Would You Do This Dynasty Trade for 2017 1.05? (1 Viewer)

S

Scot from LV

Footballguy

• Feb 3, 2017

• #1

I've been offered 2018 1st, 2nd & 3rd for my 2017 1.05. His team is not great so his 2018 pick is likely to be anywhere from 1.01 to 1.06. 12-team PPR dynasty league.

 

Snorkelson

Footballguy

• Feb 4, 2017

• #2

Flipping a top five pick in a talented class should bring more. The difference between them finishing with the 1.04 or the 1.08 isn't that big of a difference. Even if you get the same 1.05 next year you are only gaining a 2 and 3, which are pretty long shots. 

 

jwsbowler

Footballguy

• Feb 4, 2017

• #3

Snorkelson said:

Flipping a top five pick in a talented class should bring more. The difference between them finishing with the 1.04 or the 1.08 isn't that big of a difference. Even if you get the same 1.05 next year you are only gaining a 2 and 3, which are pretty long shots. 

Click to expand...

Agree with Snorkelson...  I would want this 1.5 pick as the 2018 second is "blah, but has value to a degree".  The 3rd is a "throw away" (opinion) and not worth anything.  So, would you do a 1.5 for (worse case) a 1.8 and 2.8???  I would not.

 

Zyphros

Footballguy

• Feb 6, 2017

• #4

It's the same question as would you trade 1.10 for a 2nd and a 3rd?  No you wouldn't.  1.05 should be late 1st and future late first.  You're not gaining value here. 

 

Warhogs

Footballguy

• Feb 6, 2017

• #5

How good is your team and do your needs fit what's BPA at 1.05?  For me I think this trade is worth consideration. I might try to negotiate the 2018 3rd to be a 2017 2nd if he has a pick in round 2.

 

G

Gally

Footballguy

• Feb 6, 2017

• #6

I think I hold off because you are "guessing" the pick with be in the top half of the draft next year.  I would rather have the for sure 1.05 in a deep draft then a question mark for next year.