1.1 Pick (1 Viewer)

[switz]

I don't dislike Andy, but I have noticed he often challenges other people's posts on players, but rarely provides his own opinion. Just my $0.02

You can't be serious. You're probably the only person on the board that would ever say that I don't provide an opinion.

Hey, that's been my experience. Often and rarely aren't always and never. But from my experience that's how I've seen it.And that's not a knock on you - some people are just more reactive.

 

[switz]

Guy, ok sorry like switz said you don't do rankings, my bad. How guys have McFadden as being the best from the 2008 rook class, not many. That is fact. I made a list, minus you, no one is saying it's not so. So again Sorry I put you on that list. My big rankings is Stewart will not amount too much, that I'm on record for. Ellis was a bonus, for me easy but others like the way He looked. Look that up other Ellis's name sake. So keep up the good work, and no you don't have to post any rankings.

I, for the record, did NOT have McFadden as the #1 RB in the class. Even though I fully expected him to be the #1 RB drafted.I had McFadden at #3, and Stewart at #4. I still stand by both of those rankings. I had Mendenhall as #1, and even though he fell i the draft, in the long term he may be the best RB in the class.I had Jones as the #2, and I feel he has more risk, but also has all the ability needed to be eventually the #1 RB in the class.Stewart I think will be probably the best in the short term, but probably will not have a long career. I just can't see him holding up as a bigger back.McFadden seems to have a lot of straight line speed, and that's it. He can't attack people in the Pros like he did in college. He's perfect for the Raiders system, but I have more concerns about him than Jones or Mendenhall.Now, for ANYONE to say they were right or wrong about players based on the draft results is ridiculous. TONS of people had McFadden going as the first RB in the draft, even if they did not have him ranked #1 on their own board. Do they all deserve a huge pat on the back? Sure... whatever.But it's far far far too early to say who was right on their rankings. Even after the first two seasons it will be too early. Give at least 5, unless someone busts really early.

 

[Yitbos69]

M=S seems to think he was the only person who had McFadden as the #1 RB.......he was not....I did not have him as #1.......I Had them 1)Stewart 2)Mendenhall 3)McFadden......I am not sure what point M=S is trying to make but for the most part he comes across like a tool in every post.....M=S no one cares where you had McFadden ranked and even though I like Stewart and Mendenhall more as NFL backs I never thought either would be taken before McFadden in the NFL draft....

 

[Maroney=Speed]

M=S seems to think he was the only person who had McFadden as the #1 RB.......he was not....I did not have him as #1.......I Had them 1)Stewart 2)Mendenhall 3)McFadden......I am not sure what point M=S is trying to make but for the most part he comes across like a tool in every post.....M=S no one cares where you had McFadden ranked and even though I like Stewart and Mendenhall more as NFL backs I never thought either would be taken before McFadden in the NFL draft....

Not saying I'm the only one, but there's not many who do, you included. Thanks for helping my case.

 

[Sabertooth]

Who knew I was such a lightning rod and/or bellwether?

Be a Man, stand by your rankings. Do us all a favor. Post them here. I bet you won't. I'm on record, will you be?

1. Darren McFadden

/thread

 

[Yitbos69]

M=S seems to think he was the only person who had McFadden as the #1 RB.......he was not....I did not have him as #1.......I Had them 1)Stewart 2)Mendenhall 3)McFadden......I am not sure what point M=S is trying to make but for the most part he comes across like a tool in every post.....M=S no one cares where you had McFadden ranked and even though I like Stewart and Mendenhall more as NFL backs I never thought either would be taken before McFadden in the NFL draft....

Not saying I'm the only one, but there's not many who do, you included. Thanks for helping my case.

Still missing your point.......Unless your point is you think yourself to be AWESOME!...if so got it!