I think a lot can be learned from the stats chart. It can help you try to determine some reasonable type of projection range for a player.
First I think most people agree that AJ GReen is pretty talented regardless of his QB situation.
I wanted to find out of talent can rise about a situation to create top 5 WR #s.
I looked up 2 stats in Data Domintor from 2004 -2011. TOP REC seasons and TOP TD Seasons. for WR/TE.
Data shows Top 200 for each.
I wanted to see:
-Who was scoring TDs.
-How often they repeated top #s.
-What situation WR/TE was in when it happened.
-Was QB elite level? Was player elite level?
For TDs...only Antonio Gates appears in all 8 seasons from 2004-2011 for TDs 2011 being his lowest 7Tds. 2004 highest 13Tds.
TD scorers typically had a top QB throwing to them.
Some larger, possession WRs like T.O. didn't matter which QB was throwing. Span of several great years.
Short WRs didn't score as often except for Marvin Harrison. They still did well but he TD production could vary. Probably lack Redzone targets like big WRs. But you can't just be big...you have to be big and good....
Let's Start with TDs...I wanted to see who are the players that seem to do this...and how often.
#1 Randy Moss 23, 13, 11, 8 appeared 4 times. (55 TD)
#2 Gronk 17, name appears 1 time but is #2 overall in TD performances as TE. (
#3 Muhsin Muhammed 16 in 2004...one time.
#4 Megatron 16 2011, 12 2008, 12 2010. 3 times. Still young.(40td)
#5 Braylon Edwards 16, 2007 7 2010.
#6 Terrell Owens 15, 14, 13, 10, 9 appears 5 times. Very consistent as of a few years ago. (61tDS)
#7 Marvin Harrsion 15TD in 2004, 12 in 2005, 12 in 2006. 3 times (39td)
#8 Jordy Nelson 15TD 2011.
#9 Dwayne Bowe 14TD 2010, 7 in 2008.
#10 Vernon Davis 13TD 2009, 7TD 2010.
#11 Antonio Gates 13TD 2004, 10TD 2010, 2005, 9TD 2006, 2007, 8TD 2008, 2009, 7TD 2011. 8 times (74 TDs)
#12 Jennings 12TD 2007, 2010, 9TD 2011, 2008...4xtimes.
#13 Fitzgerald 12TD 2009, 2008, 10TD 2005, 2007, 8TD 2004, 2011, 6TD 2006, (66)
#14 Reggie Wayne 12TD, 10Td 10TD 9TD. 4 x times
There are a few others but That's enough.
Tom Brady is responsible for top TDs #1, #2,
GB QB responsible for Jennings, Jordy.
PManning Harrison/Wayne.
Rivers/Brees responsible for Antonio Gates
Alex Smith for Davis
Various QBs for Terrell Owens. ROMO, Garcia, McNabb.
Kurt Warner/Jake Plummer & other responsible for Fitzgerald
Stafford for Calvin Johnson
muhsin...not sure.
Bowe has had Matt Cassell, maybe trent edwards.
Most top performances though have had an elite QB of sorts.
This seems to indicate that AJ Green will need an elite QB to be a consistent performer in this range.
NEXT I LOOKED AT RECEPTIONS I didn't indicate the years.
#1. WELKER 123, 122, 112, 112, and 86....5 times.
#2. Andre Johnson 115, 103, 101, 85, 79...also 5 times.
#3. Roddy White 113, 100, 88, 85, 83, 5 times
#4. TJ Housh: 112, 92, 90, 79, 78, 73,
#5. Reggie Wayne 110, 104, 100, 86, 83
#6. Steve Smith NYG: 107, see other steve smith too for other years explanation
#7. BMarshall: 104, 102, 101, 86, 82 (NOTICE drop off when at MIAMI)
#8. Steve Smith CAR 103. Not sure which is which after this...not labeled...but som smaller #s and in the 80s rec seasons.
#9. Fitzgerald
#10. Derrick Mason
#11. T HOLT
#12. A BOLDIN
#13. Tony Gonzalez TE
#14. J Witten 100
That rounds out the 100 REC WR/TEs.
It gets deep through the 90+rec.
Welker has 3 of top 5 REC seasons 2009, 2011 2008...but total TDs = 16 combined.
Gronkowski had 17 TD in 2011...on 90 REC.
Plaxico had 12 TD one season on 70 REC. Not bad.
Once again Tom Brady was responsible for the TOP performances.
Then Matt Schaub for AJ whatever for others.
Surprisingly, Brees wasn't in here. Likely due to distribution. Colston and Graham were near the top on these lists. and Brees did throw to Gates before RIVERs. Colston's injury issues haven't helped consistency.
A really good situation it seems can get a player to a certain level. Let's say 80+/- catches.
A really talented WR regardless of the situation seems to be able to get to about 80+/- receptions even in bad situations. ( Marshall, MIA)
In all likelihood it takes both a great situation and talent for the WR to produce and 90-100+ rec and 10+ TDs season for more than one season. And these odds increase when the player is over 6ft tall.
(Size Matters in Red Zone targets...no surprise...except for Marvin Harrison).
About 1 year ago. No one thought Dalton would be any good and AJ Green would suffer because of it.
Dalton did well for Rookie as did Green AND the question seems to be How Good can Dalton be?
Let's say Dalton becomes elite-ish...Romo/Rivers/Schaub/Eli range. It's possible to produce high #s.
Many of those big seasons came from top QBs.
Full seasons in great situation should result in 100+ rec 12-15td season.
Down seasons by the same token should still be in higher range. 80 rec 8 TD or few REC and lots of TDs and lots of REC and few TDs.