2008 rookies (1 Viewer)

[Unwrittenlaw]

Compared to last year, which positions are more talented than last year's class? (looking at a dynasty standpoint and not redraft)

QB: There isn't much at QB this year compared to last year. Russell,Quinn and Edwards seem like better options than Brohm, Ryan, and Flacco.

RB: Is this year's class talentwise better than AD/Lynch/Selvin?

WR: I don't think this year's WR class will be able to match the talent of CJ/Bowe/Rice/Gonzalez.

TE: How does this year's TE class compare to last year's Zach Miller/Olsen?

DL: The DL seems superior compared to last year's

LB: I don't think the 2008 LB class will be able to match the talent of Willis/Poslus/Beason/Harris.

K: Kickers in the 2007 class weren't very good besides Crosby and Folk. How good are Barth, Mehlhaff and Coutu?

 

[The Jacket]

DL was reasonably weak this year, really. Dorsey is easily the best of the two years, and Ellis may even be better than anything 2007 gave us, but the rest of this class was very uninspiring. The DEs are just awful for the most part, and depth at DT isn't strong.

I would take 2007 all things considered. Dorsey and Ellis keep it close, but 2007's depth is too great (which says something because it wasn't a deep class).