2012 Rookie Class Poll, which duds are you still high / done with (1 Viewer)

[KellysHeroes]

Happens every draft, theres studs and duds. Sometimes the duds take a couple of years to develop, which ones from the list above are you still holding and which have you given up on.

 

[EBF]

Bernard Pierce - 108 carries, 532 yards (4.9 YPC)

How is he even in the "dud" conversation? He did about as well as possible given the circumstances.

 

[KellysHeroes]

Bernard Pierce - 108 carries, 532 yards (4.9 YPC)How is he even in the "dud" conversation? He did about as well as possible given the circumstances.

fixed, moved him out for Keshawn Martin, Hou WR

 

[Fly]

Not on the list but I still like Marvin Jones.

 

[Matt's Eagles]

Not on the list but I still like Marvin Jones.

I like Marvin Jones a lot too...

 

[KellysHeroes]

Not on the list but I still like Marvin Jones.

I like Marvin Jones a lot too...

If you noticed, the players I posted where 4th rounders or higher... and I don't really consider him a dud

 

[cstu]

Not sure how anyone could give up on Stephen Hill already. He still younger than most of the WR's coming out in this draft.Given up on Posey after the Achilles. I'm getting the impression the Texans are planning to draft a WR, which would certainly hurt Posey's chances.

 

[MAC_32]

Lmj isn't going anywhere.

 

[KellysHeroes]

i'm surprised by people giving up on Pead, def a good buy

 

[MAC_32]

i'm surprised by people giving up on Pead, def a good buy

I am surprised Pead owners are giving up, this is why I wanted nothing to do with him though.

 

[msommer]

Although not on the list I still have high hopes fpr Alshon Jeffery

 

[biju]

I'm not ready to give up on Brian Quick, but I really need to see him progress this offseason or he's gone. I knew he was going to be raw but I also expected his athleticism to make up the difference and for him to at least see the field more than he did.A line of 11 catches for 156 yards and 2 TDs isn't exactly inspiring.

 

[cstu]

A lot of people giving up on Wylie too early. The only thing keeping him from being Antonio Brown is a QB and staying healthy.

 

[lbouchard]

I like TJ Graham if BUF drafts a QB, preferably one with a cannon.Also, how can Mo Sanu be considered a dud?

 

[moderated]

Lmj isn't going anywhere.

Except to the bench.

 

[Kree]

I would still take a bit of a flutter on Hill and Jenkins, given they'll likely be cheap.