Fear & Loathing
Footballguy
I'm going to be revisiting this one shortly in light of the dog fighting scandal. It looks like there's a possibility of suspension there, which would definitely affect Vick's value. So much for turning things around...I realize you have to cut the tiers off at some point, but I don't see this seperation between VY and Vick. If anything, I prefer VY.[71] Michael Vick ATL 27.2 - After finally getting rid of a coach & coordinator who were too stubborn to maximize Vick’s strengths, I went into the offseason very high on Vick compared to the guys ahead of him. But I like what the Patriots & Rams have added to help their QBs lead high-scoring offenses. I still like Vick, especially if you can get him on the cheap while other owners are blaming him & his airport incident for the defense's collapse & poor WR play.
[64] Vince Young TEN 24.3 - I’ve dropped him because I’ve soured a bit on the Titans’ team for ’07. He could certainly go higher if you're drafting from scratch, but the Titans' WR corps inspires zero confidence if you're going for it all this year (as you should be).
Why do you see Vick as better?
Last edited by a moderator: