6 man trade help, WHIR (1 Viewer)

[WhiteRob443]

OK so for my 12 team standard league, I'm thinking of making a trade to the Brees owner, involving my B.Cooks, and need advice.  Really want to try and get Graham from him.  Here's our team's

My team

QB-Carr

RB-Elliott, Ingram, Foster, D.Johnson (CLE), & A.Morris

WR-Cooper, Cooks, D.Thomas, Shepard, & Hurns

TE-J.Thomas & Pitta

His team

QB-Brees & Tannenhill

RB- CJA, Hill, Crowell, B.Allen, & D.McFadden (no idea why)

WR- Bryant, Baldwin, Pryor, DGB, & Coleman (IR)

TE- Graham

The trade I thought of doing

My B.Cooks, J.Thomas, & A.Foster

for

His D.Bryant, J.Graham, & I.Crowell

I feel it's farily even, with me slightly winning since Foster is still a question mark, but Bryant is out til week 8 most likely and Foster should return soon, maybe even this week, Thomas has done well in JAC, and maybe the Brees/Cooks pairing will sound good to him.  Is this a good trade for both?  Should I offer more (possibly Hurns?)? or should I not even try for it?

 

[Forestbull]

I would probably do the trade(on your side) 

The only thing I worry about is trading Cooks at his absolute lowest. His last two years in the 2nd half of the season, he went crazy. 

I also hate trading for injured players, especially injured players with injury history (although Foster is as well) also Dez might more of a decoy a lot of the season when he does play. 

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749554-frank-gore-for-alshon-or-cooks/

 

[KarmaPolice]

That's a tough one.  I have stared at it for awhile and gone back and forth, which I guess means that I think it's fair-ish.

What it's boiling down to for me are the WRs.  I would easily rather have Crowell and Graham. 

The Saints are a hard one.  Brees and Cooks are a lot better at home than away, but after Car, I believe their home games are Denv, Seattle, and LA - oof.   I think Dez is still a little bit away from returning and when he does, is he going to be effective?  Will get crabby and washed up in that QB debate that is brewing in Dallas?  Like the other poster said - you are selling low on Cooks.

I would throw that offer out and see what the response is.  I think the Wrs are wash and I like RB/TE more for you.