Benson for Cam Newton (1 Viewer)

[flinstones]

t's a 10 team league, start 11. 1-qb, 3-rb, 3-wr, 1-te, 1-k, 1-def, 1-flex(rb,wr,te,k)

1-ppr(rb,wr,te) 1 pt per 10 rushing/rec, 10 pts for 200 yds pass(1 pt per 10 thereafter)

Team A is 4-0 in it's conf.

Team B is 0-4 in other conf.

They are brothers.

Trade offer: team b- benson for team a-newton(newton avg 43/week in our league to benson's 12)

Team a's argument is he wants benson to back up scott or vice versa so he has the starter whom ever it be.

It's the only offer team A has had.

Team A:

Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB

Newton, Cam CAR QB ®

Barber, Marion CHI RB

Green-Ellis, BenJarvus NEP RB

Mathews, Ryan SDC RB

McGahee, Willis DEN RB

Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB (Q)

Scott, Bernard CIN RB

Tomlinson, LaDainian NYJ RB

Austin, Miles DAL WR (Q)

Green, A.J. CIN WR ®

Maclin, Jeremy PHI WR

Edwards, Braylon SFO WR

Wallace, Mike PIT WR

Clark, Dallas IND TE

Graham, Jimmy NOS TE

Gronkowski, Rob NEP TE

Bryant, Matt ATL PK

Bears, Chicago CHI Def

Cowboys, Dallas DAL Def

Team B:

Ryan, Matt ATL QB

Gore, Frank SFO RB (P)

Hunter, Kendall SFO RB ®

Benson, Cedric CIN RB

Jackson, Steven STL RB

Johnson, Chris TEN RB

McCluster, Dexter KCC RB

McFadden, Darren OAK RB

Spiller, C.J. BUF RB (P)

Amendola, Danny STL WR

Collie, Austin IND WR

Moss, Randy FA WR (P)

Ford, Jacoby OAK WR

marshall, Brandon MIA WR

Moore, Lance NOS WR

Smith, Steve CAR WR

Thomas, Mike JAC WR

Winslow, Kellen TAM TE

Gould, Robbie CHI PK

Chargers, San Diego SDC Def

0

 

[AmosMoses]

I would approve of you quitting fantasy football.

 

[Phil4]

Do you reward point for punt or kick return yards ?

 

[Touchdown Syndrome]

You must be new!

Welcome!

We here at the SP ("Shark Pool") vehemently oppose ALL TRADES unless, of course, everyone can absolutely agree on 100% equal value for each side.

Our motto: Don't let owners determine player values or team needs...that's anarchy!

(PS...awesome first post )

 

[Foxhound]

No, for Newton at this point he is giving you something closer to Gore, SJax, or bundle something else with Cam to get McFadden. You could also go Cam for Chris Johnson only if you think he can break out of his slump. You are selling off a top 5 QB waaaaay too low for someone like Benson. You need to get a top 10 RB for him at least.

Edit* I wouldn't even take SJax for Newton...

 

[Touchdown Syndrome]

No, for Newton at this point he is giving you something closer to Gore, SJax, or bundle something else with Cam to get McFadden. You could also go Cam for Chris Johnson only if you think he can break out of his slump. You are selling off a top 5 QB waaaaay too low for someone like Benson. You need to get a top 10 RB for him at least.Edit* I wouldn't even take SJax for Newton...

Bingo!And because YOU think that's what Newton is worth, logically EVERYONE should think the same way, regardless of their roster/team needs/personal opinion. Therefore....VETO!

 

[Wrigley]

I farted

 

[HAM]

I farted

You alright?

 

[SlaX]

Team A will likely never play Newton except for the bye and needs RB depth (especially in a start 3RB, 4 w/ flex situation). Team B has RB depth and is looking to upgrade his QB situation.

What's the problem here? Relationship has nothing to do with it.

Regardless of what Cam is getting per week, how much is that worth sitting on the bench?

 

[runner06]

The general feeling from posters here (including myself) is that trades shouldn't be vetoed unless you suspect collusion.

 

[theoneandonly]

This is a start 3 rb 1flex league. Starting rbs should be pretty valued. Only 1 qb is playing a week.

Team A has Rodgers so hes not playing Newton. Benson is a guy he will use more often even with the suspension that may not even come.

Team B is also 0-4 and could use a stronger qb. This trade is fair enough. Let people manage there own teams.

 

[Buffaloes]

trade veto forum