What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

TSN ranks all players by position (1 Viewer)

jwvdcw

Footballguy
Didn't see anything about this on the front page.

Go to yahoo's sports page for links to all of this: http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/news?slug=05ts...v=tsn&type=lgns

NO. 1 PEYTON MANNING (Indianapolis Colts)

Strengths: Is one of the smartest players in the league. Has excellent instincts and feel for the game. Sees the entire field, knows when to audible out of bad plays and runs the Colts' offense with precision. Commands the respect of his teammates. Is an excellent technician who can make all the throws and is the best play-action quarterback in the game. Shows great release quickness, accuracy and touch to all levels. Can fit the ball into tight spots and excels at hitting receivers in stride.

Weaknesses: Is not a great athlete. Sometimes forces the ball into tight coverage and has trouble finding passing lanes.

Bottom line: Manning is one of the best to play the game. He is a smart playmaker who still has the work ethic to improve. The only thing missing from his resume is a Super Bowl ring. Grade: 9.6

NO. 2 TOM BRADY (New England Patriots)

Strengths: Has outstanding mechanics and off-the-charts football intelligence. Processes information quickly and regularly finds his second, third and fourth options. Audibles effectively and handles pressure phenomenally well. Has underrated size, athleticism and arm strength. Puts zip on the deep out. Has a picture-perfect high release, excellent quickness setting up and quick feet. Can make all the throws. Has superb accuracy, usually hits receivers in stride and shows a deft touch on shorter throws. Is an exceptional ballhandler and play-fake artist. Rarely carries a mistake over to the next play.

Weaknesses: Isn't much of a scrambler. Gambles once in a while but normally isn't careless with the ball.

Bottom line: Brady is an unrivaled caretaker quarterback, and though he doesn't have to carry New England's offense, he can when necessary. He never seems to face a situation or defense for which he isn't prepared. Grade: 9.5

NO. 3 DAUNTE CULPEPPER (Minnesota Vikings)

Strengths: Has a massive frame, is mobile and has rare arm strength. Is exceptionally fast for his size, is elusive in space and will break tackles. Can fit the ball into tight spots and puts zip on the deep out. Has a quick release and shows improved touch and timing. Is intelligent, well-prepared and adeptly reads defenses and makes pre-snap adjustments. Throws well on the run. Is strong and doesn't go down easily. Shows ball skills and sells his play fakes.

Weaknesses: Can be erratic in his delivery and technique. Occasionally throws off his back foot. Doesn't always hit receivers in stride. Lacks great initial quickness and change-of-direction skills.

Bottom line: Culpepper seems to get better each season and has emerged as an elite playmaker. Although he will miss Randy Moss' explosiveness, Culpepper's ability stands on its own. Grade: 9.1

NO. 4 DONOVAN MCNABB (Philadelphia Eagles)

Strengths: Has great size and strength. Has excellent vision, feels the pocket closing and makes smart decisions about when to run. Is difficult to bring down in the open field because of his physical makeup. Has superb arm strength and good touch. Throws well when rolling to the right or left and throws a great deep ball. Regularly finds secondary receivers and is a consummate leader.

Weaknesses: Has average mechanics and technique. Accuracy still is a concern. Tends to be streaky.

Bottom line: The biggest factor in McNabb's rise to an elite level has been his improved decision-makinghe does a much better job with pre-snap reads and rarely makes mental errors during a play. Grade: 9.0

NO. 5 BRETT FAVRE (Green Bay Packers)

Strengths: Has great arm strength and can make all the throws. Puts excellent velocity on the ball when throwing on the run or across his body. Plays hurt and suffers no drop-off in production. Makes great pre-snap reads, excels at working through his progressions and can sense the blitz. Releases quickly and is accurate in most situations. Has great pocket presence and buys time with his footwork. Has excellent playmaking ability.

Weaknesses: Can be overconfident in his ability. Forces some throws and puts the ball up for grabs. Gets hot and cold. Can run a little but has lost some foot speed.

Bottom line: Favre is a consummate leader who relies on his wits more because his natural abilities are in decline. Grade: 8.4

Also: NO. 6 MICHAEL VICK, Atlanta Falcons; NO. 7 AARON BROOKS, New Orleans Saints; NO. 8 STEVE MCNAIR, Tennessee Titans; NO. 9 TRENT GREEN, Kansas City Chiefs; NO. 10 JAKE DELHOMME, Carolina Panthers

NO. 1 LADAINIAN TOMLINSON (San Diego Chargers)

Strengths: Is highly skilled but is just as valued for his character, leadership and drive. Shows remarkable body control and balance. Runs with speed, quickness and determination. Has rare vision, instincts and toughness. Is patient, allows holes to develop and makes exceptional use of his blockers. Changes speeds and sets up defenders. Is one of the league's best pass-catching backs. Runs sharp routes on all three levels and catches the ball away from his body. Keeps his feet in pass protection and will finish off blitzers.

Weaknesses: Lacks elite speed. Is durable but is starting to show some wear and tear and won't hold up over time without more relief.

Bottom line: Tomlinson is a workhorse who can take the ball 30 times a game, grind out tough yards and provide big plays as a runner and receiver. He is the game's best and most complete back. Grade: 9.6

NO. 2 SHAUN ALEXANDER (Seattle Seahawks)

Strengths: Is a big, physical straight-line back who runs with toughness, nice body lean and excellent leg drive. Shows initial quickness and second-gear speed. Has the burst to bounce runs outside and can exploit cutback lanes. Reads blocks well, makes quick decisions and wastes little motion. Has much-improved vision and decisiveness. Has reliable hands and has some big-play receiving ability. Can bowl over defensive backs. Gives a solid blocking effort and has the size to anchor. Has solid durability and stamina and can wear down defenses.

Weaknesses: Is fumble-prone. Doesn't change directions quickly and lacks elusiveness. Loses effectiveness attacking the perimeter. Needs a seam and won't often create on his own. Lacks recognition skills, sophisticated route-running ability and awareness against zone coverage. Doesn't show great body control as a receiver.

Bottom line: Alexander isn't an ideal fit for a West Coast scheme, but he is a top-notch pure runner and has developed into an adequate receiver. Grade: 9.2

NO. 3 JAMAL LEWIS (Baltimore Ravens)

Strengths: Has an exceptional combination of size, strength, speed and quickness. Takes a lot of hits but runs with exceptional balance and body control. Is a physical tackle-to-tackle runner who consistently breaks tackles and gets yards after contact. Is one of the best in the league at keeping his feet moving after initial contact and rarely loses yards.

Weaknesses: Is an average receiver without great ability to adjust and a marginal blocker who will miss assignments in pass protection. Has struggled with fumbles in the past.

Bottom line: Lewis has battled injuries and off-the-field problemshe was suspended for four games last yearbut he possesses rare ability to bolt for a big gain and to wear down defenses with his north-south running style. Grade: 9.0

NO. 4 EDGERRIN JAMES (Indianapolis Colts)

Strengths: Shows patience and excellent vision. Can pound the ball between the tackles and still has the speed to bounce outside. Runs with a great base and tremendous balance. Is a reliable receiver and an underrated blocker who does a great job of picking up the blitz.

Weaknesses: Durability is a major concern. Has lost speed, burst and explosiveness. Hesitates when making sharp cuts and lacks his once phenomenal agility and elusiveness.

Bottom line: James showed last season that he still is an elite player. Much of what the Colts do on offense is based around Peyton Manning's play fakes to James and James' ability to produce on the team's signature stretch play. Grade: 9.0

NO. 5 PRIEST HOLMES (Kansas City Chiefs)

Strengths: Has rare intangibles, plus excellent quickness, vision and lateral running skills. Has a rare ability to make defenders miss; can stop and start with no wasted motion. Is an outstanding inside-out runner who can bounce the ball to the edge quickly. Has excellent hands and is a superb route runner who consistently beats linebackers trying to cover him man-to-man. Is excellent after the catch; has deceptive ability to bounce off contact and runs with outstanding balance and body control. Is phenomenal inside the red zone. Sets up screens and blocks well and can make himself small and hide behind his massive offensive line. Is solid in pass protection and has great blitz awareness.

Weaknesses: Lacks top-end speed. Suffered a right knee injury and missed the last eight games in 2004. His injury history dates to college, and because he carries the ball so much, his durability is a big concern.

Bottom line: Holmes won't take the ball and consistently turn the corner off-tackle, but if healthy, he should bounce back in a big way and deliver great production. Grade: 8.9

Also: NO. 6 CLINTON PORTIS, Washington Redskins; NO. 7 DEUCE MCALLISTER, New Orleans Saints; NO. 8 AHMAN GREEN, Green Bay Packers; NO. 9 CURTIS MARTIN, New York Jets; NO. 10 COREY DILLON, New England Patriots

NO. 1 FRED BEASLEY (San Francisco 49ers)

Strengths: Has solid power as a straight-ahead runner, can get tough yards and can catch on screens and swing passes. Shows awareness and is dependable in run and pass blocking. Won't make many defenders miss but is great at lowering his pads and delivering a blow. Shows some ability picking up the blitz.

Weaknesses: Is better as a run blocker than in pass protection and at times does not front-up defenders.

Bottom line: Beasley is a solid starter whose strength is as a lead blocker in two-back sets. Grade: 7.5

NO. 2 WILLIAM HENDERSON (Green Bay Packers)

Strengths: Has great lower-body strength. Drives his legs, gets movement and is a great finisher. Maintains a strong base and blocks with leverage. Gets solid knee bend and delivers a blow in pass protection. Still runs with solid power. Has soft hands and will recognize zone or man coverage.

Weaknesses: Is aging and starting to slow down. Has lost some quickness and agility as a blocker and ballcarrier.

Bottom line: Henderson leads by example with his preparation and determination. He remains a solid lead blocker. Grade: 7.2

NO. 3 JERALD SOWELL (New York Jets)

Strengths: Blocks well in space and misses few blocking assignments. Can line up all over the field. Takes impressive angles as a blocker and has balance and leverage at the point of attack. Is excellent at finding soft spots in zones and has an uncanny ability to get open.

Weaknesses: Lacks ideal speed and elusiveness. Is not a threat after the catch.

Bottom line: Few fullbacks can match Sowell's excellence as an underneath receiver. Grade: 7.2

NO. 4 TERRELLE SMITH (Cleveland Browns)

Strengths: Is well-built and excellent on isolation runs. Delivers a big blow at the point of attack when the linebacker fills the hole. Can adjust his angles on the move. Is solid in pass protection and can anchor and take on blitzing linebackers. Gives quarterbacks the extra second to dump the ball. Can be effective as a short-yardage runner.

Weaknesses: Doesn't get many touches and is adequate in the passing game. Lacks the speed to break a long run when he gets a seam.

Bottom line: An excellent leader, Smith just wants to block, which is what he does best. Grade: 7.2

NO. 5 JUSTIN GRIFFITH (Atlanta Falcons)

Strengths: Plays with a wide base, shows nice balance and sustains blocks. Is aggressive, shows solid quickness and wastes little motion. Runs with power and shows decent instincts and cutback vision. Sells play-action and won't drop many passes.

Weaknesses: Doesn't have the bulk to engulf or wear down defenders. Lacks ideal lower-body strength and won't always push the pile. Occasionally takes false steps. Lacks a second gear, elusiveness and home run speed.

Bottom line: Griffith isn't dominant in any area and is only an average lead blocker, but his versatility and relentless style make him a quality starter. Grade: 7.1

Also: NO. 6 JEREMI JOHNSON, Cincinnati Bengals; NO. 7 LORENZO NEAL, San Diego Chargers; NO. 8 MIKE ALSTOTT, Tampa Bay Buccaneers; NO. 9 BRAD HOOVER, Carolina Panthers; NO. 10 DARIAN BARNES, Dallas Cowboys

NO. 1 RANDY MOSS (Oakland Raiders)

Strengths: Has a rare combination of size, explosiveness and athleticism. Possesses top-end speed, tracks the ball well and is a lethal vertical threat. Dominates jump balls because of his size, leaping ability and timing. Has body control and can adjust to throws outside his frame. Reads defenses fairly well and usually locates soft spots against zone coverage. Can shield defenders from the ball; his big hands help him make tough catches in traffic. Has dangerous speed and some elusiveness after the catch.

Weaknesses: Will run half-hearted routes, especially when he isn't the primary receiver. Lacks elite initial quickness, doesn't always use his hands well and has some trouble against press coverage. Doesn't always sustain blocks. Has serious character issues. Was slowed by a hamstring injury last year.

Bottom line: Moss is a lightning rod for controversy and is a bit of an underachiever, but when the effort is there, he nearly defines the prototype at the position. His ability to go deep plays to Kerry Collins' strength of throwing deep with accuracy. Grade: 9.5

NO. 2 TORRY HOLT (St. Louis Rams)

Strengths: Has excellent speed and initial quickness. Gets clean releases against press coverage. Sets up defenders, explodes out of his cuts and separates against man-to-man coverage. Adjusts to passes outside his frame and can make difficult catches on vertical sideline routes. Reads defenses well, makes pre-snap adjustments and finds soft spots against zone coverage. Can shield defenders and make tough catches in traffic. Has big hands and rarely drops anything. Is fast and shifty after the catch.

Weaknesses: Lacks elite size and occasionally gets muscled out of his routes. Sometimes takes his eyes off the ball to find the defender. Doesn't play with a mean streak or consistent intensity. Won't sustain blocks.

Bottom line: What Holt loses because of his less than ideal strength and size he makes up for with speed, excellent routes and know-how. Grade: 9.4

NO. 3 MARVIN HARRISON (Indianapolis Colts)

Strengths: Is tough and durable. Shows excellent quickness off the snap. Has great hands and can make catches outside his frame. Has excellent body control and despite his size, can take the ball away from bigger defenders. Has rare feel for the game. Can work through double-teams and still make big plays. Will make catches in traffic. Has excellent feel for working back to the ball when the quarterback is flushed out of the pocket. Is an exceptional route runner; knows how to set up guys and get out of breaks quickly. Can make defenders miss after the catch.

Weaknesses: Can have trouble against press coverage because of his lack of size and strength. Is just average as a blocker. Sometimes avoids contact and goes out of bounds.

Bottom line: Harrison's consistent play and willingness to put in a lot of time with Peyton Manning will land Harrison in the Hall of Fame when his career is finished. Grade: 9.2

NO. 4 CHAD JOHNSON (Cincinnati Bengals)

Strengths: Possesses an elite combination of size, strength and athletic ability. Has deceptive speed and is a vertical threat. Is physical and can take the ball away from defensive backs. Has tremendous agility and body control. Has excellent hands to make tough catches look easy. Consistently beat double-teams last season.

Weaknesses: Needs to improve his concentration and on-field attitude when things go wrong. Must give better effort on the back side when he is not the No. 1 option. Could improve at finding holes in zone coverage.

Bottom line: About the only thing missing from Johnson's game is a consistent effort as an aggressive blocker. One of the game's dynamic young receivers, he plays with great enthusiasm. Grade: 9.1

NO. 5 TERRELL OWENS (Philadelphia Eagles)

Strengths: Has a remarkable physical makeup, prototypical size, speed and strength, and his talent demands constant double-teams. Makes plays and is a threat to score every time he makes a catch. Will go over the middle and make catches in traffic. Is effective against zone and man coverage and can't be defended one-on-one. Catches the ball away from his body and does a good job shielding the ball from defenders. Is a monster in the red zone.

Weaknesses: Needs to improve his routes; relies too much on physical strength to get open. Has inconsistent concentration and intensity and can be distracted by off-the-field issues.

Bottom line: Although Owens creates too much controversy for some, he is one of the NFL's elite playmakers, and he makes the receivers around him better. Grade: 9.0

Also: NO. 6 HINES WARD, Pittsburgh Steelers; NO. 7 PLAXICO BURRESS, New York Giants; NO. 8 LAVERANUES COLES, New York Jets; NO. 9 ANDRE JOHNSON, Houston Texans; NO. 10 STEVE SMITH, Carolina Panthers

NO. 1 TONY GONZALEZ (Kansas City Chiefs)

Strengths: Is versatile and can line up in many spots. Has excellent hands and can extend and catch outside his frame. Creates mismatches at all levels and makes linebackers and safeties look bad one-on-one. Is an excellent route runner and has great quickness and speed. Faces a lot of double and bracket coverage but still produces. Is excellent in the red zone.

Weaknesses: Is just average as a blocker. Doesn't have a lot of strength in-line blocking and doesn't appear to work on this part of his game.

Bottom line: Gonzalez is one of the best athletes ever to play tight end and can change the outcome of any game. Grade: 9.3

NO. 2 ANTONIO GATES (San Diego Chargers)

Strengths: Has an excellent combination of size and speed. Shows exceptional quickness off the line and in his routes. Can change direction with little wasted motion and shows great instincts for someone who didn't play college football. Is a load for linebackers and safeties one-on-one. Has soft hands and can make catches outside his frame and over his shoulder. Can use finesse or power to gain yards after the catch.

Weaknesses: Makes the effort and wants to improve as a blocker but never will be dominant in-line.

Bottom line: The scary thing about Gates is he is just starting to feel comfortable reading defenses. He is Drew Brees' go-to guy on third down. Grade: 8.6

NO. 3 TODD HEAP (Baltimore Ravens)

Strengths: Has excellent focus and receiving skills. Will go over the middle and can make catches in traffic. Can be effective on short, intermediate and long routes and is tough to tie up on release.

Weaknesses: Doesn't have dominating blocking skills. Lacks power and base on run blocks and struggles to sustain blocks at the point of attack. Can be too upright when he sets up his routes and doesn't dominate the red zone. Durability is a concern.

Bottom line: Heap should bounce back from an injury-plagued 2004 season and thrive because Derrick Mason will take attention from him. Grade: 8.5

NO. 4 ALGE CRUMPLER (Atlanta Falcons)

Strengths: Has an excellent combination of size, speed, agility and hands. Changes direction well, shows sound body control and bursts out of his cuts. Excels against man-to-man coverage and finds soft spots in zones. Has the frame to shield defenders and can make catches in traffic. Can elude defenders or overpower them.

Weaknesses: Lacks in-line blocking power. Plays high and with inconsistent technique. Struggles against big two-gap defenders and doesn't use his hands well, often failing to lock on. Has been hindered by nagging injuries.

Bottom line: Crumpler isn't a great blocker, but he's reliable on possession throws and can make plays downfield and after the catch. Grade: 8.4

NO. 5 RANDY MCMICHAEL (Miami Dolphins)

Strengths: Shows quickness and great change-of-direction skills. Is too fast for linebackers and too big for defensive backs in man coverage. Has big, soft hands and is one of the top vertical threats at the position. Takes sound angles and uses leverage as a blocker.

Weaknesses: Must improve his bulk and strength. Gives an inconsistent effort and drops too many balls.

Bottom line: McMichael can improve physically but already is one of the best seam-stretching tight ends in the league. He should continue to climb the charts. Grade: 7.9

Also: NO. 6 JASON WITTEN, Dallas Cowboys; NO. 7 JEREMY SHOCKEY, New York Giants; NO. 8 DANIEL GRAHAM, New England Patriots; NO. 9 DALLAS CLARK, Indianapolis Colts; NO. 10 BUBBA FRANKS, Green Bay Packers

NO. 1 MIKE FLANAGAN (Green Bay Packers)

Strengths: Is intelligent and moves well. Shows great balance and pulls effectively on screens and toss plays. Reaches linebackers easily and sustains his blocks. Takes sound angles and uses his hands well. Handles pre-snap calls and adjustments and rarely makes mistakes. Snaps consistently on shotgun plays. Excels at picking up stunts and blitzes. Redirects easily and rarely takes false steps.

Weaknesses: Lacks ideal strength and has some trouble against big defenders in the gap or over his nose. Doesn't get much movement. Won't always reach explosive one-gap penetrators. Is coming off knee surgery after playing only three games last year.

Bottom line: Flanagan is athletic and technically sound. He won't overpower his man often, but he is an excellent starter and has upside. Grade: 8.0

NO. 2 OLIN KREUTZ (Chicago Bears)

Strengths: Can play guard or center. Is an outstanding technician who gets great blocking position. Has an explosive first step and quickness. Works hard and shows excellent aggressiveness and balance. Is an intelligent leader who makes all the line calls. Can pull and get outside on screens and sweeps. Is fairly efficient at finding targets downfield and great at picking up line stunts and blitzes.

Weaknesses: Is undersized; won't overpower defensive tackles and lacks the strength to drive off bigger opponents. Does not get much movement with a defender on his nose. Is inconsistent with his snaps out of the shotgun.

Bottom line: Kreutz gets the most out of his ability, but his lack of size makes durability an issue. Grade: 8.0

NO. 3 JEFF HARTINGS (Pittsburgh Steelers)

Strengths: Has the ability to play through pain and shows excellent toughness. Plays at a high tempo and with some edge. Has great vision, solid athleticism and quickness off the snap. Shows awareness in pass protection and does well protecting his edge. Rarely puts his body in poor position. Gives a solid downfield effort. Can stand up defenders at the snap with a solid punch.

Weaknesses: Has a history of knee problems. Has average playing strength and does not have great power or explosiveness. Sometimes has anchor issues in pass protection against powerful nose tackles.

Bottom line: Hartings has the smarts, toughness and technical ability to play at a high level if his knees hold up. He can be so tough to beat that he can wear on the psyche of his opponent. Grade: 8.0

NO. 4 MATT BIRK (Minnesota Vikings)

Strengths: Has elite speed, mobility and intelligence. Fires out of his stance and has a productive first step. Makes exceptional use of angles. Hits the moving target and can pull wide consistently. Has a quick pass set and short-area quickness. Shows awareness and rarely gets beaten by blitzes or stunts. Gives terrific help to his guards. Plays with balance and leverage. Is a terrific leader and makes solid line calls.

Weaknesses: Has had recent surgeries. Lacks great bulk and strength and occasionally gets driven back or needs help against massive tackles. Lacks mirror-and-slide skills. Can struggle against quicker interior pass rushers.

Bottom line: Birk is one of the league's elite centers when healthy, but his short- and long-term durability are concerns. Grade: 8.0

NO. 5 KEVIN MAWAE (New York Jets)

Strengths: Plays with a wide base, stays balanced and works to sustain blocks. Has the lateral mobility to adjust to moving targets at the second level. Has sound footwork; keeps the defender in front and rarely is beaten by double moves.

Weaknesses: Lacks bulk and lower-body strength; struggles against two-gap defensive tackles. Won't knock many defenders off the ball and will struggle to get movement in short-yardage situations.

Bottom line: Mawae is consistent, gives great effort and rarely allows his assignment to make plays, but he is nearing the end and isn't a dominant run blocker. Grade: 7.9

Also: NO. 6 JEREMY NEWBERRY, San Francisco 49ers; NO. 7 JEFF SATURDAY, Indianapolis Colts; NO. 8 HANK FRALEY, Philadelphia Eagles; NO. 9 MIKE FLYNN, Baltimore Ravens; NO. 10 LeCHARLES BENTLEY, New Orleans Saints

NO. 1 WILL SHIELDS (Kansas City Chiefs)

Strengths: Has outstanding durability. Is an excellent two-way blocker who sets the tempo for the line. Shows initial quickness off the ball and excellent upper-body strength. Has strong hands; can grab and throw defenders to the ground. Shows the ability to connect on combination blocks and is a solid blocker on the second level. Takes excellent angles and can adjust to moving targets. Plays with outstanding base and balance, excellent vision and awareness. Does a nice job of pulling and getting up through the hole. Has excellent quickness in his pass set. Can handle edge and power rushers.

Weaknesses: Age might soon catch up with him. Will have problems with premier one-gap pass rushers. Needs to use his hands better and deliver a more powerful punch.

Bottom line: Shields continues to play at a high level, and he can be a dominating run and pass blocker. He eventually will find his way into the Hall of Fame. Grade: 8.3

NO. 2 ALAN FANECA (Pittsburgh Steelers)

Strengths: Is tough and plays with an edge. Is durable, possessing an excellent combination of strength and athleticism. Works hard and is smart and shows exceptional vision and awareness. Takes excellent angles in the running game. Makes a great effort to get downfield and find blocks. Keeps his hands active and in sound position.

Weaknesses: Can be a little too aggressive in pass protection. Doesn't consistently anchor in pass protection and can get pushed back. Athletic defensive tackles sometimes beat him on his edge.

Bottom line: Faneca is the key to the Steelers' running game. He pulls and leads many of the signature running plays. Grade: 8.1

NO. 3 MIKE WAHLE (Carolina Panthers)

Strengths: Takes solid angles, plays with a mean streak and is physical at the point of attack. Rarely loses once locked on. Gets leverage, keeps his legs driving after contact and can push the pile in the running game. Can engulf undersized defenders. Stays under control, has range, runs screens well and is among the league's best at pulling and trapping. Maintains separation and forces rushers to take wider angles to the quarterback. Is durable and versatile; can play tackle or guard.

Weaknesses: Struggles to hold up on island in pass protection, lacks lateral mobility and is vulnerable to double moves. Takes too long to redirect inside after starting outside. Doesn't get into his pass set quickly and lacks awareness in pass protection.

Bottom line: Wahle lacks athleticism and needs help in pass protection, especially if he lines up at tackle. But he rarely makes mistakes and is one of the league's better drive blockers. Grade: 7.9

NO. 4 STEVE HUTCHINSON (Seattle Seahawks)

Strengths: Is gritty, efficient and technically sound. Rarely loses one-on-one when he gets position. Has long arms and powerful hands and gets terrific hand placement. Is feisty and relentless. Gets out quickly on pulls and traps. Plays with balance and leverage in pass protection. Shows awareness on blitzes and stunts.

Weaknesses: Lacks ideal feet, lateral movement and speed. Has trouble hitting moving targets. Occasionally struggles mirroring and sliding against quick double moves.

Bottom line: Hutchinson might never reach elite status because of his average athleticism, but he is pretty close. Coming off his best season, he could get better. Grade: 7.9

NO. 5 VINCE MANUWAI (Jacksonville Jaguars)

Strengths: Is tough and physical and plays with an edge to his game. Has an excellent motor and a strong initial punch. Plays with excellent leverage in the running game and is solid when pulling on counters. Is a great anchor in pass protection.

Weaknesses: Must improve his balance and body control. Can be late off the ball. Needs to improve his awareness in pass protection and is not consistent protecting the edges. Is injury-prone.

Bottom line: Manuwai has short arms, but he is powerful and explosive and difficult to push around. Grade: 7.8

Also: NO. 6 LARRY ALLEN, Dallas Cowboys; NO. 7 BRIAN WATERS, Kansas City Chiefs; NO. 8 MARCO RIVERA, Dallas Cowboys; NO. 9 CHRIS VILLARRIAL, Buffalo Bills; NO. 10 EDWIN MULITALO, Baltimore Ravens

NO. 1 ORLANDO PACE (St. Louis Rams)

Strengths: Has a rare combination of size, power and athleticism. Shows solid initial punch, plays with leverage and consistently gets movement at the point of attack. Has great initial quickness and will adjust to moving targets at the second level. Sets quickly and has the lateral mobility to handle double moves in pass protection. Has an explosive first step to prevent edge rushers from beating him wide and uses his long arms to ride defenders past the pocket. Bends at the knees and anchors against bull rushers.

Weaknesses: Gets complacent against weaker competition. Occasionally takes poor angles to downfield blocks. Has had a few injuries in the past but works to stay in shape. Is coming off a bit of a down season by his standards.

Bottom line: Pace is a perennial Pro Bowl player. Durability is a minor concern, but after holding out the past two years, he should benefit from taking part in a full preseason. Grade: 9.5

NO. 2 WALTER JONES (Seattle Seahawks)

Strengths: Has an ideal combination of size and athleticism. Plays with balance, moves his feet well and rarely gets beaten by double moves. Has excellent football intelligence, takes great angles and wastes little motion getting position. Bends at the knees, plays with a solid base and anchors well against the bull rush. Delivers an adequate initial punch, locks on to defenders and has the long arms to ride explosive edge rushers past the pocket.

Weaknesses: Isn't a dominant run blocker. Doesn't consistently move the pile and won't work to finish blocks with authority. Lacks a mean streak and could stand to be more aggressive. Hasn't always kept himself in ideal shape and is a step slow when he gets too heavy.

Bottom line: Jones is a finesse blocker who won't knock his man back at the point of attack, but he rarely misses an assignment and almost never allows a sack. Grade: 9.2

NO. 3 JONATHAN OGDEN (Baltimore Ravens)

Strengths: Has rare size and athletic ability and long arms. Is a physical player and has excellent upper- and lower-body strength. Shows a nasty streak. Is smart; rarely is out of position in the running or passing game. Shows excellent patience in his pass set. Has sound awareness of stunts and can step inside and protect. Can adjust against spin moves. Is difficult to beat around the edge, wins battles on initial contact and can ride defensive ends around the edge. Has rare power. Gets off the ball and into his set quickly. Can reset and anchor and engulf and wall off.

Weaknesses: Doesn't show a lot of range and can get pushed around on short sets. Has had problems with counter moves. Will lose contact after the first hit.

Bottom line: Doesn't show a lot of range and can get pushed around on short sets. Has had problems with counter moves. Will lose contact after the first hit.

NO. 4 FLOZELL ADAMS (Dallas Cowboys)

Strengths: Engulfs undersized defenders at the point of attack and can drive them off the ball. Rarely loses a battle once locked on to a defender. Has a wide frame and uses his long arms to force edge rushers to take wider angles to the quarterback and can anchor against bull rushers. Can sell draws and screens. Is versatile, durable and fairly agile.

Weaknesses: Footwork is inconsistent. Is vulnerable to double moves. Is slow out of his stance; superior edge rushers can turn the corner against him. Lacks the range to pull or trap and isn't comfortable playing in space. Takes poor angles to blocks. Takes false steps and isn't fundamentally sound.

Bottom line: Although Adams hasn't realized his potential, he is a powerful run blocker and can hold his own in pass protection. Grade: 8.6

NO. 5 JORDAN GROSS (Carolina Panthers)

Strengths: Plays with a mean streak, can knock defenders back, has upper-body strength and rarely loses once locked on. Rarely takes false steps and is fundamentally sound. Never stops working. Plays under control in space, rarely lunges and moves well laterally. Rarely is beaten by double moves. Has enough lower-body strength to hold his ground against bull rushers and rarely makes mistakes.

Weaknesses: Lacks prototypical size and explosiveness and can't engulf defenders. Must play with perfect technique against bull rushers. Lacks an explosive first step and struggles to prevent penetration.

Bottom line: Gross is an explosive drive blocker who plays with a nonstop motor. He is athletic enough to hold his own in pass protection. Grade: 8.4

Also: NO. 6 CHRIS SAMUELS, Washington Redskins; NO. 7 BRYANT MCKINNIE, Minnesota Vikings; NO. 8 JOHN TAIT, Chicago Bears; NO. 9 WILLIE ROAF, Kansas City Chiefs; NO. 10 WILLIE ANDERSON, Cincinnati Bengals

NO. 1 DWIGHT FREENEY (Indianapolis Colts)

Strengths: Is the most explosive end in the league, a relentless pass rusher who must be accounted for on every down. No one has a better first step; gets on the offensive tackle's outside edge quickly and puts pressure on the entire left side of the line. Shows excellent lean to turn the corner and rare closing burst from the backside. Has an impressive repertoire of rush moves and can generate a bull rush because he plays with such excellent leverage. Is a playmaker and an explosive hitter who knows how to finish. Has improved against the run. Has added strength and plays with solid leverage.

Weaknesses: Is not a quick-shed end. Can have trouble playing the run when it comes right at him.

Bottom line: Freeney is special because his effort, motor and desire to make plays are second to none. Because offenses must scheme to try to stop him, he makes the players around him better and now has a better supporting cast. Grade: 9.0

NO. 2 SHAUN ELLIS (New York Jets)

Strengths: Has enough anticipation, agility and instincts to generate consistent pressure from the outside. Can dominate opponents with power and quickness. Is big and quick enough to penetrate as a one-gap interior player. Excels at beating opponents off the snap and almost always wins with power against tight ends. Plays with discipline against the run. Displays consistent leverage and can collapse the pocket. Tackles explosively and rarely gives up on plays.

Weaknesses: Lacks elite speed and doesn't have explosive acceleration around the corner. Lacks bulk and base as an interior player. Must be active to avoid getting engulfed inside.

Bottom line: Ellis lacks elite pass-rushing speed but is a power rusher who is a force against the run. He has developed into one of the league's best all-around linemen. Grade: 8.9

NO. 3 MICHAEL STRAHAN (New York Giants)

Strengths: Is quick and explosive off the line, plays with great leverage and tremendous balance and regularly rocks offensive linemen. Never stops moving his feet. Has a variety of pass-rush moves and counters; can collapse the pocket or use finesse to create pressure. Uses his hands well and has long arms. Diagnoses and reacts quickly against the run and the pass. Is a premier pass rusher whose excellent run defense sometimes is overlooked. Is a true every-down lineman.

Weaknesses: Is somewhat vulnerable to low blocks. Doesn't vigorously pursue plays away from him; tends to conserve his energy for pass rushing and defending the point of attack. Durability might be a concern.

Bottom line: Strahan played only eight games last season because of a torn chest muscle, but he remains an elite player and draws double-teams 90 percent of the time. Grade: 8.9

NO. 4 JULIUS PEPPERS (Carolina Panthers)

Strengths: Has outstanding quickness and will disrupt plays in the backfield. Plays with solid leverage, uses his long arms to keep blockers at bay and uses his hands well to shed blocks. Takes solid angles to the ball, can get through traffic and excels in pursuit. Has the first step to shoot inside gaps, can run around a lot of tackles and has great closing speed to the quarterback. Can redirect inside after starting outside and has a variety of pass-rush moves. Times his jumps well, has long arms and does a nice job of getting his hands up to bat down passes. Can drop into coverage.

Weaknesses: Doesn't have great size for a player with his height, gets engulfed at times and can wear down if teams run at him consistently.

Bottom line: Peppers is an explosive pass rusher who also is disruptive when defending the run. He is versatile enough to line up at multiple spots and makes plays all over the field. Grade: 8.8

NO. 5 PATRICK KERNEY (Atlanta Falcons)

Strengths: Has sideline-to-sideline range and excellent closing speed. Takes solid angles, uses his hands to get through traffic and locates the ball quickly. Has the upper-body strength to maintain separation. Breaks down in space and wraps up on contact. Has the initial burst to put an offensive tackle back on his heels. Can knife inside after starting outside and has an array of pass-rush moves. Plays with solid leverage and can collapse the pocket. Is durable.

Weaknesses: Lacks elite lower-body strength, can't anchor against double-teams and will wear down when run at consistently. Doesn't always play with a wide base.

Bottom line: Kerney lacks elite bulk and power, but he has the burst, athleticism and intensity to excel in a one gap-scheme. Grade: 8.6

Also: NO. 6 JASON TAYLOR, Miami Dolphins; NO. 7 RICHARD SEYMOUR, New England Patriots; NO. 8 KABEER GBAJA-BIAMILA, Green Bay Packers; NO. 9 AARON SCHOBEL, Buffalo Bills; NO. 10 LEONARD LITTLE, St. Louis Rams

NO. 1 KRIS JENKINS (Carolina Panthers)

Strengths: Has the first step to beat linemen at the point of attack. Plays with a mean streak, is difficult to budge, uses his hands well and has the upper-body strength to maintain separation. Can shed quickly and disrupt running plays in the backfield. Never stops hustling, can slip blocks in space and is fast enough to make plays in pursuit. Has great range and can shoot inside gaps. Has great closing speed in the backfield, can redirect inside after starting outside, has a variety of moves and runs line stunts well. Can collapse the pocket and gets his hands up and tips passes.

Weaknesses: Plays too high, struggles to anchor against double-teams, lacks recognition and has problems disengaging from blockers. Takes poor angles at times and takes himself out of plays by getting too far upfield. Durability is a concern.

Bottom line: Jenkins is coming off a season- ending shoulder injuryhe played just four games last yearand was slowed by ankle injuries in 2002. The Panthers desperately need him at full strength because he can occupy the middle of an offensive line. Grade: 9.2

NO. 2 SHAUN ROGERS (Detroit Lions)

Strengths: Has an exceptional combination of quickness, size and power and shows rare initial quickness for his size. Draws double-teams regularly and can anchor or split them. Has phenomenal power at the point of attack. Stands up interior linemen, uses swim moves and penetrates consistently. Has great closing burst, takes sound angles and changes direction ridiculously well for his size. Is a playmaker on the run and a powerful tackler. Plays one-gap and two-gap techniques equally well.

Weaknesses: Can wear down, but his motor is more consistent than in the past. Sometimes plays high and loses explosiveness. Can be overaggressive and take himself out of plays.

Bottom line: Rogers can do it all, and he's durable and young enough to get better. His effort was much steadier the past two seasons. Grade: 9.1

NO. 3 MARCUS STROUD (Jacksonville Jaguars)

Strengths: Has outstanding size, athleticism, quickness and strength. Has the physical tools to be a dominating inside presence. Is extremely explosive off the snap and makes plays. Has an excellent feel for blocking schemes, shoots gaps and disrupts. Has great strength and leverage. Plays stout against the run and can split double-teams. Will get in passing lanes. Is a solid hitter and wrap-up tackler.

Weaknesses: Must become more consistent and intense. Could improve his counter rush moves.

Bottom line: Stroud wasn't as productive in 2004 because he didn't adapt well to having to play end at times. He has all the physical tools to dominate on the inside and to be a regular Pro Bowl player. Grade: 8.8

NO. 4 KEVIN WILLIAMS (Minnesota Vikings)

Strengths: Has an impressive frame and rare speed and athleticism for his size. Changes direction quickly and has terrific body control and an explosive burst through the hole. Has the upper-body power to knock back linemen and rip, swim and club effectively. Finds the ball quickly and will pursue the run. Is a powerful tackler and a disruptive playmaker. Is a versatile, hard-working, high-character player.

Weaknesses: Can be nearly impossible to block one-on-one when he goes all-out, but he sometimes seems to conserve energy. Lacks great bulk and can be engulfed when he doesn't win with quickness. Will play high when tired.

Bottom line: Williams is entering just his third season, but he already has established himself as one of the league's most disruptive tackles and can reach elite status. Grade: 8.5

NO. 5 JOHN HENDERSON (Jacksonville Jaguars)

Strengths: Is tall with excellent strength and eats up a lot of space inside. Is an active, high-motor player who plays physically inside and flashes a mean streak. Gets into blockers quickly and can penetrate and make plays in the backfield. Shows excellent strength against the run. Is relentless as a pass rusher and often gets coverage sacks.

Weaknesses: Needs to protect his lower legs better against cut blocks. Is inconsistent finding the ball on running downs.

Bottom line: Henderson made big leaps in each of the past two seasons. If he continues to improve at this rate, he will be a regular Pro Bowl player. Grade: 8.3

Also: NO. 6 CASEY HAMPTON, Pittsburgh Steelers; NO. 7 PAT WILLIAMS, Minnesota Vikings; NO. 8 ROD COLEMAN, Atlanta Falcons; NO. 9 TOMMIE HARRIS, Chicago Bears; NO. 10 LA'ROI GLOVER, Dallas Cowboys

NO. 1 JULIAN PETERSON (San Francisco 49ers)

Strengths: Is a playmaker who has great instincts and rare first-step quickness. Is best when close to the line, where he can use his speed to shoot gaps and chase plays from behind. Has tremendous closing speed and is a solid open-field tackler. Has improved his ability to read blocks and take solid angles. Is adept at dropping into coverage and can turn and run with most tight ends and backs. Has a nose for the ball.

Weaknesses: Durability is a big concern; he played only five games last year because of injury. Isn't a big, physical player, and opponents can take him out of his game by running right at him. Relies on natural ability to avoid contact and lacks the size to stack and shed. Has a blitz-first mentality and must improve his recognition skills.

Bottom line: Peterson is one of the most athletic and versatile players in the league when healthy. He is an especially effective nickel rusher. Grade: 9.2

NO. 2 KEITH BULLUCK (Tennessee Titans)

Strengths: Is big, tall and rangy and uses his exceptional speed to make plays all over the field. Is an excellent pass rusher and blitzer who can avoid blocks and finish. Has the long arms to be disruptive in the passing lanes. Is smooth and fluid in coverage and has the skills to play man-to-man. Is aggressive against the inside run and hits with power.

Weaknesses: Lacks great instincts but is working to improve. His play suffers when he's tired because it negates his ability to avoid blockers and use his speed in pursuit.

Bottom line: Bulluck took over on defense last season, playing with a nonstop motor and leading the Titans in tackles. He is a special player who should become a perennial Pro Bowl selection. Grade: 9.1

NO. 3 TAKEO SPIKES (Buffalo Bills)

Strengths: Is a terrific athlete who plays with abandon. His initial quickness, diagnostic skills and speed are outstanding. Takes great angles to the ballcarrier and has excellent closing burst in pursuit. Sifts through traffic quickly and uses his hands to slap away blockers. Shows great power at the point of attack as a tackler and is a devastating blitzer. Has outstanding range and ball skills in coverage.

Weaknesses: Prefers being in space and gets frustrated if he constantly is fighting off blocks. Doesn't always play with leverage. Occasionally is out of control and takes himself out of plays by overextending.

Bottom line: A two-time Pro Bowl player, Spikes is a perfect fit for the Bills' scheme because he makes plays from sideline to sideline and doesn't have to come off the field. Grade: 8.7

NO. 4 LaVAR ARRINGTON (Washington Redskins)

Strengths: Has the quickness to make plays from sideline to sideline. Can run with backs or tight ends downfield and always is around the ball. Is an offensive tackle's worst nightmare as a pass rusher. Attacks the line against the run, playing with leverage and using his upper-body strength to shed blockers. Reads and diagnoses plays quickly.

Weaknesses: Can be overaggressive and gets out of position. Durability is a concern; played in only four games last year because of a knee injury. Contract disagreement could affect his attitude.

Bottom line: The Redskins need Arrington to be healthy and happy in 2005, and there is no guarantee of either. He is best suited to play off the line but has not been used that way since 2001. Grade: 8.6

NO. 5 ANDRE CARTER (San Francisco 49ers)

Strengths: Has great quickness and explosiveness and can get upfield in a hurry. Has perfected his pass-rush technique. Has great counter moves, works hard with his hands and doesn't allow offensive tackles to ride him past the quarterback. Uses his long arms to create separation, always plays with solid leverage and has great closing speed to the quarterback. Shows solid instincts on the edge and uses stunts and twists effectively.

Weaknesses: Lacks ideal strength, has a difficult time maintaining control of the line of scrimmage against the run and struggles with double-teams. Durability is a huge concern; is coming off two back surgeries last year after playing in only seven games.

Bottom line: If healthy, Carter likely will be used as a pass rush specialist because he doesn't have ideal range to drop into coverage. Grade: 8.1

Also: NO. 6 DERRICK BROOKS, Tampa Bay Buccaneers; NO. 7 KEITH BROOKING, Atlanta Falcons; NO. 8 KENDRELL BELL, Kansas City Chiefs; NO. 9 MIKE VRABEL, New England Patriots; NO. 10 WILLIE McGINEST, New England Patriots

NO. 1 RAY LEWIS (Baltimore Ravens)

Strengths: Can take a game over athletically, physically and mentally. Is a tough, aggressive, high-intensity player who feeds off the energy of the crowd. Runs to the ball well and shows excellent sideline-to-sideline speed and range. Takes solid angles and is exceptional playing through and over traffic. Has excellent initial pop. Is an explosive hitter and tackler and plays with a mean streak.

Weaknesses: Can be overaggressive and overrun plays. Can get engulfed if he doesn't beat linemen to the spot. Isn't a consistent take-on and shed player. Doesn't have the shoulder or arm strength to shock blockers and get them off him like he used to.

Bottom line: Lewis can carry the defense on his back and should have a more productive season now that the Ravens are back in a 4-3. He shows rare leadership ability and intangibles and is the type of player who makes his teammates better. Grade: 9.4

NO. 2 BRIAN URLACHER (Chicago Bears)

Strengths: Has great size and athleticism. Is a smooth runner who attacks the line with quickness and moves well laterally. Uses his hands well, is explosive and rarely gets tied up in traffic. Is aggressive going to the ball and excels at diagnosing plays and getting in position. Has solid awareness in zone coverage and adequate speed to run with backs and tight ends in man coverage. Is a proficient tackler.

Weaknesses: Blockers can get into his legs because he is tall and rangy. Will take false steps toward the line of scrimmage. Is sometimes too eager to make plays and gets out of position on play-action. Durability is a minor concern; injuries limited him to nine games last season.

Bottom line: Urlacher missed the Pro Bowl for the first time in his career last season. Expect him to be driven to produce this season. Grade: 8.9

NO. 3 TEDY BRUSCHI (New England Patriots)

Strengths: Has great lateral mobility and is extremely versatile. Can step up and fill in the hole. Has phenomenal instincts and a great feel for slipping blocks. Is an outstanding pass rusher, blitzer and cover guy. Takes excellent angles and uses his hands well on the pass rush. Is a textbook tackler. Can turn and get depth in zone schemes or match up with backs in man-to-man. Can jam backs and tight ends at the line.

Weaknesses: Had an offseason stroke that threatens his career. Is no longer a young player and might not recover quickly, and his role could change if he returns. Lacks prototypical interior size.

Bottom line: Because his game is based more on intelligence and instincts than physical talent, Bruschi could have plenty of football left if he is cleared to return. Grade: 8.3

NO. 4 JONATHAN VILMA (New York Jets)

Strengths: Is an outstanding athlete who plays with a high motor and has excellent quickness and agility. Excels at slipping blocks and staying clean. Diagnoses quickly, gets through traffic and blows up plays. Has great range in pursuit, displays closing burst to the ballcarrier and will make a lot of plays on the run. Tackles well in the open field and can match up one-on-one with most running backs. Shows instincts in coverage and has excellent ball skills. Shows excellent closing burst to the quarterback.

Weaknesses: Runs around too many blocks and must learn when to take them on, using leverage and hands. Is undersized and can be overpowered at the point of attack if he gets locked up with an offensive lineman.

Bottom line: Vilma was the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year in 2004 and has a chance to be special. He should continue to improve, and it won't be long before he is the leader of the Jets' defense. Grade: 8.1

NO. 5 JAMES FARRIOR (Pittsburgh Steelers)

Strengths: Is tough, physical and competitive. Makes plays all over the field against the run and pass. Has excellent instincts and consistently beats offensive linemen to the spot. Can stand up fullbacks and offensive linemen. Played faster last season than in the past. Can sift through traffic to make plays and takes excellent angles in pursuit. Is tough to block when attacking the line. Excels in coverage and has a great feel in zone. Is a playmaker and ballhawk.

Weaknesses: Can struggle when matched up in man coverage and when he has to open his hips and run.

Bottom line: Farrior dominated last season, making the Pro Bowl and turning in the best year of his career. He didn't have a sack in his last 10 games but made the players around him better. Grade: 8.0

Also: NO. 6 DAN MORGAN, Carolina Panthers; NO. 7 AL WILSON, Denver Broncos; NO. 8 EDGERTON HARTWELL, Atlanta Falcons; NO. 9 JEREMIAH TROTTER, Philadelphia Eagles; NO. 10 NICK BARNETT, Green Bay Packers



NO. 1 CHRIS McALISTER (Baltimore Ravens)

Strengths: Has a rare combination of size, strength and speed. Feet and hips are smooth and fluid. Is physical in coverage and can match up with any receiver in man-to-man coverage. Performs best against bigger, more physical receivers. Can redirect receivers on their releases and is a hard hitter after the catch. Shows high/low awareness in zone coverage and backpedals well. Can jam receivers and bump them downfield. Is a reliable tackler and an excellent leaper.

Weaknesses: At times can be almost too physical in coverage. Gets too loose in cushion coverage and occasionally will go low and miss tackles. Holds and grabs downfield. Struggles against double moves and often gambles and gets out of position.

Bottom line: McAlister made the Pro Bowl last season but wasn't happy with his performance overall. He stayed in Baltimore in the offseason and worked hard, so expect the game's best corner to be even better. Grade: 8.8

NO. 2 CHAMP BAILEY (Denver Broncos)

Strengths: Has rare athleticism, excellent cover skills and swagger. Can shadow and lock down an opponent's No. 1 receiver. Has elite transition quickness, recovery speed and ball skills. Holds up well against double moves. Can jam and ride a receiver downfield. Keeps solid position in zone coverage. Is a decent tackler who makes the effort in run support.

Weaknesses: Lacks prototypical size and can be pushed around by bigger receivers. Keeps his hands too low in press coverage. Turned too late and had problems tracking the ball last season.

Bottom line: Despite giving up too many big plays in 2004, Bailey is a special corner. He also is a high-character team leader. Grade: 8.7

NO. 3 TY LAW

Strengths: Opens his hips quickly in turn-and-run situations and can handle himself isolated in coverage. Plays with great confidence and a mean streak. Can jam receivers at the line and muscle them off routes. Shows solid footwork, changes direction quickly and can blanket receivers underneath. Shows burst to the ball and is a playmaker. Sheds blocks quickly, is willing in run support and is a reliable open-field tackler. Shows great awareness and instincts.

Weaknesses: Lacks elite speed and great discipline. Can be overaggressive and is vulnerable to play-action and pump fakes. Has lost a step and won't always recover from mistakes. Missed nine games last year because of a foot injury. Can be a distraction.

Bottom line: Law is losing steam and must prove his body can hold up, but he has few weaknesses in his game. Grade: 8.5

NO. 4 NATE CLEMENTS (Buffalo Bills)

Strengths: Excels in man coverage. Is physical, aggressive and confident. Will smother receivers at the line and is great at taking them out of their routes early. Can turn and run without losing much in transition; has explosive speed and can make up for mistakes. Has excellent closing burst when the ball is in the air. Has surprising change-of-direction skills. Has tremendous ball skills, including exceptional hands and leaping ability. Is a superb return specialist and a threat with the ball.

Weaknesses: Must improve his concentration and recognition skills. Loses focus at times and does not pay attention to detail. Relies on his physical tools and speed too much. Takes too many chances.

Bottom line: If Clements shows focus and cuts down on his mental lapses, he could become one of the league's top two corners. Grade: 8.4

NO. 5 PATRICK SURTAIN (Kansas City Chiefs)

Strengths: Is athletic, explodes out of his cuts and can blanket receivers underneath. Shows knee bend, footwork and forward burst. Has the fluid hips and speed to run with most receivers downfield. Can recover from mistakes and has the height to compete for jump balls. Reads quarterbacks' eyes, is aggressive and jumps routes. Has playmaking ball skills and body control. Can get to the quarterback on blitzes. Fills hard against the run and can deliver the big hit.

Weaknesses: Gets caught out of position and can be overaggressive. Is vulnerable to double moves and pump fakes. Isn't strong enough to press or muscle many receivers. Gets nicked up.

Bottom line: Surtain must be more disciplined and physical, but he has outstanding short-area cover skills, holds his own downfield and plays the run well. Grade: 8.4

Also: NO. 6 ANTOINE WINFIELD, Minnesota Vikings; NO. 7 GARY BAXTER, Cleveland Browns; NO. 8 SHELDON BROWN, Philadelphia Eagles; NO. 9 SAMARI ROLLE, Baltimore Ravens; NO. 10 LITO SHEPPARD, Philadelphia Eagles

NO. 1 ED REED (Baltimore Ravens)

Strengths: Has excellent physical tools. Is smooth, fluid and fast and has quick feet and excellent instincts. Does a nice job of baiting the quarterback into making poor decisions. Has rare burst to close and recover when he looks out of position. Shows excellent range while the ball is in the air. Has the best ball skills of any safety in the NFL; has soft hands and gets the ball at its highest point. Has excellent run skills and is a threat to score every time he takes the ball away from the opponent. Is ideal for run blitzes.

Weaknesses: Will gamble, gets out of position at times and puts teammates at risk. Sometimes has trouble in man coverage.

Bottom line: Reed was named the league's defensive player of the year last season and might make more even big plays in a new scheme that will increase his opportunities to free-lance. Grade: 9.4

NO. 2 ROY WILLIAMS (Dallas Cowboys)

Strengths: Is comfortable lining up close to the line, where he does his best work, and can play linebacker. Reads plays quickly, is aggressive and can disrupt running plays in the backfield. Uses his hands well and can shed blocks quickly. Plays with discipline and rarely takes false steps. Takes sound angles and makes plays in pursuit. Is a reliable open-field tackler and wraps up on contact. Is a physical run stuffer who forces fumbles. Can match up with most tight ends and has solid range in zone coverage. Has sound ball skills and can compete for jump balls. Is a playmaker.

Weaknesses: Lacks elite speed, recovery speed and agility.

Bottom line: Williams, coming off his second consecutive Pro Bowl, doesn't have elite cover skills, but there are few weaknesses in his game. He makes up for his lack of ideal top-end speed by rarely making mistakes. Grade: 9.3

NO. 3 RODNEY HARRISON (New England Patriots)

Strengths: Is a big-time hitter who relishes collisions. Is instinctive, takes outstanding angles and wastes little motion. Excels in the box and in run support and also is outstanding in cover 2. Has excellent range and covers more ground than his speed suggests. Often can recover from mistakes. Is an outstanding blitzer and will run over many backs in pass protection.

Weaknesses: Isn't effective in man-to-man schemes. Can be too aggressive; will gamble and bite on play fakes. Age and his physical style could catch up with him.

Bottom line: Harrison takes such good care of his body and has such solid instincts that he might play at a high level for at least another couple of years. Grade: 8.5

NO. 4 BRIAN DAWKINS (Philadelphia Eagles)

Strengths: Has outstanding ball skills and does a great job of tracking the ball in the air. Has excellent range, doesn't waste motion and can get to the ball and make plays. Is outstanding in zone coverage. Has great football knowledge and instincts. Is a great blitzer, an intimidating presence over the middle and an outstanding leader.

Weaknesses: Durability is becoming a concern. Doesn't have great size to hold up in run support; switched to more of a center field role last year.

Bottom line: Dawkins excels in all aspects of the game, has no significant weaknesses and rarely makes mistakes. Grade: 8.2

NO. 5 TONY PARRISH (San Francisco 49ers)

Strengths: His upper-body strength allows him to play off blocks efficiently and get to balls. Is excellent at diagnosing the run, has solid range and plays with high energy. Has a feel for zone coverage, is intelligent and gets himself into good position. Plays with leverage, is agile and can intimidate receivers over the middle. Has adequate ball skills.

Weaknesses: Is limited in man coverage. Can match up with most tight ends and backs but struggles with slot receivers and wideouts. His top-end speed is questionable. Missed too many tackles last year.

Bottom line: At times Parrish is overly aggressive, but he gets the most out of his physical skills and is consistent. Grade: 8.1

Also: NO. 6 MICHAEL LEWIS, Philadelphia Eagles; NO. 7 DONOVIN DARIUS, Jacksonville Jaguars; NO. 8 SEAN TAYLOR, Washington Redskins; NO. 9 TROY POLAMALU, Pittsburgh Steelers; NO. 10 ADAM ARCHULETA, St. Louis Rams

 
Last edited by a moderator:
NO. 1 ADAM VINATIERI (New England Patriots) Is the NFL's best pressure kicker and might be the best in league history. Has phenomenal concentration. Understands weather and wind conditions in Foxboro and handles the elements with remarkable poise. Has excellent mechanics and a strong leg. Gets the ball up quickly, has an excellent follow-through and rarely hits balls poorly. Still has outstanding leg strength and distance. Doesn't need to be replaced on kickoffs. Grade: 7.5 NO. 2 MIKE VANDERJAGT (Indianapolis Colts) Possesses an excellent combination of accuracy and leg strength. Is effective in all types of elements and gets excellent lift on field goals. Has been disappointing on kickoffs and doesn't work on getting better at them. Is disliked by many of his teammates. Grade: 7.3 NO. 3 DAVID AKERS (Philadelphia Eagles) Has one of the strongest legs in the league and outstanding accuracy. Has good mechanics and handles the wind and weather conditions in Philadelphia well. Is outstanding on kickoffs, getting good height and distance. Hits the ball quickly and rarely miss-hits a kick. Grade: 7.3 NO. 4 PHIL DAWSON (Cleveland Browns) Is steady and mentally solid and has the NFL's best array of specialty kicks. Is effective on onside kicks and is a good directional kicker but is below average kicking off. Missed a few crucial kicks late last season. Grade: 7.3 NO. 5 JASON ELAM (Denver Broncos) Has a big-time leg with range from 50 yards and beyond but has lost a little on his kickoffs. Is accurate and has no trouble making adjustments in poor weather. Has long been one of the league's best kickers and still performs at a high level. Can remain solid for two or three more seasons. Grade: 7.3 Also: NO. 6 MATT STOVER, Baltimore Ravens; NO. 7 SEBASTIAN JANIKOWSKI, Oakland Raiders; NO. 8 SHAYNE GRAHAM, Cincinnati Bengals; NO. 9 NATE KAEDING, San Diego Chargers; NO. 10 RYAN LONGWELL, Green Bay Packers
NO. 1 SHANE LECHLER (Oakland Raiders) Has excellent size and hands. Shows solid leg strength and gets great distance on his punts. Gets nice hang time and can steer his team out of trouble when backed up near the end zone. Must cut down on touchbacks and improve his directional placement. Has the potential to put up Hall of Fame-type numbers. Grade: 6.8 NO. 2 CHRIS HANSON (Jacksonville Jaguars) Is a solid athlete with nice size and strength. Shows solid hands catching the ball. Can directional punt to his left. Has nice touch to place the ball inside the 20. Gets solid hang time, but release is slow and methodical. Has not been able to get back to his peak level of 2002. Grade: 6.8 NO. 3 MIKE SCIFRES (San Diego Chargers) Is an up-and-comer who probably deserved a Pro Bowl nod last season. Has a solid combination of leg strength and accuracy. Punts with power and can boot his team out of trouble when pinned in its own end zone. Can find the sideline on pooch punts or place the ball inside the 10 with regularity. Grade: 6.7 NO. 4 HUNTER SMITH (Indianapolis Colts) Has improved his pooch and directional punting. Is technically sound, gets solid distance and has excellent hang time. Is deliberate and has a history of getting punts blocked. Wears down, possibly because of added kickoff duties. Grade: 6.7 NO. 5 CHRIS GARDOCKI (Pittsburgh Steelers) Is a big, solid athlete. Has the NFL's fastest handling and get-off times. Holds the record for attempted punts without having one blocked. Gets excellent hang time and can make directional punts. Skills have diminished a tad in recent seasons. Still performs at a high level and shows little decrease in his abilities. Grade: 6.6 Also: NO. 6 CRAIG HENTRICH, Tennessee Titans; NO. 7 TODD SAUERBRUN, Denver Broncos; NO. 8 BRAD MAYNARD, Chicago Bears; NO. 9 SCOTT PLAYER, Arizona Cardinals; NO. 10 JOSH BIDWELL, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
 
Some of my thoughts on the 3 main offensive skill positions:-I think Brady deserves the #1 spot.-I think Culpepper is way overrated and should be maybe 7 or 8.-Weird to still see McNair up there...is he going to be back to his old form? If so, then he belongs higher. If not, then maybe he shouldn't be on this list at all.-Glad to see Holmes so low...hes definitely helped by that system imo.-Convsersely, its nice to see J Lewis so high, as he is hurt tremendously by his team's offensive system and talent.-The writing regarding Moss is strange to me. Seems like they exaggerated a lot on his negatives, and I kept hearing around hear that Collin's isn't accurate on deep passes, yet they say thats his strength.-TO belongs in the top 3.-Plaxico Burress, coles, and AJ at 7,8,9? I have to think guys like Boldin, Williams, Clayton, etc. are more deserving.-Mason continues to be the most undervalued WR of this generation imho.-Harrison is getting up there in age and should be a bit lower.

 
How in the name of God do you make a list of the best wide receivers in football and put T.O. at #6. Especially when we are talking about a purely football ranking. IMO this is reason alone to ignore the ranking altogether.

 
How in the name of God do you make a list of the best wide receivers in football and put T.O. at #6. Especially when we are talking about a purely football ranking. IMO this is reason alone to ignore the ranking altogether.
They listed "distracted by off field issues" as a weakness, so my guess is that they took into account all of the BS that comes with having T.O. your your team.
 
Weaknesses: Isn't much of a scrambler. Gambles once in a while but normally isn't careless with the ball.
I find it interesting that this is the best "weakness" that they can come up with for Brady. The fact that he isn't careless with the ball is a weakness??? Only further supporting his case for #1 ranking imho.
 
Some of my thoughts on the 3 main offensive skill positions:

-I think Brady deserves the #1 spot.

-I think Culpepper is way overrated and should be maybe 7 or 8.

-Weird to still see McNair up there...is he going to be back to his old form? If so, then he belongs higher. If not, then maybe he shouldn't be on this list at all.

-Glad to see Holmes so low...hes definitely helped by that system imo.

-Convsersely, its nice to see J Lewis so high, as he is hurt tremendously by his team's offensive system and talent.

-The writing regarding Moss is strange to me. Seems like they exaggerated a lot on his negatives, and I kept hearing around hear that Collin's isn't accurate on deep passes, yet they say thats his strength.

-TO belongs in the top 3.

-Plaxico Burress, coles, and AJ at 7,8,9? I have to think guys like Boldin, Williams, Clayton, etc. are more deserving.

-Mason continues to be the most undervalued WR of this generation imho.

-Harrison is getting up there in age and should be a bit lower.
I agree with you jwv. The rankings of Plax and Coles are flat out awful. :yucky:
 
I'd have to say that these rankings are WEAK. There are so many holes in these rankings its hilarious.Plax the #7 WR in the NFL? LOL.Alexander at #2 is too high and there is no Tiki Barber in the Top 10 RBs. Mack Strong is definately a top 10 FB in the NFL.KGB a top 10 DE? I don't think so.Archuleta a Top 10 Safety. Bwahahaha Ya right.

 
How on god's green earth do they have Gary "freakin" Baxter as the #7 CB in the entire NFL?!!!! :eek: .....read no more.

 
a lot of critics here...anyone want to pick a position or two and give us your list?
I'll take a stab at WR which I think is the worst of them all here. Plax in top 10 is a joke, not even top 25 IMO.1. Randy Moss - Teams HAVE to devote at least 2 players to him every play. Changes the game more than any WR out there taking the Safety out of the box and opening things up for the rest of the offense.

2. T.O - Take his attitude away and this guy is the best all around WR in the game.

3. Torry Holt - Might be the best at adjusting to the ball and makes tough catches look routine.

4. Marvin Harrison - Yeah he's getting old but might be second to none in route running and hands.

5. Hines Ward - Nothing but class and work ethic here. We all know how great of a blocker he is and with such a little frame is not scared to do whatever is asked.

6. Chad Johnson - Has all the tools to be a top 5 WR for the next 7-10 years and plays the game with passion.

7. Andre Johnson - T.O without the attitude IMO. Just needs a consistant Carr to be an elite player.

8. Joe Horn - Could be the only reason anyone thinks A. Brooks is a quality QB. The guy just keep putting up numbers regardless of how bad the offense does.

9. Derick Mason - Has to be the most underrated WR if not player I have seen.

10. (gulp) Nate Burleson - Yes I am from Minnesota, but this guy just knows how to get open (138 rec. last season at UNLV). He also lead the league in yards after catch and it's not because he was benifiting from Moss. Has a great stiff arm and drags defenders for extra yards.

11. K. Johnson

12. R. Williams

13. D. Jackson

14. R. Wayne

15. C. Chambers

 
a lot of critics here...anyone want to pick a position or two and give us your list?
I'll take a stab at WR which I think is the worst of them all here. Plax in top 10 is a joke, not even top 25 IMO.....

2. T.O - Take his attitude away and this guy is the best all around WR in the game.

.....
That's like saying take Martial Faulk's age away and he'd still be the all around best running back in the league. It's just not grounded in reality.If you're going to rate players by position, should it come into play whether or not you WANT the player on your TEAM? TO may be a great athelete but he's not worth his big mouth and offline problems. He's too selfish and eventually he's going to split the locker room into factions of who can stand to play with him and who cant.

With the Patriots winning 3/4 Superbowls based on team chemistry this is the formula that works nowadays. I know the Pats wouldnt take TO, and any team based on a similar philosophy would also pass.

Based on that it's very fair to list TO behind the other recievers. Moss may be a punk, but he's nowhere NEAR the level of distraction that TO is.

 
a lot of critics here...anyone want to pick a position or two and give us your list?
I'll take a stab at WR which I think is the worst of them all here. Plax in top 10 is a joke, not even top 25 IMO.1. Randy Moss - Teams HAVE to devote at least 2 players to him every play. Changes the game more than any WR out there taking the Safety out of the box and opening things up for the rest of the offense.

2. T.O - Take his attitude away and this guy is the best all around WR in the game.

3. Torry Holt - Might be the best at adjusting to the ball and makes tough catches look routine.

4. Marvin Harrison - Yeah he's getting old but might be second to none in route running and hands.

5. Hines Ward - Nothing but class and work ethic here. We all know how great of a blocker he is and with such a little frame is not scared to do whatever is asked.

6. Chad Johnson - Has all the tools to be a top 5 WR for the next 7-10 years and plays the game with passion.

7. Andre Johnson - T.O without the attitude IMO. Just needs a consistant Carr to be an elite player.

8. Joe Horn - Could be the only reason anyone thinks A. Brooks is a quality QB. The guy just keep putting up numbers regardless of how bad the offense does.

9. Derick Mason - Has to be the most underrated WR if not player I have seen.

10. (gulp) Nate Burleson - Yes I am from Minnesota, but this guy just knows how to get open (138 rec. last season at UNLV). He also lead the league in yards after catch and it's not because he was benifiting from Moss. Has a great stiff arm and drags defenders for extra yards.

11. K. Johnson

12. R. Williams

13. D. Jackson

14. R. Wayne

15. C. Chambers
I think that Hines Ward is way overvalued. He has never even been the #1 WR on his team, and while you critisize Burress, I think you'll see this year just how much he helped Ward.
 
a lot of critics here...anyone want to pick a position or two and give us your list?
I'll take a stab at WR which I think is the worst of them all here. Plax in top 10 is a joke, not even top 25 IMO.....

2. T.O - Take his attitude away and this guy is the best all around WR in the game.

.....
That's like saying take Martial Faulk's age away and he'd still be the all around best running back in the league. It's just not grounded in reality.If you're going to rate players by position, should it come into play whether or not you WANT the player on your TEAM? TO may be a great athelete but he's not worth his big mouth and offline problems. He's too selfish and eventually he's going to split the locker room into factions of who can stand to play with him and who cant.

With the Patriots winning 3/4 Superbowls based on team chemistry this is the formula that works nowadays. I know the Pats wouldnt take TO, and any team based on a similar philosophy would also pass.

Based on that it's very fair to list TO behind the other recievers. Moss may be a punk, but he's nowhere NEAR the level of distraction that TO is.
Other than the Pats, who would pass? Two other teams that come to mind when talking about "team first" are the Ravens and Eagles- the two teams that wanted TO last offseason.
 
How in the name of God do you make a list of the best wide receivers in football and put T.O. at #6.  Especially when we are talking about a purely football ranking.  IMO this is reason alone to ignore the ranking altogether.
... and then to compound matters rank Plaxico Burress as the 7th best receiver :no: in the NFL. It doesn't appear much thought was put into these rankings. :banned:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I believe I was reading this magazine in a book store this past week and what caught my eye was Grossman's ranking as the number 15 QB. I say I believe because I've read so many mags lately that they are starting to run together. Time to upgrade him or is this further proof that these rankings are a crock?

 
a lot of critics here...anyone want to pick a position or two and give us your list?
I'll take a stab at WR which I think is the worst of them all here. Plax in top 10 is a joke, not even top 25 IMO.1. Randy Moss - Teams HAVE to devote at least 2 players to him every play. Changes the game more than any WR out there taking the Safety out of the box and opening things up for the rest of the offense.

2. T.O - Take his attitude away and this guy is the best all around WR in the game.

3. Torry Holt - Might be the best at adjusting to the ball and makes tough catches look routine.

4. Marvin Harrison - Yeah he's getting old but might be second to none in route running and hands.

5. Hines Ward - Nothing but class and work ethic here. We all know how great of a blocker he is and with such a little frame is not scared to do whatever is asked.

6. Chad Johnson - Has all the tools to be a top 5 WR for the next 7-10 years and plays the game with passion.

7. Andre Johnson - T.O without the attitude IMO. Just needs a consistant Carr to be an elite player.

8. Joe Horn - Could be the only reason anyone thinks A. Brooks is a quality QB. The guy just keep putting up numbers regardless of how bad the offense does.

9. Derick Mason - Has to be the most underrated WR if not player I have seen.

10. (gulp) Nate Burleson - Yes I am from Minnesota, but this guy just knows how to get open (138 rec. last season at UNLV). He also lead the league in yards after catch and it's not because he was benifiting from Moss. Has a great stiff arm and drags defenders for extra yards.

11. K. Johnson

12. R. Williams

13. D. Jackson

14. R. Wayne

15. C. Chambers
I think that Hines Ward is way overvalued. He has never even been the #1 WR on his team, and while you critisize Burress, I think you'll see this year just how much he helped Ward.
Hines Ward is far from overvalued. He is the ultimate team player. He is without a doubt the best blocking WR in the NFL. He was a QB in college, so why not allow him a learning curve at WR? Everyone says Vick hasn't had a lot of experience at QB, but you don't want to say the same for Ward?
 
a lot of critics here...anyone want to pick a position or two and give us your list?
I'll take a stab at WR which I think is the worst of them all here. Plax in top 10 is a joke, not even top 25 IMO.1. Randy Moss - Teams HAVE to devote at least 2 players to him every play. Changes the game more than any WR out there taking the Safety out of the box and opening things up for the rest of the offense.

2. T.O - Take his attitude away and this guy is the best all around WR in the game.

3. Torry Holt - Might be the best at adjusting to the ball and makes tough catches look routine.

4. Marvin Harrison - Yeah he's getting old but might be second to none in route running and hands.

5. Hines Ward - Nothing but class and work ethic here. We all know how great of a blocker he is and with such a little frame is not scared to do whatever is asked.

6. Chad Johnson - Has all the tools to be a top 5 WR for the next 7-10 years and plays the game with passion.

7. Andre Johnson - T.O without the attitude IMO. Just needs a consistant Carr to be an elite player.

8. Joe Horn - Could be the only reason anyone thinks A. Brooks is a quality QB. The guy just keep putting up numbers regardless of how bad the offense does.

9. Derick Mason - Has to be the most underrated WR if not player I have seen.

10. (gulp) Nate Burleson - Yes I am from Minnesota, but this guy just knows how to get open (138 rec. last season at UNLV). He also lead the league in yards after catch and it's not because he was benifiting from Moss. Has a great stiff arm and drags defenders for extra yards.

11. K. Johnson

12. R. Williams

13. D. Jackson

14. R. Wayne

15. C. Chambers
I think that Hines Ward is way overvalued. He has never even been the #1 WR on his team, and while you critisize Burress, I think you'll see this year just how much he helped Ward.
Hines Ward is far from overvalued. He is the ultimate team player. He is without a doubt the best blocking WR in the NFL. He was a QB in college, so why not allow him a learning curve at WR? Everyone says Vick hasn't had a lot of experience at QB, but you don't want to say the same for Ward?
Hasn't Ward been in the league a lot longer than Vick?Anyway, I'm not saying that Ward isn't a great team guy and doesn't do a lot of little things like blocking. But a few years ago he was really underrated (wouldn't have even made a top 30 WR list probably) and then there was this mass hysteria of "OH my gosh, Hes underrated! Lets move him way up in our rankings!" and he became overrated imo. I just can't see a WR who has never proved himself as a #1 and faced the other teams' best CB each week as a top 10 WR.

 
1. Bryant McKinnie?2. No London Fletcher? (MLB) he's only led the league in tackles the last 5 years.3. No Brian Moorman? (P)4. No Sam Adams? (NT)Sorry, I'm a little biased, but also fair.

 
Patriots homer here.Yes, it's 4 months after these rankings came out but...Tedy Bruschi as the #3 OLB? When he wasn't likely to even play this season after his stroke? :eek:

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top