Hankmoody said:
Fair enough, but I don't understand the point of tracking IR players that are "obscure, but not too obscure", especially when it's just your opinion on what's too obscure. You really think it's worth tracking Harry Douglas over a guy like Dede Westbrook?
You'd be surprised how quickly a "deep dynasty stash" like Jacob Hollister becomes "how did I not pay attention to Gronk's handcuff?" when Gronk sprains his pinky rib and Hollister goes for 10/103/2. Once the games matter there is no distinction between "deep" and "relevant". Every player is one play, certainly one game, away from being a starter for your redraft team. How can you not want that list at your fingertips? I bet a whole bunch of redraft players that had no idea who Tarik Cohen and Chris Carson were on draft day now wishes they had.
I came here to post about Dede Westbrook because that's a team that is in desperate need of weapons and Westbrook is a powder keg waiting to happen (unfortunately in more ways that one, to his potential detriment) and should be on this kind of list when I saw your response to him being listed. If the purpose of the post is to not lose track of players so as to be able to ambush your league mid-season with a great snag I don't understand why you wouldn't track them all. This post is a great concept and I'd be happy to start an "all players" version of it but that's kind of silly to have two of them going.
A couple of points -
A - I completely agree on Westbrook.
But the fact is, he has never played an in an NFL regular season game. So until he is ready to come back, he isn't any more relevant than anyone that may return down the road. I view him like a rookie that will start
NEXT year. Until he returns, he is only a blip on the radar at best, and furthermore, he isn't even slated to return yet....not that I have seen.
Tarik Cohen and Chris Carson were all guys that many of us knew of. In fact anyone that was a Jordan Howard owner that didn't even think about Cohen was a bit silly. In Carson's case there were at least 3 if not 4 people ahead of him on the depth chart.
AND - These guys were never on IR. Reflect on why this thread was made.
But I think you are right. You should start your own post, and include every player you choose. I did this as a favor to a few of the guys around here, that didn't track many of the more popular names that are slated to return,
IN MOST STANDARD FORMATS.
But as often happens in the Shark Pool, someone wants to take issue with whatever someone does, and they want to start going down the hair splitting, and "semantics" road, to try and tinker with the original plan.
This may have been completely innocent, but this is why I had several members contact me last year via PM and say they chose not to come here anymore.
No matter how helpful I was trying to be, its become more of an issue and pain in the ### debating everyone's idea of who is relevant and who is not. That's just not worth my time, as I was just trying to post reminders for people that didn't follow a few things as well as I do mentally.
So you mentioned
This post is a great concept and I'd be happy to start an "all players" version of it but that's kind of silly to have two of them going..
I will delete this one, and there is no need bumping this one up anymore and cluttering up the front page of the Shark Pool.
Everyone please refer to HankMoody's upcoming massive list/thread of players, and sift through the names and determine who is relevant in your leagues, and who is not, and proceed from there.
MODS - Please lock this thread and keep it from cluttering up the front page.
All earlier incomplete lists/posts have been deleted, everyone please refer to HankMoody's upcoming list.
TZM