Ghost Rider
Footballguy
Yes, we can agree to disagree, but to clear up a few points:The 2018 49ers with Garoppolo barely beat an awful Lions team and got smacked by the 8-7-1 Vikings and 12-4 Chiefs. They were not on track to be anything remotely like the 2019 version Garoppolo or no Garoppolo. 2017 was impressive; a small sample size partially affected by teams not having tape on him, but nonetheless impressive.
Not sure where you are getting that the 49ers defense was anything like they were this season though: I vividly remember 9ers fans wanting Robert Saleh fired
As for coaching: I don't like resorting to the eye test but it is pretty obvious to me that Kyle Shanahan is a great coach. Bad coaches don't have an elite running game with a discarded UDFA as their best back.
If Garoppolo is good then why did Shanny trust Matt Ryan to sling the ball around all season in 2016 and break records but literally only calls passes when forced to, despite having worse RBs today?
And when he finally trusted Garoppolo in the Super Bowl....Kansas City thanks him for it
You say Garoppolo can make the Super Bowl when everything is perfect while Dak goes 8-8 as if the Cowboys talent and coaching was anything like the Niners. Cowboys were equal at OL, better at WR and RB and worse at literally every other position group: TE, DL, LBs, CBs, Safeties with Jason Garrett instead of the guy who orchestrated one of the best offenses of the 2000s in Atlanta
This arguement can be flipped pretty easily too: Blake Bortles came as close as you possibly can to going to the Super Bowl with a far worse offensive supporting cast than Jimmy G had, worse coaching and maybe a slightly better defense. Is he also better than Dak/Stafford/Rivers/etc? Because they haven't been to a Super Bowl after all
I know what I saw from Jimmy G: when it mattered most, I was praying for him to have the ball against my team; he got it, and did exactly what I expected him to
49ers had the better roster through and through but unlike the other playoff games they needed Jimmy to cover up how terrible he is for just a little longer: he could not
If we still disagree fine but statistically Dak has an advantage in just about everything on Garoppolo and has done quite a bit of winning considering how screwed the Cowboys appeared with Romo's injuries going into 2016 despite never having a roster as stacked as last year's 9ers were
Running the ball is the staple of the Shanahan offense. Even in 2016 when Ryan was the MVP, he was only 17th in pass attempts, while the Falcons had the 12th most rushing attempts that season (despite not having a running QB, which can always inflate rushing attempts). Just like his dad, who coached my Broncos to two Super Bowl wins, Kyle is all about running the ball, but will ride the hot passing hand when it happens, like with Ryan at times in 2016 or Garappolo in spots last year.
I seriously doubt the game plan in the two NFC playoff games was to have so few pass attempts, but once they got the lead in both, they just hammered away with the running game. And when you are gashing the defense, like they were against the Packers, it is smart to just keep running it down their throats.
The miss to E Sanders late in the Super Bowl was bad, which I have said before. You have to hit that guy for the score, but of course we could flip it and say, "Jimmy G handed the defense a 4th quarter double digit lead and they blew it." It's not as simple as, "The QB blew it." The defense blew it. Or basically, Mahomes took it from them.
Last edited by a moderator: