Best all-time FF starting line-up (1 Viewer)

[Zigg]

Syracuse:

McNabb

Brown, Csonka

Harrison, Monk

Mackey

If you want to add Ks, I'm pretty sure the 'Cuse has a few of them too. How do others stack up?

 

[DenverBroncos]

Miami:

Testaverde

Portis, McGahee, Edge, Gore

Andre Johnson, Reggie Wayne, Santana Moss, Devin Hester

KWIII, Shockey, Olsen

And I don't even want to get started with their LB's and DB's. And this is really a current fantasy lineup.

 

[Native]

Georgia Bulldogs

QB: Fran Tarkenton

RB: Herschel Walker, Terrell Davis

WR: Hines Ward

TE: Randy McMichael

PK: Kevin Butler

 

[Happy Ragnarok]

Pitt:

Marino

Dorsett, CMart

Fitzgerald, Bryant?

Ditka

 

[benson_will_lead_the_way]

Georgia BulldogsQB: Fran TarkentonRB: Herschel Walker, Terrell DavisWR: Hines WardTE: Randy McMichaelPK: Kevin Butler

hearst as a flex

 

[dgreen]

Miami:TestaverdePortis, McGahee, Edge, GoreAndre Johnson, Reggie Wayne, Santana Moss, Devin HesterKWIII, Shockey, OlsenAnd I don't even want to get started with their LB's and DB's. And this is really a current fantasy lineup.

Jim Kelly. Michael Irvin. Chuck Foreman.

 

[Steelfan7]

Texas

Qb - Vince Young

Rb- Earl Campbell

Rb - Priest Holmes

Wr - Roy Williams

Wr - Alfred Jackson

TE - Finley

K - Phil Dawson

Flex - Ricky Williams

 

[Big Petey]

Syracuse:McNabbBrown, CsonkaHarrison, MonkMackeyIf you want to add Ks, I'm pretty sure the 'Cuse has a few of them too. How do others stack up?

Gary Anderson KOlindo Mare K

 

[David Yudkin]

Pittsburgh

QB - Dan Marino

RB - Curtis Martin, Tony Dorsett

WR - Larry Fitzgerald, Antonio Bryant

TE - Mike Ditka

 

[Steelfan7]

PittsburghQB - Dan MarinoRB - Curtis Martin, Tony DorsettWR - Larry Fitzgerald, Antonio BryantTE - Mike Ditka

I wonder where you got that list from?

 

[perry147]

Alabama

QB Joe Namath

RB Shawn Alexander, Johnny Musso

WR Don Hutson, John Stallworth

TE Ozzie Newsome

 

[Please See Mine]

Penn State

QB: Kerry Collins

RB: Franco Harris, Curt Warner

WR: Joe Jurevicious, Kenny Jackson, Bobby Engram

TE: Kyle Brady

Ugh, Def might be better

 

[Steelfan7]

Alabama

QB Joe Namath

RB Shawn Alexander, Johnny Musso

WR Don Hutson, John Stallworth

TE Ozzie Newsome

Stallworth went to Alabama A&M

 

[jurb26]

Penn StateQB: Kerry CollinsRB: Franco Harris, Curt WarnerWR: Joe Jurevicious, Kenny Jackson, Bobby EngramTE: Kyle BradyUgh, Def might be better

I'd go with Larry Johnson in there at RB...Miami owns this list hands down.Though where are all the Tenn fans?

 

[Ministry of Pain]

Miami

QB: Jim Kelly

RB1: Edge

RB2: Portis

WR1: Andre Johnson

WR2: Reggie Wayne

TE: KWII

Reserves

QB: Vinny Testeverde

RB: McGahee, Gore, Highsmith

WR: Santana Moss, Michael Irvin, Brian Blades, Devin Hester, Eddie Brown, Brett Perriman,

TE: Bubba Beans n Franks, Jeremy Shockey, Greg Olsen

And on defense...

DL: Jerome Brown, Warren Sapp, Cortez Kennedy, Vince Wilfork

LB: Ted Hendricks, Ray Lewis, Jessie Armstead

DB: Ed Reed, Sean Taylor, Ryan McNeil, Antrelle Rolle

 

[Spartans Rule]

Tennessee

QB: Peyton Manning

RB: Jamal Lewis, Charlie Garner (Travis Henry, James Stewart)

WR: Anthony Miller, Stanley Morgan, Peerless Price (Willie Gault, Tim McGee)

TE: Jason Witten

 

[Raider Nation]

Notre Dame

QB - Joe Montana

RBs - Jerome Bettis, Ricky Watters, Paul Hornung

WRs - Tim Brown, Rocket Ismail

TE - Dave Casper

PK - John Carney

 

[Raider Nation]

TROJANS

QB - Carson Palmer

RBs - O.J. Simpson, Marcus Allen, Reggie Bush

WRs - Lynn Swann, Keyshawn Johnson

TE - Who cares? We're gonna use a 6th lineman and run the ball down your throat!

 

[Dr. Awesome]

USC:

Leinart

Dwayne Jarrett

Mike Williams

Lendale White

Reggie Bush

 

[Holy Schneikes]

Miami owns this list hands down.Though where are all the Tenn fans?

I think Pittsburgh stacks up well against Miami, particularly if you are adjusting for eraKellyPortis, McGahee, Edge, GoreAndre Johnson, Reggie Wayne, Santana Moss, Devin HesterKWIII, Shockey, OlsenMarinoDorsett, CMartFitzgerald, Bryant?Ditka QB Kelly vs Marino - Kelly was a great QB, but obviously Marino stands apart. 8 years in top 5 at his position, plus there were years where he might have dominated a league almost no matter who was on his team. Kelly had two top 5 years, one of which was #5. Huge edge to Pittsburgh (which may be the determining factor right there).RB1 Dorsett (another HOFer) vs Edge - Adjusting for era, Dorsett crushes Edge. Both had two excellent years early in their careers, but DorsettHe was top 10 at his position 8 of 9 straight years, and one of those years he only played 9 games. Edge couldn't give you that.RB2 Cmart vs Portis/Gore/McGahee. - Cmart better than any of those guys. 7 top 10 years, 4 years in top 5.WR1 Fitz vs Johnson - Both on track for excellent careers but Fitz has been a considerably better fantasy performer overall. Both have 1st and 2nd place finishes, but Fitz has been top 5 at his position every year he's played in 15+ games. Johnson, not so much.WR2 Bryant vs Wayne/Moss - Clear advantage Miami here, 4 top 10 finishes (Wayne) to 1.TE Ditka vs KWII/Shockey (another HOFer) if TE was a required fantasy position in the 1960s, Ditka might have won leagues by himself. He helped define the position. Big edge Pittsburgh.So if there is ownage, I don't think it is in favor of Miami.

 

[perry147]

Alabama

QB Joe Namath

RB Shawn Alexander, Johnny Musso

WR Don Hutson, John Stallworth

TE Ozzie Newsome

Stallworth went to Alabama A&M

 

[Fodasme69]

USC:LeinartDwayne JarrettMike WilliamsLendale WhiteReggie Bush

 

[Please See Mine]

Penn StateQB: Kerry CollinsRB: Franco Harris, Curt WarnerWR: Joe Jurevicious, Kenny Jackson, Bobby EngramTE: Kyle BradyUgh, Def might be better

I'd go with Larry Johnson in there at RB...Miami owns this list hands down.Though where are all the Tenn fans?

at peak production, you are right, but for a career, I'm not sure that I'd put him up there.