BobbyLayne
Footballguy
Da Gura having fun with thread title this morning,
That's a good observation. Speculative but makes sense. He talked about how he'd push for s couple days and then they'd see how it responded. Obviously the results were not good so he probably has been dealing with an inflammatory condition, and I wouldn't be surprised if he's had it drained a few times this year. Plaxico dealt with bone on bone for years. Those were highly productive seasons. Every player is different, it's mostly pain management at this point.
From the descriptions I heard after the game, it sounds like he's got mallet finger (can't straighten the tip of the middle finger). If true, the treatment is basically to splint it for 6 weeks, and the tendons will grow back together. If the finger bends at any point during that healing process, it will undo any healing that's been done, and the 6 week clock restarts. There's probably a decent chance that playing in the games will cause enough physical trauma to interrupt the healing process, so I doubt it fully heals until the offseason.Caldwell at the presser..no questions about Stafford's finger. Well that is the only thing anyone wants to know!!
There's a lot of ways they could muck it up. Going to be a tough three weeks. Time to find if out how good they really are.Lions fans be like "this ain't real. This real?" Always looking over their shoulder.
Nah, you guys are a legit team. Weird what losing Calvin has done to Stafford. Reminds me of when Favre lost Sharpe. He just took his game to a new level.
Too much history of heartache. It was only 2013 that the Detroit seemed poised for possible playoffs, and lost their last 4. 2014 & 2011 each ended with a loss against (though at) GB Week 17, the former obviously being more costly. They win at least one of the next two and people might start to believe. MightLions fans be like "this ain't real. This real?" Always looking over their shoulder.
Nah, you guys are a legit team. Weird what losing Calvin has done to Stafford. Reminds me of when Favre lost Sharpe. He just took his game to a new level.
Interesting perspective. Based on your experience, do you think the cold weather will affect the finger? Good news is this week is the only game of the remaining three where that should be a factor.From the descriptions I heard after the game, it sounds like he's got mallet finger (can't straighten the tip of the middle finger). If true, the treatment is basically to splint it for 6 weeks, and the tendons will grow back together. If the finger bends at any point during that healing process, it will undo any healing that's been done, and the 6 week clock restarts. There's probably a decent chance that playing in the games will cause enough physical trauma to interrupt the healing process, so I doubt it fully heals until the offseason.
I've had it, and the good news is that it isn't painful at all, and doesn't swell, so other than grip strength, it shouldn't affect his play. He'll wear the split during the games and glove to protect the splint, and should be good to play. Obviously, he has no grip strength in the tip of that finger, so he'll have to compensate with his other fingers. It will probably take a little zip off of his fastball, and make deep throws tougher (but he doesn't throw deep that frequently anyway). With time to practice the new throwing grip, he'll probably be fine.
A real possibility the Lions lose out. They really need to beat the Giants and get in position for the #2 spot. Really three huge games. The NY and GB games are both huge.I think we are basically praying that following arguably inevitable situation doesn't play out ...
We lose to the Giants and Cowboys, before losing to the Packers to hand them the division and leave us out of a wildcard spot at 9-7.
One hopes and prays this doesn't happen but it's also not exactly long odds for us to drop two tough road games then lose the big one at home against Rodgers.
Please Lions, don't do the inevitable !
I predicted 1-4 finish. NO loss. But Detroit handled them pretty well. I was pretty much laughed out of here at the mere suggestion that NYG and GB could beat them. I believe the quote was:A real possibility the Lions lose out. They really need to beat the Giants and get in position for the #2 spot. Really three huge games. The NY and GB games are both huge.
The Packers have lost four in a row and are in free fall.
[They're not] likely to suddenly rip off a big winning streak.
I doubt cold weather will matter much, especially with the glove. There's no pain or stiffness, you just can't straighten the tip of the finger when the injury occurs. Once the splint is applied, it will keep the finger joint extended, so you won't be able to grip the ball with the top section of that finger.Interesting perspective. Based on your experience, do you think the cold weather will affect the finger? Good news is this week is the only game of the remaining three where that should be a factor.
This is pretty much dead on except for the splinting. They may go with more of a flexible splint that would allow some mobility so that he can actually grip the ball and not do his Jay Cutler impression. A flexible splint does open the chance of reinjuryI doubt cold weather will matter much, especially with the glove. There's no pain or stiffness, you just can't straighten the tip of the finger when the injury occurs. Once the splint is applied, it will keep the finger joint extended, so you won't be able to grip the ball with the top section of that finger.
Somehow, I've managed to do this three times playing basketball.
Then again. The ball is oblong.There's a lot of ways they could muck it up. Going to be a tough three weeks. Time to find if out how good they really are.
I'm old enough to remember when the Steelers were the laughingstock of the league. They won their first division title in season number 50. Before Bob Kraft the Patriots were a terrible franchise. I always had hope that it was possible, but there's very little comfort from their history.
There's a path to the #1 seed, but it's predicated on the Cowboys collapsing. That seems unlikely given their style of play and who they face. Two good young teams learning how to win (TB then DET on MNF) at home, then they finish on the road against the imploding Eagles.
I don't think anyone expects the Lions to win out. Their current streak of 5 straight is 2 short of the longest win streaks of my lifetime - 1995 and 2010-11. They won 10 straight 1953-54 and 1934. To get to the number 1 seed, they need to finish with 8 straight wins & have Dallas lost two more times. Both are highly improbable.
But I bring that possibility up because I don't think they can win a playoff road game with their current rushing attack. So to me, the only way to get to Houston is to host two playoff games.
Their only NFL titles (0 SB appearances) were 1935, 1952, 1953 & 1957 - they also lost the Title game in 1954. At some point their history will change, but right now they're one of four teams that have never been to a Super Bowl. Would take some serious magic to make it this year.
Amazing that almost half the league - 13/32, 41% - have never won a Super Bowl.
I agree... Weirder things have happened. 2008 Giants come to mindThen again. The ball is oblong.There's a lot of ways they could muck it up. Going to be a tough three weeks. Time to find if out how good they really are.
I'm old enough to remember when the Steelers were the laughingstock of the league. They won their first division title in season number 50. Before Bob Kraft the Patriots were a terrible franchise. I always had hope that it was possible, but there's very little comfort from their history.
There's a path to the #1 seed, but it's predicated on the Cowboys collapsing. That seems unlikely given their style of play and who they face. Two good young teams learning how to win (TB then DET on MNF) at home, then they finish on the road against the imploding Eagles.
I don't think anyone expects the Lions to win out. Their current streak of 5 straight is 2 short of the longest win streaks of my lifetime - 1995 and 2010-11. They won 10 straight 1953-54 and 1934. To get to the number 1 seed, they need to finish with 8 straight wins & have Dallas lost two more times. Both are highly improbable.
But I bring that possibility up because I don't think they can win a playoff road game with their current rushing attack. So to me, the only way to get to Houston is to host two playoff games.
Their only NFL titles (0 SB appearances) were 1935, 1952, 1953 & 1957 - they also lost the Title game in 1954. At some point their history will change, but right now they're one of four teams that have never been to a Super Bowl. Would take some serious magic to make it this year.
Amazing that almost half the league - 13/32, 41% - have never won a Super Bowl.
You were laughed at for the 1-4 prediction, and since they are already 2-0 you can kiss that prediction goodbye. Now they might still lose their next three, but I think they eek out one. Yeah, the Lions are not a great team, but there are no great teams.I predicted 1-4 finish. NO loss. But Detroit handled them pretty well. I was pretty much laughed out of here at the mere suggestion that NYG and GB could beat them.
Yes, but if they lose out, I was 1 penalty and an unpredictable overtime from being rightYou were laughed at for the 1-4 prediction, and since they are already 2-0 you can kiss that prediction goodbye. Now they might still lose their next three, but I think they eek out one. Yeah, the Lions are not a great team, but there are no great teams.
Who was predicting 4-1?? Lions fans know better than that.Yes, but if they lose out, I was 1 penalty and an unpredictable overtime from being right2-3 is a lot closer to 1-4 than 4-1, which is what most people in here were predicting.
If anything, no one has been right about them. Sure, the record speaks for itself but to completely dismantle the Saints and then to come back and need the help of the refs to fend off Chicago... the fact that people were so over-confident in here is laughable. Yeah, I think they will win the division. At first I did not think so but clearly Minnesota doesn't want to win it, and Green Bay is just starting to figure themselves out, but we've see that before (see Atlanta and then what followed).
This week will be very telling. I think you guys should be quite concerned about Stafford's injury. That is very unfortunate; he's had a great season and is undoubtedly an MVP candidate if he can finish strong (I don't think he will win though). Been a crazy season. You're right, there are no great teams. Look at the NFC... Dallas and even they are proven to be mortal... After that it's all basically the same.
I'll eat my sock if Detroit takes the division. not happening with that defense.
I hope a wet ball doesn't make things even more difficult for Stafford's injured hand.BobbyLayne said:Saturday forecast is supposed to be 42-44. That's pretty comfortable but 90% chance of rain, wind 5-7.
did I mention I was wearing one of those edible socks that day?BobbyLayne said:I'll eat my sock if Detroit takes the division. not happening with that defense.
I'll be at the game. Should be miserable.I hope a wet ball doesn't make things even more difficult for Stafford's injured hand.
Who was doing that ? Nobody in here was doing that. People were hopeful, maybe even a little confident that they would find a way to win 2-3 out of their last 5, but nothing more. I think you completely fail to understand the mindset of a Lions fan, to be honest.Dr. Brew said:Yes, but if they lose out, I was 1 penalty and an unpredictable overtime from being right2-3 is a lot closer to 1-4 than 4-1, which is what most people in here were predicting.
If anything, no one has been right about them. Sure, the record speaks for itself but to completely dismantle the Saints and then to come back and need the help of the refs to fend off Chicago... the fact that people were so over-confident in here is laughable. Yeah, I think they will win the division. At first I did not think so but clearly Minnesota doesn't want to win it, and Green Bay is just starting to figure themselves out, but we've see that before (see Atlanta and then what followed).
This week will be very telling. I think you guys should be quite concerned about Stafford's injury. That is very unfortunate; he's had a great season and is undoubtedly an MVP candidate if he can finish strong (I don't think he will win though). Been a crazy season. You're right, there are no great teams. Look at the NFC... Dallas and even they are proven to be mortal... After that it's all basically the same.
probably. I just got an impression of rose colored glasses. you're probably right.Who was doing that ? Nobody in here was doing that. People were hopeful, maybe even a little confident that they would find a way to win 2-3 out of their last 5, but nothing more. I think you completely fail to understand the mindset of a Lions fan, to be honest.
This is key. Stafford's ability to put the ball in places other QBs cannot has been a big reason he's been able to engineer many of the 4Q comebacks. If he can't do that the Lions are in trouble.Anxious to see how Stafford's finger plays out.
PFF:CBS Top Ten this morning:
1. New England
2. Dallas
3. Kansas City
4. Detroit
5. Oakland
6. Seattle
7. Atlanta
8. NY Giants
9. Denver
10. Pittsburgh
Told the media this morning the game plan won't change at all.Whatever setup he had seemed to work for him. Stafford took his usual diet of reps during the 20 minutes open to the media, and threw to a variety of wideouts. His short passes were crisp and on line, then he stretched out to about 40 yards before practice was closed to reporters.
I'm thinking about a Lions game that's 3 days away in the middle of December. This can only mean 1 thing, I'm dead.
Obviously I have tons of Lions fans at work, around the 'hood and at church. None of them think the Giants will win another game this year.I wish I had positive thoughts about this game. I do not. This is not a good matchup. On the road vs. a team fighting for a playoff spot/positioning is never a great start. Couple that with our strengths on offense (passing/pass protect) are exactly what their defense does well (secondary/rush the QB).
I will say that nothing about NYG's offense scares me (including OBJ). This game boils down to how well our defense can keep us in the game. I just see too many 3 outs on offense to make it happen.
NYG 27 Caldwells 20
Since we are Lions fans and have suffered through so many years of ineptitude, we are entitled to dream and if we are going to dream, we may as well dream big.I was really nervous about the Saints game...much more than this one. Going back to before Thanksgiving, I thought this was the most winnable of their "tougher" games. I guess I worry more about teams with a prolific offense. I believe this will be a very close game. The Lions really need to win and I think they will.
Lions 20, Giants 16.
There is no question the Lions have flaws. If they play well, they can definitely beat the Giants. I don't expect them to win at Dallas but it sure would be fun to watch that game if we beat the Giants and Tampa Bay beats Dallas. It is beyond belief to even think about that being possible.Futz said:3000
I'd like to dream big but I just don't think they are a complete enough team unless Ansah reincarnates 2015, Levy becomes a playmaker again and Washington can slash his way to 70-80 yards a game going forward AND stay healthy. Not likely but it'll be fun to watch some important December games for a change.
I just saw a national group (maybe NBC sports not sure) where 6 out of 8 X-spurts expect Big Blue to win. Even in the Lions hometown papers, 3/4 or 4/5 expect the NYG to prevail. Fine by me. I hope the Lions players see that & it fires them up.Since we are Lions fans and have suffered through so many years of ineptitude, we are entitled to dream and if we are going to dream, we may as well dream big.
With that in mind, lets assume the Lions beat the Giants (and that is not dreaming, it is definitely realistic). Dallas plays a very good and smoking hot Tampa Bay team. If Dallas loses and we win, that Dallas game could be for home field throughout the playoffs.
Even a big dreamer could never imagine that being possible. But it is.![]()
Ebron has physical gifts but I do tend to agree that at this stage of his career, he's a losing type of player. 3rd and 2 and he runs a 0 yard route and gets tackled immediately at a pivotal point of the game. He also heard footsteps and dropped another important 3rd down play. He reminds me so much of Vernon Davis it's scary. He flashes but doesn't make the simple yet winning plays in a game. You just hope he puts it all together at one point but it may not be here.Eric Ebron is worthless...the guy has some skill but he can`t block at all and he is a losing type of player. If you watched the game close today not only did he have another huge drop but he gives up on plays and was blown up at the line 4-5 times when a decent block could have netted some positive yards.
Why was Stafford still throwing and running from the Lion 30 with 20 seconds left down by 2 scores? That late hit could have taken him out. Stafford is tough as nails though...
You mean Vernon Davis at the beginning of his career right? That guy was awesome after Singeltary jumped all over him. The year Crabtree got hurt Davis was awesome, I remember him having some monster games in the playoffs too. I think one of the games he caught the game winning touchdown against the Saints.Futz said:Ebron has physical gifts but I do tend to agree that at this stage of his career, he's a losing type of player. 3rd and 2 and he runs a 0 yard route and gets tackled immediately at a pivotal point of the game. He also heard footsteps and dropped another important 3rd down play. He reminds me so much of Vernon Davis it's scary. He flashes but doesn't make the simple yet winning plays in a game. You just hope he puts it all together at one point but it may not be here.
I don't think you see any of the top QBs sitting when they are in a 2 score or less deficit. Stranger things have happened. This team obviously misses Theo. He's the chain mover.