6 Keeper League (1 Viewer)

[Chucklar]

Okay I’m stuck on my 6th keeper, please help! 12 team H2H, full point PPR & full point per carry, 1 point per 10 rush yards, 5 receive yards. Here’s who I’m keeping and who I’m stuck on:

Keeping:
Josh Allen, Buf.
Amon St. Brown, Det.
Jonathan Taylor, Indy
Isiah Pacheco, KC
Garrett wilson, NYJ

I am currently thinking Dalton Kincaid because of TE scarcity but I also have Michael Pittman, Jr. and DK Metcalf. Thoughts? Thanks all!!!

 

[Gally]

What are your starting requirements? Are there any limitations to the keepers (years kept, salary cap, round lost)?

Without knowing those I would rank them this way:

1. Pittman
2. Metcalf
3. Kincaid

I wouldn't force Kincaid unless people hoard TE's and there won't be anybody left that has the potential to be top 10. Its really close between Pittman/Metcalf but I lean Pittman as I think he will be more consistent in the PPR format. Kincaid is a step below those two for me.

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

Shouldn't he just keep Kincaid so he has a TE? Also shouldn't he keep Pittman over Wilson?

 

[Gally]

Shouldn't he just keep Kincaid so he has a TE? Also shouldn't he keep Pittman over Wilson?

Depends on how many TE's are being kept with regards to Kincaid. If he can draft an equivalent TE (meaning top 10-ish) then I would rather keep Pittman over Kincaid. (Depending on starting lineup requirements).

 

[Chucklar]

What are your starting requirements? Are there any limitations to the keepers (years kept, salary cap, round lost)?

Without knowing those I would rank them this way:

1. Pittman
2. Metcalf
3. Kincaid

I wouldn't force Kincaid unless people hoard TE's and there won't be anybody left that has the potential to be top 10. Its really close between Pittman/Metcalf but I lean Pittman as I think he will be more consistent in the PPR format. Kincaid is a step below those two for me.

 

[Chucklar]

There are no limitations, it’s just straight up 6 keepers. Sorry I was so slow and on getting back to you with this!!!

 

[Chucklar]

Shouldn't he just keep Kincaid so he has a TE? Also shouldn't he keep Pittman over Wilson?

These are the questions of the day!!! Honestly I’m between Pittman and Kincaid, thinking of passing on Metcalf…

 

[Big Nate]

Initially I lean Kincaid to lock up a top TE and not have to worry. BUF is lacking pass catchers and I'd definitely take the risk on Kincaid due to his upside. He's only going to get better and there is a lot of opportunity in BUF.

Second option is Pittman but I would try to trade Pittman and Metcalf for draft pick(s). If you can get some sort of draft pick it is better than throwing them back in the pool and getting nothing.

Convince people Pittman/Metcalf is better than their worst keeper and they need some studs.

For those that say don't keep Kincaid here is my issue - but it does depend how many TEs are kept: Kincaid is going to be picked in the first round for sure. Now if you don't draft him you are picking up whatever TEs are left and you feel you need to possibly reach to get a good one or you just punt TE and hope for the best.

There will be lots of good options for WRs in your first round - someone probably comparable to Pittman or at least a young rookie with tons of upside and lots of value. This is a great young WR rookie crew this year.

 

[Chucklar]

Okay all, I traded Metcalf for a second round pick, so now I’m down to Pittman or Kincaid…talk me into either one!!! I’m leaning in a direction but want to see what y’all think…thanks so much!!!

 

[Big Nate]

Okay all, I traded Metcalf for a second round pick, so now I’m down to Pittman or Kincaid…talk me into either one!!! I’m leaning in a direction but want to see what y’all think…thanks so much!!!

Nice work on the trade. I was in a lot of these 4-5 keeper leagues and I have always liked getting something for a player rather than just sending back a top player to the draft and not getting anything.

For your last keeper when do you have to make the decision? It isn't bad right now to have an extra top keeper just in case someone has a significant pre-season/training camp injury.

Closer to the keeper date you can made that decision. I'm struggling between Kincaid and Pittman if I had to make a decision. I'd like to keep both....

 

[Chucklar]

That’s a very good point. I have quite a while before I have to choose…mid-late August I think. And agreed, it’s nice getting something instead of just throwing him back…! Thanks for the help!!!

 

[Gally]

1. Pittman
2. Metcalf
3. Kincaid

I wouldn't force Kincaid unless people hoard TE's and there won't be anybody left that has the potential to be top 10. Its really close between Pittman/Metcalf but I lean Pittman as I think he will be more consistent in the PPR format. Kincaid is a step below those two for me.

I still believe what I wrote here. I would go Pittman unless there are a ton of TE's being kept.

 

[Big Nate]

1. Pittman
2. Metcalf
3. Kincaid

I wouldn't force Kincaid unless people hoard TE's and there won't be anybody left that has the potential to be top 10. Its really close between Pittman/Metcalf but I lean Pittman as I think he will be more consistent in the PPR format. Kincaid is a step below those two for me.

I still believe what I wrote here. I would go Pittman unless there are a ton of TE's being kept.

Yeah can't go wrong with Pittman. #1 target in INDY. Safer pick especially in PPR. Good point.

 

[Chucklar]

1. Pittman
2. Metcalf
3. Kincaid

I wouldn't force Kincaid unless people hoard TE's and there won't be anybody left that has the potential to be top 10. Its really close between Pittman/Metcalf but I lean Pittman as I think he will be more consistent in the PPR format. Kincaid is a step below those two for me.

I still believe what I wrote here. I would go Pittman unless there are a ton of TE's being kept.

Yeah can't go wrong with Pittman. #1 target in INDY. Safer pick especially in PPR. Good point.

Definitely a good point…!!! Just torn with TE scarcity. I guess if decisions were easy it wouldn’t be as fun LOL…!!!

 

[fooserman55]

I would keep Kincaid. His stats are going to improve a lot over last year, especially with Diggs gone, and the fact that you would be stacking him with Allen is a big plus.

 

[Tonycarpenter]

Okay I’m stuck on my 6th keeper, please help! 12 team H2H, full point PPR & full point per carry, 1 point per 10 rush yards, 5 receive yards. Here’s who I’m keeping and who I’m stuck on:

Keeping:
Josh Allen, Buf.
Amon St. Brown, Det.
Jonathan Taylor, Indy
Isiah Pacheco, KC
Garrett wilson, NYJ

I am currently thinking Dalton Kincaid because of TE scarcity but I also have Michael Pittman, Jr. and DK Metcalf. Thoughts? Thanks all!!!

Keep Kincaid with that group.
Try to trade Pacheco for value. I don't see it getting any higher.