Prosise for Thielen...??? Update Thielen and 4.6 for 2.12 (rookies) (1 Viewer)

In another dynasty PPR (12 team league), start 1 - 1 - 2 - 1 - 2 flex - 1 - 1.   I am searching for WRs mostly.  Will hunt TE and QB in draft probably, but will take BPA.

QB: Roethlisberger, Bortles, Smith, Garoppolo
RB: Bell, McCoy, Howard, Coleman, Kelley, Stewart, Forte, Washington, Prosise (TS), Sims (IR)
WR: Fitzgerald, Hopkins, Jeffery, Hurns, Moncrief, Britt 
TE: Walker, Gresham, McDonald, Doyle, Z Miller (IR)
K:  Prater, Santos
D:  Arizona

I can leave Prosise on my taxi squad forever (if need be), but we only have two spots.  I need to make room for the IR players, thus planning on dropping Santos and someone...

Been offered Thielen and 2017 4th (rookie) for Prosise and 2017 2nd... I will not deal the picks, but would you deal Prosise for Thielen straight up???  With this team, I have been successful with a win and a runner up this year in the past two years.

I would rather have Prosise than Theilen in the long term.  Thielen had a nice year but the Vikings will never throw enough and I am assuming that Treadwell will eventually earn a starting spot and diminish Theilen's value.  The Seahawks like Prosise and he will be utilized when healthy.  I keep Prosise.

Gally said:

I would rather have Prosise than Theilen in the long term.  Thielen had a nice year but the Vikings will never throw enough and I am assuming that Treadwell will eventually earn a starting spot and diminish Theilen's value.  The Seahawks like Prosise and he will be utilized when healthy.  I keep Prosise.

Click to expand...

Thanks Gally... I think if the picks were reversed, I might think about it.

same owner just came back with Thielen and his 4.6 rookie pick for my 2.12 rookie pick.  I can drop the kicker for the roster spot.

My picks are 1.11, 2.12, 3.12 and 4.12.   I am going to push for his 3.6 pick...  

jwsbowler said:

same owner just came back with Thielen and his 4.6 rookie pick for my 2.12 rookie pick.  I can drop the kicker for the roster spot.

My picks are 1.11, 2.12, 3.12 and 4.12.   I am going to push for his 3.6 pick...  

Click to expand...

I just don't think Thielen is worth giving up the 2.12 pick.  I wouldn't have much confidence in him being a player that I would put in my lineup unless there were significant injuries or bye issues.  He is just a guy and would rather have the 2.12 pick.

Gally said:

I just don't think Thielen is worth giving up the 2.12 pick.  I wouldn't have much confidence in him being a player that I would put in my lineup unless there were significant injuries or bye issues.  He is just a guy and would rather have the 2.12 pick.

Click to expand...

Thanks Gally... I walked away.  A 3rd rounder would be do-able.  

I like Thielen and I think him for 2.12 is a fair offer.  If I needed immediate WR help I would probably do that but I can see arguments either way since I think that is about right value for him.