What’s really disturbing, is that Joe Buscaglia heavily implies that the reason the Bills keep running it up the gut over and over is because
Mcdermott wants it, not because Daboll wants it. If that’s the case, that is a real issue.
Not having Allen throw more and not using Allen as the primary runner was inexcusable and an abject failure. If McDermott’s view I’d success is running the ball unsuccessfully up the middle over and over and over again, this team is doomed.
I saw this article today and, if true, it would explain a whole lot of what's gone wrong this year.
During the off-season, the Bills made a lot of noise about wanting to run the football more. That made sense to me. They were a one-dimensional offense last year. That one-dimensional offense worked extremely well because you had a pro bowl QB who can cover up for missed blocking assignments throwing to two pro bowl WRs. Why hand the ball off to your replacement-level RB when you can just chuck it down the field for Diggs instead? But hey think of how awesome this offense would be if there was a running game to go with it, and wouldn't it be nice to have more balance when the weather gets shaky, etc.
But then Jacksonville decided they wanted Etienne to be their third down back (lol) and we basically just stood pat. No problem. This is still Allen's team and we'll still fling the ball all over the field.
Except as early as week 1 we were calling all these running plays. Including runs on second and long, and runs in the red zone that are stuffed at the LOS almost without exception. And we've just kept doing it even though we know with total, 100% certainty that it isn't going to work because we've been trying this same thing for 12 weeks now and it hasn't succeeded a single time. We're 0-12 at "establishing the running game."
I guess I was sort of blaming Daboll for that, but it would actually make a ton of sense if it was a McDermott thing instead.
Regardless of who's to blame, though, McDermott talks a lot about being a physical team, and about running the ball and stopping the run.
This roster wasn't built to do any of that. Our o-line is fine at pass protection, but it's not a "power running" line. And we don't have a RB who can run behind a line like this or even contribute much in the passing game. And while we've spent a ton of draft capital on our d-line, we don't have any run-pluggers besides Star. And we run the nickel as our base defense. All of this adds up to a team that can't credibly threaten to run the ball and that gets trucked by teams that can.
If this is a philosophical difference between McDermott and Daboll, it's presumably also a philosophical difference between McDermott and Beane, because we haven't even seriously tried to build the 1990s-era team that McDermott keeps talking about. And besides, why would you spend a quarter of a billion dollars on a QB just to hand the ball off? You can just draft a parade of rookies to do that -- it worked for New England after all.