What QBs are in your Championship game? (3 Viewers)

[BigA]

Rivers/Favre(me) vs VY/Romo

 

[greenroom]

Big Ben (me) vs McNabb

 

[Your Mom]

I'll just cover my two "main" leagues since those are the ones that are the most competitive and have the most active owners.KWarner/EManning vs. DBrees/TRomo - 12 team 2QB league. Amazingly the team with DBrees/TRomo was the 3rd seed out of 4 going into the playoffs and barely won his game in week 15 which just happened to be against me.TBrady/JCampbell vs. BRoethlisberger/TRomo - 12 team 2QB league. The team with TBrady/JCampbell made the playoffs as the 4th seed out of 4 by half a game due to a tie earlier in the season.

Here are a couple more 2QB data points:Romo/Flacco(Ryan) vs Schaub/Roethlisberger - A tough Rodgers/Brees team was knocked out last week, along with a Cutler/VY combo.Brees/Flacco(Cutler) vs Rodgers/Eli - Romo/Smith(Ryan) and Rivers/VY knocked out last week.And yes, 2 QB leagues ARE a lot better.

Another 2 Qb leagueA. Smith/D.Garrard (mine) vs P.Manning/C.Palmer.

 

[WKTSWAY]

Cutler (me) vs. P. Manning

I'm obviously not winning because of my QB...

 

[bryhamm]

Rodgers vs. McNabb

dittoalthough i almost beat the rodgers owner and i started cassell

 

[Lascelle]

League #1 (2 QB) - Aaron Rodgers & Alex Smith vs. Tom Brady & Jason Campbell

League #2 - Matt Schaub vs. Brett Favre

League #3 - Aaron Rodgers vs. Kurt Warner

No Brees or Manning here. My teams are highlighted.

 

[ninerfan]

P. Manning (me) vs. Warner (thinking about starting Alex Smith)

Roethlisberger (me) vs. P. Manning (I have Wayne)

McNabb (me) vs. Warner (I have Boldin)

Rivers (me) vs. Roethlisberger

 

[thriftyrocker]

Brady (me) vs. Ben

Rodgers (me) vs. Rivers

Schaub (me) vs. Brees

Brady (me) vs. Rivers

Peyton (me) vs. Alex Smith (benching Schaub?)

Peyton/Flacco (me) vs. Rivers/Ben (2 QB league)

 

[bulger2holt]

Schaub (me) vs Rodgers

12 team redraft

 

[davidwb]

league 1: Rivers (me) vs Manning (the elder)

league 2: Young (me) vs Brady

both are 14-team redraft leagues

 

[MikeApf]

Ben R. vs. Peyton Manning

M

 

[SaintsInDome2006]

My SB opponent and I actually TRADED QB's at the beginning of the year:

I sent P. Manning for Rivers, Jennings and Lynch.

I also could have had Boldin instead of Jennings, and he still has Boldin.

I have been alternately barating myself and celebrating depending on the results.

Lots of irony here (I think that's the word); and I cannot say i mind that Manning is facing the Jets this week and might sit at some point.

 

[Black]

Interesting thread.

Rodgers (me) vs. Rivers.

Warner vs. Cutler (dude is stacked elsewhere...you'd have to be).

 

[thammond]

Smith vs Eli

Smith is currently ranked #23 and Eli is #10 in my league scoring. Not really two heavy weights.

 

[Ted Lange as your Bartender]

1. Brees vs Rivers/Schaub (keeper)

2. Eli vs Peyton (redraft)

3. Semifinals: Rodgers, Ryan, Favre, Warner (keeper)

 

[Mr.Pack]

Jason Campbell or Jay Cutler vs Kurt Warner

 

[Homer]

Peyton vs. McFlabb

Peyton for better or worse as waivers ended last week and Brady Quimm just hit IR

 

[MDPapi]

Manning/Sanchez vs. Schaub/Rivers

 

[Abstract]

Romo (mine) vs. FavreRoethlisberger (mine) vs. McNabb

I have the same......good luckBig Ben vs. McNabb

 

[CataclysmicThunder]

mine / opponent's

Rodgers vs. Romo

Rodgers vs. Warner

Rodgers vs. Smith

Rodgers vs. Flacco

Flacco vs. Rodgers

Rivers vs. P. Manning

Rivers vs. Rodgers

Rodgers vs. Brady

Rivers vs. Brady

Rodgers/Rivers (QB/OP) vs. McNabb

Rodgers vs. Brees

Schaub vs. E. Manning

Rodgers vs. Schaub

 

[Sleeping King]

Brady (me) vs. Hamburglar

 

[The Man with the Plan]

Whole bunch of teams with Matt Schaub at QB.

Moral of the story: Draft Matt Schaub and you probably make the Super Bowl.

 

[Hurl Bruce]

I started out with Palmer and Garrard and now have A Smith, V Young, and J Campbell...

vs.

Rodgers and Favre

 

[Ladsud]

Brees vs Ben

 

[Johnny Ice]

Eli vs. Peyton

Rodgers vs. Rivers

Both redraft leagues

 

[Philo]

Rivers (me) vs. Peyton Manning(12 team)

I've got the other side of this one.

 

[slayer666]

Peyton Manning (me) vs. David Garrard (14 teams)

Philip Rivers (me) vs. Tony Romo (12 teams)

 

[JoeTall]

16 team, 4 keeper:

Freeman (or Cutler, nah (me)) vs Roethlisberger

14 team, 4 keeper:

Rogers vs Roethlisberger (or Farve)

I think I'm the only one in this thread that said Freeman. And for sure the swear word: Cutler.

 

[gilpdawg]

14 teams-Rivers and McNabb

 

[Dragon1952]

I've got Rivers (me) vs Peyton Manning in one and Schaub (me) vs Big Ben or Palmer in the other.

In other leagues where I'm not in the championship game:

Eli or Ben vs McNabb

Rodgers vs Favre/McNabb

Rodgers/McNabb vs Brees

Rodgers vs Brees

Palmer vs Brady

 

[Hendo]

14 teamer Drew Brees(mine) Vs Peyton Manning

12 teamer Ben Rothlisberger(mine) Vs Aaron Rodgers

hoping to get two titles this year

 

[MCguidance]

Rivers/Favre vs Palmer/Campbell

 

[UW72]

12 Team Keeper (Keep 3)

Rodgers (me) vs. Rivers

10 Team Keeper (Keep 3)

Rodgers (me) vs. Romo

 

[chippymaroongold]

Schaub vs. Peyton Manning (me) and/or Alex Smith

 

[LadyBeBop]

Whole bunch of teams with Matt Schaub at QB. Moral of the story: Draft Matt Schaub and you probably make the Super Bowl.

That was my strategy. 3rd round value at a 6th round price.

 

[C-Bound]

Rivers and Peyton.

 

[mattsam]

We have two weeks left and the simis are

Me A Rodgers (#4 seed)- Him E Manning (#1 seed)

#2 seed P Manning- #3 seed McNabb

 

[bigfische]

Schaub vs. Campbell

 

[Winning IS Everything]

League 1: Brees (Edit to add Schaub is my backup QB here) vs Romo 10 Teams

League 2: Schaub (mine) vs Rodgers 10 Teams

Hoping for two titles here also and Schaub was a must have target of mine in drafts this year.

 

[Ministry of Pain]

Peyton vs Rodgers (me)

 

[Menace]

makes you wonder if grabbing a top QB early is worth it. I am glad I did, I'm going with Rodgers.

 

[Go Pack]

Romo vs McNabb (me), 10 team league

P. Manning (me) vs Rodgers, 16 team league

P. Manning vs Rodgers, 10 team league

P. Manning vs Rodgers, 12 team league

Rivers vs Warner, 12 team league

Seems the Peyton/Rodgers is the most popular in my leagues. Lots of people hoping Peyton plays long enough to have a good game this week.

 

[LadyBeBop]

Schaub/McNabb.

Midweek change. Apparently, my opponent is going with Eli over McNabb.So it's Schaub/E. Manning(I'm up against Manning twice in two weeks.)

 

[CentralPA]

Brees (me) v.s. Schaub (them)

 

[Fireballer]

Schaub vs Rivers

 

[Mr. Know-It-All]

Whole bunch of teams with Matt Schaub at QB. Moral of the story: Draft Matt Schaub and you probably make the Super Bowl.

In retrospect, yes. Wasn't he hurt early in the season though? Our Schaub owner wound up barely making the playoffs and I thought it was due to Schaub being hurt early. He then traded away some decent talent for a QB and that is what led to his losing in the semis.

 

[Tat]

He's got Rogers, I have Palmer/Alex Smith.

 

[pacman_fl]

12 team dynasty #2 (start 2) - Brees/Rodgers

This is my team. All TDs are 6 pts and we get distance bonus. My RBs suck (intentionally since this is the 2nd year and the RBs were my "3rd year plan"). The WRs are good too. Pretty stoked about this QB combo for the next few years.As for the thread, definitely some trends. Schaub was a nice pickup for many in re-drafts (including me). Glad he stayed healthy. I don't see many Garrard led teams though

 

[shredhead]

Rodgers vs Rodgers (24 team with 2-12 team conferences)

Rodgers vs Rivers (10 team)

Brady, Eli/Palmer, Romo, Schaub (12 team in semi's these 4/5 still alive) - (I am the Brady owner and actually drafted Rodgers, but traded him for Brady in a package deal, a move that may come back to bite me, but not sure i'd be where I'm at now without the trade)

 

[5-ish Finkle]

Moral of the story: Draft Matt Schaub and you probably make the Super Bowl.

Unless you ran into a Rodgers, Jennings, Finley meat-grinder last week. Rodgers vs. Romo in one league's SB.Roeth vs. Rivers in the other.