What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Brian Westbrook (1 Viewer)

Scorehoard

Footballguy
The Eagles have this swagger about them this season thusfar. McNabb is looking dominant, Stallworth is proving his worth, but like when TO was in town, is Westbrook once again the wildcard that keeps this train rollin?! OR will the injury bug set in when stiffer competition in faced? Let's hear what you have..

 
Last edited by a moderator:
:shrug: Sure he could. Contrary to popular belief, this team has a bunch of weapons on offense and as long as he stays healthy Westbrook can be a top 5 RB (yes I said top 5).
 
Westbrook has 3 career 3 TD games...two against the 49ers, so while yesterday's game was a pleasant surprise, it wasn't shocking per se. What I liked about the game was how Reid protects him by giving Buckhalter plenty of action. I think Westbrook did all his damage on just 16 touches. He's already ailing so he's a risk to go down any time, but Reid at least appears like he doesn't want to exacerbate the issue.

 
I don't think you'll see Westbrook put up 15+ TDs; he just doesn't get enough goal-line looks, and while he's definitely a threat to break one from anywhere on the field, that's not good enough to have the consistent TD production you need to be truly elite. But he could certainly average 100+ combined yards from here out, and could put up enough TDs to remain in the top 5.

 
He's solid 24K gold in a PPR league. Keep this up? Nah, he'll get dinged up. Ride him while the wheels are turning and keep the spare on hand.

 
Obviously he can and will continue this production; and he will remain health.

Reason: First year in 3 that I didn't draft him.

 
Completely disagree... Barring injury what is going to stop him???He is proving his worth as a runner and wants the ball more... and everyone knows his value as a receiver... They have had two games where they were up big and hardly used him... (Houston & 49ers) He will continue to produce big numbers and is one of the best backs in fantasy this year... Take it to the bank!
 
Very similar to last years start by the way, 2 good games and #3 was huge (week 4 not so good, lets hope that changes). In his first 11 games last year he averaged about 14 ppg, in a non-ppr format. Health is always a concern, but healthy he is a solid top 10 (top 5 in PPR).

 
Completely disagree... Barring injury what is going to stop him???
He's on pace for 2240 yards and 26 TDs. I think that's why LHUCKs says No. Saying he won't continue with this output really isn't a knock on Westbrook. It's just unrealistic to predict that kind of output for any RB.
Agreed, of course I dont think that he is going to put up 150 and 3 every week... I dont think we have to take the original question that literal do we??? My point was is that Westbrook is going to continue to be one of the top producers at the runningback position...
 
Completely disagree... Barring injury what is going to stop him???
He's on pace for 2240 yards and 26 TDs. I think that's why LHUCKs says No. Saying he won't continue with this output really isn't a knock on Westbrook. It's just unrealistic to predict that kind of output for any RB.
I dont think we have to take the original question that literal do we???
It's the FBG way. We like to take questions literally (sort of a way to make fun of someone) until the person rewords the question.
 
I'll take the production he's given me again this year, 28,28, 46 in the first 3 weeks, PPR and point per 5 rushes with 3TD 5 point bonus....very similar to last years start, he actually outscored LT2 on my team overall through 9 weeks last year.

 
I'm sorry, but when I hear the words "bone on bone" I automatically think:

A) No freakin' way am I renting that one

or

B) No freakin' way does that guy play 16 games.

I really don't get in the business of predicting injuries, but this sounds similar to the condition that ended D. Davis' season. Limiting Westy to 16 touches is great, but it only takes one solid hit. Again, you could say that about any player in the league, but how can you not seriously believe that this guy is in serious jeopardy of getting hurt. Both Westy and Portis and Culpepper are at greater risk of missing time because each is already injured.

He has the talent and situation to be top 5, but I think he'll end up closer to 9-12 due to injury and I don't think there's any way the guy is playing in week 16 unless Philly is fighting for their playoff lives.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This feels SO MUCH like last season, but with more Westy injuries. SELL HIGH.

...he will NOT play 16

 
This feels SO MUCH like last season, but with more Westy injuries. SELL HIGH....he will NOT play 16
I'll second that, says the disgruntled former 2005 Westbroken owner. The guy singlefootedly destroyed my championship run.
 
This feels SO MUCH like last season, but with more Westy injuries. SELL HIGH....he will NOT play 16
I'll second that, says the disgruntled former 2005 Westbroken owner. The guy singlefootedly destroyed my championship run.
I definitely could have used him down the road last year, thats for damn sure. I don't wanna hate on the guy but I just don't see him lasting the whole season. He does have some easy games coming up so I would hang onto him for now.
 
Sell high. He has a knee problem that doesn't look like it's going away, with a lot of games left to go. He's also extremely unlikely to get any more 70 TD runs to make his numbers look so good.

 
To be a super stud on the level of Westbrook's current production needs 20+ touchdowns. It would be stunning to see him score touchdowns that consistently given the fact that he is not a between the tackles runner that will get inside the 5 carries. Then add in the nature of his condition and the possibility of the swelling preventing him from playing. Add in his history of injuries in general and he has too many strikes against him to reasonably expect a top 5 season in non-ppr leagues. In ppr leagues, he is top 5 if he plays 16 games. But given his condition, do not expect a full season.

 
pick 20 of the second round... do I pick Dunn or Westbrook? Will that Dunn pick end up looking right at the end of the season? I am doubting it for sure at this point :( :banned:

 
I don't think you'll see Westbrook put up 15+ TDs; he just doesn't get enough goal-line looks, and while he's definitely a threat to break one from anywhere on the field, that's not good enough to have the consistent TD production you need to be truly elite. But he could certainly average 100+ combined yards from here out, and could put up enough TDs to remain in the top 5.
:goodposting: 8-10 TD's will not put him near the top 5.
 
Biggest sell high in all of FF land right now. You're going to be dealing with Brian Westbrook - Questionable, all year long...

 
:rolleyes: To all the sell high posts!

Last week on the pregame show they said his ankle orthotics was causing swelling and discomfort in the knee, absolutely no talk of bone on bone. This week he comes out of the game with no knee problems and will likely not be on the injury report...

For those of you saying sell high... Sell high for who??? Lets take a look at the top backs that likely went ahead of Westbrook...

LJ & Tomlinson... I seriously doubt anyone is going to trade you these guys for Westbrook.

Alexander is now hurt and may be worth moving Westy for.... other than these guys....

Steven Jackson, Tiki Barber, Clinton Portis... Out of this group the only one I would probably take is Portis and even he comes with some genuine concerns as he has shoulder problem that may linger and in PPR it is a very tough choice... Barber is sharing carries and although he is still a great back he is losing carries around the goalline and throughout the game.... Steven Jackson does not get enough catches in a PPR league but is a good back... All of these are a toss up but I would probably take Westy over all of them and it would be difficult to get these guys as their owners spent high draft picks on them.

Caddy, Brown, Jordan.... Please....

I'm sorry but I don't see the value in selling high... Sell high for what????

 
Biggest sell high in all of FF land right now. You're going to be dealing with Brian Westbrook - Questionable, all year long...
The count me in as one of the few who is a believer. I say there is no way Westbrook is ailing that much. I think the reports are blown out of proportion.The guy is too blasted quick and elusive.With so many top RBs having issues. Jordan, James, Caddy, Alexander, Jackson, etc etc.There is no way I trade him in ppr unless its for LT2, LJ, or Portis.
 
:rolleyes: To all the sell high posts!Last week on the pregame show they said his ankle orthotics was causing swelling and discomfort in the knee, absolutely no talk of bone on bone. This week he comes out of the game with no knee problems and will likely not be on the injury report...For those of you saying sell high... Sell high for who??? Lets take a look at the top backs that likely went ahead of Westbrook... LJ & Tomlinson... I seriously doubt anyone is going to trade you these guys for Westbrook.Alexander is now hurt and may be worth moving Westy for.... other than these guys....Steven Jackson, Tiki Barber, Clinton Portis... Out of this group the only one I would probably take is Portis and even he comes with some genuine concerns as he has shoulder problem that may linger and in PPR it is a very tough choice... Barber is sharing carries and although he is still a great back he is losing carries around the goalline and throughout the game.... Steven Jackson does not get enough catches in a PPR league but is a good back... All of these are a toss up but I would probably take Westy over all of them and it would be difficult to get these guys as their owners spent high draft picks on them.Caddy, Brown, Jordan.... Please.... I'm sorry but I don't see the value in selling high... Sell high for what????
You don't have to trade a RB for another RB. I've offered him straight up for Steve Smith and am still waiting for a response. I'd be very happy with that as I'm loaded at RB, but need WR help. Knees don't swell for no reason. I believe there's an ongoing problem there, but I don't believe it's bone on bone (isn't that another one of ESPN's wacky exclusives?) until I'm shown proof otherwise.
 
I also don't think there is really anybody I would want to trade him for currently. I might try to package him with Roy Williams and target Rudi Johnson and a WR, but with McNabb as my QB that double dippin sure is nice.

 
:rolleyes: To all the sell high posts!Last week on the pregame show they said his ankle orthotics was causing swelling and discomfort in the knee, absolutely no talk of bone on bone. This week he comes out of the game with no knee problems and will likely not be on the injury report...For those of you saying sell high... Sell high for who??? Lets take a look at the top backs that likely went ahead of Westbrook... LJ & Tomlinson... I seriously doubt anyone is going to trade you these guys for Westbrook.Alexander is now hurt and may be worth moving Westy for.... other than these guys....Steven Jackson, Tiki Barber, Clinton Portis... Out of this group the only one I would probably take is Portis and even he comes with some genuine concerns as he has shoulder problem that may linger and in PPR it is a very tough choice... Barber is sharing carries and although he is still a great back he is losing carries around the goalline and throughout the game.... Steven Jackson does not get enough catches in a PPR league but is a good back... All of these are a toss up but I would probably take Westy over all of them and it would be difficult to get these guys as their owners spent high draft picks on them.Caddy, Brown, Jordan.... Please.... I'm sorry but I don't see the value in selling high... Sell high for what????
You don't have to trade a RB for another RB. I've offered him straight up for Steve Smith and am still waiting for a response. I'd be very happy with that as I'm loaded at RB, but need WR help. Knees don't swell for no reason. I believe there's an ongoing problem there, but I don't believe it's bone on bone (isn't that another one of ESPN's wacky exclusives?) until I'm shown proof otherwise.
I would actually agree with you on your point, if you are loaded at running back then by all means sell, but I think people get carried away with the whole 'sell high' talk!! I can imagine all of these guys screaming "sell high" after Priest's first 3 games as the starting running back in Kansas City... Sometimes you should just realize that what you have may continue to produce and you should only sell high if you think there production is fluky or their situation may change. Example (Another player getting healthy and stealing carries... or something like this....)If you truly believe Westbrooks knee is screwed then by all means sell, but if you have watched him play he is the fastest, shiftiest guy on the field and hardly looks like he is anything less than 100 percent... He is a HUGE part of one of the best offenses in football and this is not going to change, so unless he is injured he is going to be huge for his owners... I will take the risk as I dont need help at receiver.
 
dude the guy has 5 tds for the year... At goaline I see him in there most of the time.. The guy looks good and yesterday he reported that he felt great and the eagles said theres a chance hes not even on the injury report this week.... Hes not bone on bone...

If healthy this guy will get 12 tds this year....or 13

 
dude the guy has 5 tds for the year... At goaline I see him in there most of the time.. The guy looks good and yesterday he reported that he felt great and the eagles said theres a chance hes not even on the injury report this week.... Hes not bone on bone...If healthy this guy will get 12 tds this year....or 13
Agreed. In fact I have watched every game played this year and unless he is winded he is always in at goalline...
 
dude the guy has 5 tds for the year... At goaline I see him in there most of the time.. The guy looks good and yesterday he reported that he felt great and the eagles said theres a chance hes not even on the injury report this week.... Hes not bone on bone...If healthy this guy will get 12 tds this year....or 13
Agreed. In fact I have watched every game played this year and unless he is winded he is always in at goalline...
I have also seen this. Buckhalter is bigger, but Westbrook is trusted at the GL.I've always loved the guy. If the knee problems are truly behind him, he's in for the best season of his already pretty good career.
 
If Westy would stay healthy this year and play a full 16, I think he is the favorite to be the #1 RB. The Eagles O is just on fire and he is the focal point of it.

 
I don't think you'll see Westbrook put up 15+ TDs; he just doesn't get enough goal-line looks, and while he's definitely a threat to break one from anywhere on the field, that's not good enough to have the consistent TD production you need to be truly elite. But he could certainly average 100+ combined yards from here out, and could put up enough TDs to remain in the top 5.
:goodposting: 8-10 TD's will not put him near the top 5.
Well, he already has 5 TDs; he should get to at least 10. In 2005, the #6 RB had 11 TDs and 1700 total yards, which Westbrook should easily eclipse if he stays healthy. For the year, it'll be pretty easy for him to wind up in the top 5, considering how much of a head start he has. I would be mildy surprised if he puts up top-5 numbers for weeks 4-17.
 
Play him, he was the top RB in our league this week. Certainly looks like he's gonna have a healthy season.

PS: don't trade LT for him. LOL

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top