Best Ball / Draft-N-Go style leagues (1 Viewer)

[Unlucky]

In a league where you draft or auction and that's it - no moves, no trades, no lineup submissions, do you think Head to Head is better or Total Points for the season?

Head to Head seems strange to me since you can't adjust for bye weeks or injuries and thus it's possible to get hit with more bad matchups than in a traditional league. Plus, it seems that you shouldn't care about the "boring" factor of total points since you're not making any moves in this league anyway.

Thoughts?

 

[joffer]

i've never seen a draft-n-leave H2H league. i'm not sure i see the need. total points seems the way to go for that format

 

[Anonymous Internet User]

i'd vote for all-play.

H2H makes it more random.

Total points does not necessarily get the "best" team into the playoffs.

All-Play (you get a W-L record as if you played all teams in the league each week) rewards both the good teams AND consistent teams. If you're not better than average most weeks, you don't have the best all-play record at the end.

 

[Team Legacy]

H2H is MUCH more entertaining. Total points is a SNOOZE fest.