienne as my 3rd RB and if I were made the offer, I would be on the fence.
This league also values the RB really high and it's taken some work for me to field a good RB group because they get gobbled up in the rookie drafts and my teams highest rookie pick in 12 years, except if acquired by trade, has been 1.8. This is how Trey Sermon mistakes happen, when I don't practice what I preach, don't take BPA.
That's a bit extreme. As far as I know no one has an issue with the trade. Not a single comment.
I think what eighsee was saying is that ETN is his RB3 on that team. He's probably not in many people's top 5, probably in a decent amount of people's top 10 though.
Yeah I feel ya. But still, after I really thought about it, you just can't turn that down. Makes me wonder if I should throw that offer out to the 1.01 guy in our league ......
That's correct, thanks. It was a bit unclear how I stated it. He's my third (dynasty-wise) behind Bijan and Gibbs. But overall I'd probably call him the 6th-8th dynasty RB.
Back in the day when CEH had back to back 20+ point games, someone offered me my own 1st round pick for him, and I jumped on it. Then proceeded to deal away all of my older players to soft-tank.
| Team A gave up Rice, Rashee KCC WR Team B gave up Year 2024 Draft Pick 2.10; Year 2024 Draft Pick 4.01 |
Sold low. (As I also said in the Rice thread
)
Ray Rice? Otherwise, this is terrible.
The 1.11 is going to get Adonai Mitchell or Xavier Legette. Seems like a fair trade considering the risks. The trade listed above where Rice went for the 1.7 is better for the pick side. At the 1.7 you are looking at Brian Thomas or Xavier Worthy. Both have a chance to be elite.
That’s a lot for Barkley, but I get it.
Good buy low. Even if he misses time that’s great value considering.
That's crazy, I honestly could not have even brought myself to make that offer.
Another good low buy on the dip. I might spend some of my morning checking with the Rice shareholders in my leagues.Sold low. (As I also said in the Rice thread
I think it's fine.
Yeah, I agree. I’m not saying he overpaid
I've only seen 3 trades. 1.7, 1.11 and this one.
I don't like giving that up for Barkley at all.
Yeah, not technically a roster clogger since the upside is there, but if he gets more than the 8 games that I’d expect, he’d be a challenge in short bench leagues.
Agree completely with this.
A lot depends on what the NFL will do to him.
I saw your trade post and scanned my rosters for the Rice owners. Almost all my leagues I got enough of a familiarity with the owners to know they'd want no part of that kind of offer.
I would say even a full year would make this a little more challenging in terms of potential outcomes.
Any shark will take a wait & see approach to this situation.
Turned around and paired Kyren and Nico Collins for 1.01. Slight overpay but I’m not competing just yet so Kyren was a must sell for me this off season
Following up on these comments. In another league I offered multiple 2nds (don't have a late first in this league) and was countered with 1.04 for Rice. That could have been pre-accident Rice price, but current has to be lower- maybe not multiple 2nds, but something.
Yep, free move up!
I'm in mainly TE-P, one start QB, FFPC format leagues and I saw him before this incident exactly the same. Would have put him between 3-5, with a slight lean at 5 subject to were Odunze and Bowers go. He would be part of the Big 5.
Could go either way? I guess in the off chance he’s suspended indefinitely.
