Massive Trade - Help! WHIR (1 Viewer)

[Mkha2240]

10 Team - 1 Pt PPR - QB / 3 WR / 2 RB / 1 TE / 1 Flex / 1 Dst / 1 K / 6 Bench
Offered by another guy who is 3-3 (I am as well 3-3) after Week 6 of football:
Send (5):      Gurley, Cooks, Boyd, Hines, Thompson
Receive (5): Kamara, Diggs, Hyde, Sanu, AP

My Team:
QB: Netwon | WR: Cooks, Boyd, D Thomas, Shepard, Fuller, Jordy | RB: Gurley, D Freeman, Hines, Thompson, Foreman | 
TE: Ebron | K: Parkey | DST: Minnesota, Carolina

His Team:
QB: Brady, Brees | WR: Diggs, Sanders, Watkins, Sanu, Cobb, D Jackson | RB: Kamara, Hyde, AP, Lewis
TE: Gronk, Uzomah | K: Crosby | DST: New England

This guy has lost his last two, I've won my last two. The way I see it is Gurley > Kamara (Kamara is now in a committee), Boyd is equally putting numbers as Diggs (30-40 yards fewer & 1 TD less than AJ Green, more yardage & 1 TD more than Diggs - yes I know, Diggs ceiling is higher but Boyd has been performing equally as well and consistently), Cooks > Sanu, Hyde > Hines (Hines is a great receiving back but with Mack in, it seems shaky. Hyde has hit his floor the last two games, but its still Hyde). AP > Thompson (solely because Thompson has been injured but AP also has that shoulder strain so that's a big iffy for me).
I personally don't believe I should accept this trade but I would like some outside opinions.

Leave a link and I'll reply to your question!

 

[shoecrew22]

I like your team better as is

 

[beerbuff]

I'd pass, it would destroy your WR's and Gurley is better than Kamara.

 

[notoriousbill]

I pass without hesitation

 

[Gally]

I want the Gurley side and it's not even a consideration to go the other way. 

I would do something like Gurley & Hines for Kamara, Hyde and Diggs.  That is a little closer for me.  That would give you another serviceable RB without dropping too far off from Gurley.  It also gives you a solid 3 WR set in Cooks, Boyd and Diggs. 

 

[Mkha2240]

First off, thanks everyone for replying - I had the notion of rejecting the offer but always like to see what others say/what others say to counter with. Appreciate it!
 

I want the Gurley side and it's not even a consideration to go the other way. 

I would do something like Gurley & Hines for Kamara, Hyde and Diggs.  That is a little closer for me.  That would give you another serviceable RB without dropping too far off from Gurley.  It also gives you a solid 3 WR set in Cooks, Boyd and Diggs. 

Thanks! It's so hard to trade away Gurley especially with how dominant and consistent he's been; however that trade does seem even though I doubt he'll take the offer - literally said that Sanu is currently better than Cooks (with the one game he was out and last game) and wants to offer 4 for my 5. I just laughed at him. But if it comes down to the wire, I'll definitely counter him with that - thanks again!