Bernard Scott v. Deji Karim v. Delone Carter (1 Viewer)

[kimbosliced]

So, I'm in an espn format standard 10 team league. Got one spot for any of the three. More so looking for the upside play that has legitimate chance to make a difference this year. Whom should I go with?

I picked up Scott initially because of FG rankings. But, I'm having buyer's remorse. Thoughts?

 

[CentralPA]

Maybe Karim because of the worries about MJD's knee? I often look at the starter and what his history is with injuries or if he's coming off something serious to help answer a question like this.

And not to be a #### but this type of question should go in the Assistant Coaches forum.

 

[kimbosliced]

Sorry. New here. How can I move the post?

 

[JoeSteeler]

Sorry. New here. How can I move the post?

Welcome to the forums. It's no big deal just start the same topic in the asst coach forum.

 

[Maui Monster]

I think this is a valid question in Shark Pool. He is not asking who to start and the question of 3 of the best backups out there and who is worth rostering is a question we would all want to know.

Cin looks like a train wreck. I can;t see them being any good until later in season. Karim and Carter both have RB's ahead of them with injury history. I have to believe that Carter would be more valuable with supporting cast around him. Karim is in a good position, but he does not seem to have the talent like MJD or Jennings to make a bad team better.

 

[mr roboto]

If Cincy were a normal organization I'd go Scott. Unfortunately they seem to be committed to making the wrong decisions as a mater of principle. Carter has more in front of him.

Barring an injury I don't see any of them doing much.

 

[CentralPA]

I think this is a valid question in Shark Pool. He is not asking who to start and the question of 3 of the best backups out there and who is worth rostering is a question we would all want to know.Cin looks like a train wreck. I can;t see them being any good until later in season. Karim and Carter both have RB's ahead of them with injury history. I have to believe that Carter would be more valuable with supporting cast around him. Karim is in a good position, but he does not seem to have the talent like MJD or Jennings to make a bad team better.

OK, my bad. Guess it sounded more like a lineup question to me.

 

[kimbosliced]

Thanks for the help so far. Roy Helu is also available if that matters.

 

[JoeSteeler]

I think this is a valid question in Shark Pool. He is not asking who to start and the question of 3 of the best backups out there and who is worth rostering is a question we would all want to know.Cin looks like a train wreck. I can;t see them being any good until later in season. Karim and Carter both have RB's ahead of them with injury history. I have to believe that Carter would be more valuable with supporting cast around him. Karim is in a good position, but he does not seem to have the talent like MJD or Jennings to make a bad team better.

I see your point and it is a fine line i guess.

 

[JoeSteeler]

I like Carter out of those listed. He can score points as the Colts short yardage back and could be a RB1* IMO if Addai gets injured.

*assuming Manning gets back to 100%