I don't think people are whining per se...everyone seems fairly thankful that he got us some fantasy points finally
Wasn't encouraging that it all came in garbage time though
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
RB Jahmyr Gibbs, DET (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Faust
- Start date
I don't think people are whining per se...everyone seems fairly thankful that he got us some fantasy points finally
Wasn't encouraging that it all came in garbage time though
Leroy Hoard
Footballguy
Have you been reading the same thread I have?
GibbsFreeEnergy
Footballguy
Probably because this is the most touches he’ll have all season and did very little points/touch wise in std scoring
SproutDaddy
Footballguy
Name a single Detroit player who did please. You’re simply not proving anything. By all means continue though……
Well it was the 'still' part.
Yes he got some garbage time stats today which is great but for those that took him high (and let's face it that's everyone) it has been a very disappointing half season
SproutDaddy
Footballguy
As if they’ve never been appreciative for the numerous times they’ve gotten garbage points.
SproutDaddy
Footballguy
I got him in the 5th. Your argument is invalid. Not surprised.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
When did he accumulate all these numbers?
It was 28-0 1st Half
Keep this 100% on the players and not shots at each other.
SproutDaddy
Footballguy
My comment was on the player and the analysis that followed. This isn’t surprising either. I’ll back away from the typical moderation.
Keep this 100% on the players and not shots at each other.
Leroy Hoard
Footballguy
Since when are fantasy points dependent on time of game? Isn't part of a fantasy player's value in having value in various situations?
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
Do you think Dan Campbell is wanting to get Gibbs more touches after a 38-6 result?
What were the results when Monty was the starter? Did Detroit have a winning record?
Not sure what else to tell you. Keep this 100% on the players and not shots at each other.
I don't think there is any doubt this is Monty's backfield. I'm not sure most people would argue. he's very effective and he does what Campbell wants out of a RB. We are almost half way through the season now as well so he's solidified
Chaka
Footballguy
What kind of league do you play in where 126 yards and a TD constitutes "very little".
I mean is "points per touch" really the argument?
Oh, I don't disagree with you at all.
Campbell can't wait to get Montgomery back without doubt.
I own Monty AND Gibbs. So again, I'm happy Gibbs could step in and produce. I fully expect things to revert back to the way they were with Monty carrying the load
SproutDaddy
Footballguy
So I can only simply ask 1 question. Why are you upset for drafting him when you did? That’s on those who did knowing he was in a timeshare from the get go…..and that he’s a rookie. You say im polluting a thread when I’m actually adding objective commentary many don’t want to hear. I don’t blame others for my drafting decisions.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
11/68/TD
9/58...
In a 38-6 blowout to the Baltimore Ravens
And FF folks are dancing tonight?
SELL HIGH SELL HIGH SELL HIGH
Cannot stress it enough right now
Such a bad taste in my mouth Redraft '23
Shocked he even hit the stat sheet with the way this game started
9/58...
In a 38-6 blowout to the Baltimore Ravens
And FF folks are dancing tonight?
SELL HIGH SELL HIGH SELL HIGH
Cannot stress it enough right now
Such a bad taste in my mouth Redraft '23
Shocked he even hit the stat sheet with the way this game started
Last edited:
leftcoastheel
Footballguy
Lol this thread is hot as hell. Let’s all be happy he had a game.
Yeah I'm not understanding the tone here.
Think there were owners wondering if he'd ever cross the 10 pt threshold.
He had a great PPR performance.
DET had a terrible team performance.
I'm sure things will balance out a bit after Campbell lays into them this week.
And oh, DET faces the LV D next week that just made D. Foreman look like Jim Brown. I hope Monty is back next week so he AND Gibbs can both eat and DET win by 30.
Think there were owners wondering if he'd ever cross the 10 pt threshold.
He had a great PPR performance.
DET had a terrible team performance.
I'm sure things will balance out a bit after Campbell lays into them this week.
And oh, DET faces the LV D next week that just made D. Foreman look like Jim Brown. I hope Monty is back next week so he AND Gibbs can both eat and DET win by 30.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
Rather than get offended and lose your footing, let me help
You aren't being real that the Lions lost 38-6
Dan Campbell don't give a bleep about Gibbs in a 38-6 drubbing
All that man cares about right now is when he gets Monty BACK!!! (Monty wins)
Not when can he draw up some more plays for Gibbs but you believe whatever you want
-And don't get mad, it's not personal, you might be with that last comment/post but i'm not
Lions lose 38-6
it's just not a good time to think Gibbs is going to see a lot more touches IMHO, now if the Lions had won the game and Gibbs was a big part of the victory...but that's not the story
Monty has the ball whenever he returns, so says MoP
Last edited:
smcindoe
Footballguy
Teach me.
Da Guru
Fair & Balanced
They were all garbage stats but when any team is down 28-0 in the third quarter garbage points pile up for FF players on the losing team.
Nobody disagrees with that...i just don't think the garbage stats do anything to dislodge Montgomery taking 75% of the snaps
Sunday Gravy
Footballguy
Ha. Yeah this would've been a totally different outcome with D Mont.
FarFromHome
Footballguy
First game back after missing a few. I would be thrilled if I had any shares. Lions played horrible yet he still made plays.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
Not what I'm saying
-Tell me what Dan Campbell is thinking tonight, please.
I have Gibbs in many leagues, not impressed today at all despite a decent box score
What were Gibbs' stats when it was 28-0? Curious how folks really feel
I get what your saying....great for FF if you have him but he doesn't move the dial at all at being a capable back the lions can lean on
We tried asking nice. Be more cool if you come back.
Da Guru
Fair & Balanced
Agree with that. They missed Monty today but the way the defense played it would not have mattered.
Gibby will be OK but still don`t really see the "electricity" yet. Maybe I was just expecting too much. I was thinking Thurman Thomas type of production.
Chaka
Footballguy
0-7 before the Lions got the ball.
1st drive 1 carry for 4. Incompletion to William. Sack. Punt.
Next drive 0-14
Gibbs for 2 yards. Reynolds for 4 yards. Incompletion to LaPorta. Punt
Next drive 0-21
Gibbs for 4 yards. Sack. Incompletion to LaPorta. Punt.
Next drive 0-28
Settle down MoP.
ETA: Said with love.
Sunday Gravy
Footballguy
I'm sure he's thinking what he's been thinking all season. They love Gibbs, they drafted him for a reason, they believe he can help them win games, they need to use him properly.
Rookiefever
Footballguy
Gibbs had a decently productive day with a quite a few touches and that was nice to see. I don’t think he has earned goffs trust yet. I know he was involved early on the first 3 or 4 drives but Goff doesn’t seem to look his way much at all and I’m assuming he was his first read or designed target on them early passes his way. Gibbs sure is fast and evasive but I just don’t think he’s an “alpha” out there.
Theres was a lot wrong with todays game for the lions. Not much of that is going to fall on gibbs imo. Goff definitely looks more comfortable with dmo and he evidently trusts him more than gibbs. Maybe Goff seen what he needed to with them garbage time touches gibbs had. Something just doesn’t click between those two and that impacts gibbs future production in a big way imo. I don’t expect any more blow out games like this one so I doubt the garbage time touches are coming back. Just my two cents…
Theres was a lot wrong with todays game for the lions. Not much of that is going to fall on gibbs imo. Goff definitely looks more comfortable with dmo and he evidently trusts him more than gibbs. Maybe Goff seen what he needed to with them garbage time touches gibbs had. Something just doesn’t click between those two and that impacts gibbs future production in a big way imo. I don’t expect any more blow out games like this one so I doubt the garbage time touches are coming back. Just my two cents…
Alex P Keaton
Footballguy
Shame on Gibbs for giving up all those TDs and letting the team get down 28-0.
Montgomery would’ve had like 4 sacks and a forced fumble.Shame on Gibbs for giving up all those TDs and letting the team get down 28-0.
Smack Tripper
Footballguy
Did watch the second half, did they find something here?
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
Great login/handle if you have been reading my posts of late.
Appreciate the feedback and analysis
Rookiefever
Footballguy
Lol who doesn’t love rookies , right? Anyways. It’s tough for me to stake a claim on gibbs future in the nfl. I really liked gibbs college. Like a lot a lot ! I think he may be a decent buy this off season if he doesn’t have any blow up games with dmo back. He’s talented but he definitely has to grow into an nfl player. I’m sure with his draft capitol and talent level he’ll get the chance.
Biabreakable
Footballguy
Even Thurman Thomas didnt have a great rookie year. I had him then and Riddick got almost all the TDs his rookie season.
Biabreakable
Footballguy
I dont think we got your point yet MOP.
Maybe if you repeat it a dozen more times it will sink in.
Smack Tripper
Footballguy
For those that watched, do we think anything was unlocked in usage yesterday
I didn't expect a beast year, I hoped for a little better Deandre swift in detroit, the line yesterday reads like that but anyone who watched have thoughts
I guess ulitamtely as some in this thread have said, my misplaced calculus was Detroit being in better game scripts this year, where garbage time catchup like yesterday is much more rare
I didn't expect a beast year, I hoped for a little better Deandre swift in detroit, the line yesterday reads like that but anyone who watched have thoughts
I guess ulitamtely as some in this thread have said, my misplaced calculus was Detroit being in better game scripts this year, where garbage time catchup like yesterday is much more rare
Blick
Footballguy
I don't think you can take anything from yesterday's game.
In the second half, once the game was out of hand, they looked like they were actively trying to give their two highly drafted rookies some extra opportunities to get them more integrated into the offense. Gibbs took those opportunities and looked good with them, so I'd expect that he earned some trust and will get more opportunities going forward. JaMo, less so.
Smack Tripper
Footballguy
Thats the best I can hope for in this situation
OU#1
Footballguy
When Monty is back he will be a CoP and spell him for breathers.
This won’t be a RBBC folks and Monty being injured is the only reason why he got increased touches.
Booger McFarland on NFL Primetime even commented how the Lions identity had changed without Monty, how the Head Coach missed him, and how they had to put too much on Goff without Monty.
I know it’s a tough pill to swallow but that seems to be the reality here and this aligns with the season thus far.
Gibbs had a great game and he has shown he can produce in fantasy when Monty misses time. That’s more than he did last time when Monty missed a game, so Gibbs owners should be happy with that.
Perhaps he earned a few more touches but he’s still just a CoP and backup at best unless Monty goes down. If you can’t see that then you’re just biased based on overdrafting and/or owning him.
Sorry guys that seems to be the reality here…
This won’t be a RBBC folks and Monty being injured is the only reason why he got increased touches.
Booger McFarland on NFL Primetime even commented how the Lions identity had changed without Monty, how the Head Coach missed him, and how they had to put too much on Goff without Monty.
I know it’s a tough pill to swallow but that seems to be the reality here and this aligns with the season thus far.
Gibbs had a great game and he has shown he can produce in fantasy when Monty misses time. That’s more than he did last time when Monty missed a game, so Gibbs owners should be happy with that.
Perhaps he earned a few more touches but he’s still just a CoP and backup at best unless Monty goes down. If you can’t see that then you’re just biased based on overdrafting and/or owning him.
Sorry guys that seems to be the reality here…
