Brett Favre (1 Viewer)

[detroitwhat]

I know the guy has been en fuego but his matchup is tough this week.

Carolina has been on the slide this year (4-5) but their defense so far against qb's:

1,937 Pass Yds Allowed

8 Touchdowns

7 Interceptions

I'm just saying wouldn't it make sense to go with a better matchup (for example Kurt Warner at Cincy, etc)

 

[sho nuff]

Favre...at home...against a bad team.

No, I would not bench him.

Their ranking is helped by playing against Joey Harrington, Garcia, Vince Young, Brees while he was not really lighting it up, Tim Rattay....and so on.

 

[Liquid Courage]

After what Favre did to the Vikings Defense.

No.. You do not bench him.

 

[bollocks28]

This has got to be the most thinly veiled WDIS post EVER.

 

[the spanker]

This has got to be the most thinly veiled WDIS post EVER.

AMEN. Let's put this one to rest.

 

[stevegamer]

I know the guy has been en fuego but his matchup is tough this week.

Carolina has been on the slide this year (4-5) but their defense so far against qb's:

1,937 Pass Yds Allowed

8 Touchdowns

7 Interceptions

I'm just saying wouldn't it make sense to go with a better matchup (for example Kurt Warner at Cincy, etc)

You mean tough like the #1 pass D he faced a few weeks back in Denver?Teams aren't passing against Carolina, partly because they are facing bad passing teams, and partly because their offense doesn't force you into shootouts.

 

[Aaronstory]

I am a homer. I love the man to death. I thought he was on the downside of his career before this season began, so it shocks me to type the following:

Never bench your studs.

 

[The Man With No Name]

I'm benching him this week.

He could play more years, it's if he and his wife/family want him to.

 

[zamboni]

The way he's slinging the ball right now, the only guys I'd play over him are Brady, Manning or Romo.

 

[PatrickT]

the only guys I'd play over him are Brady, Manning or Romo.

He's been sitting behind Big Ben since week 4, and I've only been on the wrong side of that one once, by 3 points. He's a solid #1 choice, but there are times to sit him. So, I'd add Ben to that list.