Better RB from here out (1 Viewer)

[War Eagle]

Hightower has looked exactly like he always has. 3rd down back. Pass catching back. Beenie should work back up to 20 carries a game.

Bradshaw has definitely looked like the lead back so far. Will he start scoring?

 

[Captain Hook]

Not sure how this can be a serious question but BRADSHAW for sure

 

[gianmarco]

Here's your answer

 

[One]

Not sure how this can be a serious question but BRADSHAW for sure

I kinda agree, it sounds absurd, but after seeing what Hightower is doing in Arizona, I get the feeling Wells can be great if he gets on the field.Regardless, if I had to chose one today, it'd be Bradshaw, easily.No telling what's up with Glass Wells.

 

[Dr. Awesome]

Here's your answer

Fbg's clearly has no issue with these type of threads in the SP. We see them all the damned time and they're rarely moved. I think this crap is worthless space sucking as I do not have Beanie AND Bradshaw.Asking where do we rank Beanie going forward would be okay...but these 1 for 1 comparisons are stupid. At a certain point Joe should start banning all the clowns that do this if they've been here longer than a month.

 

[bulger2holt]

I think Beanie is going to be beastly once he returns, which could be this week. Much, much better RB than Hightower.

 

[War Eagle]

Here's your answer

Fbg's clearly has no issue with these type of threads in the SP. We see them all the damned time and they're rarely moved. I think this crap is worthless space sucking as I do not have Beanie AND Bradshaw.Asking where do we rank Beanie going forward would be okay...but these 1 for 1 comparisons are stupid. At a certain point Joe should start banning all the clowns that do this if they've been here longer than a month.

Wow...ok then. Could you enlighten me with a thread that you find as NOT "worthless space sucking"?

 

[War Eagle]

How is it not serious and so clean cut? The landscapes are changing for for teams. Pre-rankings had Beenie up to 20 spots higher. He may not even play again this week.

Jacobs is not going away. This last incident may get him going. Especially on the goal line.

Just throwing something out there....

Put Harrison in the mix. Also projected higher than Bradshaw. Hillis isnt going anywhere.

 

[gandalas]

Here's your answer

I don't see how this thread belongs in the A/C forum...Not like the OP posted "OMG, I Haz Beanie coming back and Bradshaw on my bench...who do I start??!?!"

More like a general question of relative values between a guy that was a pretty much consensus top-20 RB in drafts this summer versus a guy who has impressed so far.

On topic, I seriously hope that Arizona finally gives Beanie a chance whenever he finally comes back. I drafted him in quite a few leagues, WAY too early this offseason, and think he could do well in that offense.

On the other hand, Bradshaw has also looked impressive. I don't really know which one I would like better at this point in time. Bradshaw definitely has a better cast around him, but by the same token also has a lot more skilled players to contend with. Arizona certainly has not looked great without Beanie, so why not let him run wild like the end of last season?

 

[Dr. Awesome]

The threads on injury updates, team threads, notice to pick up the Bronco wr Thomas, dynasty rankings...those are the kinds of threads that should be on page one.

It's crap like this that flushes the quality to page two.

 

[War Eagle]

The threads on injury updates, team threads, notice to pick up the Bronco wr Thomas, dynasty rankings...those are the kinds of threads that should be on page one. It's crap like this that flushes the quality to page two.

How many times do you need to hear that Andre Johnson hurt his ankle? Or hear to pick up Thomas? Talk about waste of space. PS. Bray Bray got a DUI, in case you hadn't heard. No suspension yet, check back for new threads.

 

[gianmarco]

Here's your answer

I don't see how this thread belongs in the A/C forum...Not like the OP posted "OMG, I Haz Beanie coming back and Bradshaw on my bench...who do I start??!?!"

More like a general question of relative values between a guy that was a pretty much consensus top-20 RB in drafts this summer versus a guy who has impressed so far.

On topic, I seriously hope that Arizona finally gives Beanie a chance whenever he finally comes back. I drafted him in quite a few leagues, WAY too early this offseason, and think he could do well in that offense.

On the other hand, Bradshaw has also looked impressive. I don't really know which one I would like better at this point in time. Bradshaw definitely has a better cast around him, but by the same token also has a lot more skilled players to contend with. Arizona certainly has not looked great without Beanie, so why not let him run wild like the end of last season?

If there's a reason to compare them, then fine. But all this looks like is a disguised ACF question. It's the same as the ACF question "Should I trade X for Y" but bringing it here. Why Bradshaw and Beanie? What's the link here?

Why not Bradshaw and Stewart? Why not Beanie and Stewart? How about Bradshaw and Addai? Do you see that if everyone started doing this for any old 2 players they want to "compare" (i.e., likely figure out whether to trade), then it just gets cluttered.

How about "How does Bradshaw compare to some other RBBC guy?". Or "Is Wells value going to go up once healthy?". Those are general topics that have bearing on any owners that have these guys.

Beanie vs. Hightower I can understand. Hillis vs. Harrison. DeAngelo vs. Stewart. Those comparisons make sense and make for good discussions. Discussing two unrelated guys other than they play RB is nothing but a disguised ACF question. And even if it's not this time, the vast majority of the time it is and only encourages others to do the same.

The mods can decide whether or not it stays but to me these threads get old.

 

[SeniorVBDStudent]

How is it not serious and so clean cut? The landscapes are changing for for teams. Pre-rankings had Beenie up to 20 spots higher. He may not even play again this week.

Jacobs is not going away. This last incident may get him going. Especially on the goal line.

Just throwing something out there....

Put Harrison in the mix. Also projected higher than Bradshaw. Hillis isnt going anywhere.

lolwut.