Judge Smails
Footballguy
Teams that are peaking at right time. Nobody else passes the eye test right now.
Agree with this. They have been winning very easily however and are a complete team passing, running and defense. Other teams being exposed.Their division/schedule has been cupcake since losing to New England...their best wins this season came against the Ravens and Bengals while both teams were mired in bad stretches of play.
... especially if you subscribe to "NFL Game Rewind". Almost anyone could see both New England and Houston beating them, if they want to.I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
Their division/schedule has been cupcake since losing to New England...their best wins this season came against the Ravens and Bengals while both teams were mired in bad stretches of play.
Fixed that for you.Broncos vs. Packers with Manning Rodgers getting his 2nd ring.
FixedI hope Seahawks vs Packers happens again, just so if the Hawks when the Packers make it all the way I don't have to hear anyone whine about the last bad call in a game that was littered with them.
ROTFLIf you have to pick 2 "fluke" AFC teams, those are Patriots & Texans... especially if you subscribe to "NFL Game Rewind". Almost anyone could see both New England and Houston beating them, if they want to.I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
That's because there are 2 sides in football and their defense is not Superbowl contenderAnd I'm not sure how NE doesn't pass the eye test.
NE vs. Denver will be a race to 50That's because there are 2 sides in football and their defense is not Superbowl contenderAnd I'm not sure how NE doesn't pass the eye test.
While it was their fourth loss in a row, the Bengals are 6-1 since that loss to Denver. The Broncos dismantled the Saints when the Saints were in the middle of a 5-1 stretch.Their division/schedule has been cupcake since losing to New England...their best wins this season came against the Ravens and Bengals while both teams were mired in bad stretches of play.
And still...nobody would rate those teams as Superbowl contenders. As solid as Denver has been during this 10 game streak, they beaten just 1 Superbowl contender: the Ravens. And of the contenders, I think they qualify as the weakest of the bunch by far...Before crowning Denver as the team to beat, I'd like to see them beat someone first.While it was their fourth loss in a row, the Bengals are 6-1 since that loss to Denver. The Broncos dismantled the Saints when the Saints were in the middle of a 5-1 stretch.Their division/schedule has been cupcake since losing to New England...their best wins this season came against the Ravens and Bengals while both teams were mired in bad stretches of play.
2005 called, it wants its fallacy back.I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
Thank you.2005 called, it wants its fallacy back.I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
Who is "someone"? Only the teams you have deemed as being worthy? I guess we'll just ignore their road win at Cincinnati (another playoff bound team), right?'TheFootballJesus said:And still...nobody would rate those teams as Superbowl contenders. As solid as Denver has been during this 10 game streak, they beaten just 1 Superbowl contender: the Ravens. And of the contenders, I think they qualify as the weakest of the bunch by far...Before crowning Denver as the team to beat, I'd like to see them beat someone first.'Ghost Rider said:While it was their fourth loss in a row, the Bengals are 6-1 since that loss to Denver. The Broncos dismantled the Saints when the Saints were in the middle of a 5-1 stretch.'TheFootballJesus said:Their division/schedule has been cupcake since losing to New England...their best wins this season came against the Ravens and Bengals while both teams were mired in bad stretches of play.
Did you watch the NFL last year? Neither was their defense then, and they made it to the Super Bowl. Their offense..and defense for that matter is better this season.'Young 8 said:That's because there are 2 sides in football and their defense is not Superbowl contender'devouredbychaos said:And I'm not sure how NE doesn't pass the eye test.
How about last year?'Young 8 said:That's because there are 2 sides in football and their defense is not Superbowl contender'devouredbychaos said:And I'm not sure how NE doesn't pass the eye test.
First off it was 2006, second off go back and check the games. Peyton played like crap minus the second half against New England. Some reason Bob Sanders came back that year and their defense turned into the 85 Bears.'Sea Duck said:2005 called, it wants its fallacy back.'Chazzhawk said:I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
Huh? 2005 Peyton lost to New England, I assume you mean the 2006-7 year when Peyton won the Super Bowl...Manning is one of the worst of the (best QBs) in the playoffs in NFL History.'99 - 2nd seed (0-1)'00 - 6th seed (0-1)'02 - 5th seed (0-1)'03 - 3rd seed (2-1) lost to New England'04 - 3rd seed (1-1) lost to New England'05 - 1st seed (0-1)'06 - 3rd seed (4-0) Super Bowl'07 - 2nd seed (0-1)'08 - 5th seed (0-1)'09 - 1st seed (2-1) lost in Super Bowl'10 - 3rd seed (0-1)Peyton/Marino/Hasselbeck/Moon are the only QBs with at least 10 Playoff starts to have below a .500 winning percentageshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_starting_quarterback_playoff_records'pizzatyme said:Thank you.'Sea Duck said:2005 called, it wants its fallacy back.'Chazzhawk said:I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
Please reread what you wrote. After you do come back and try to tell me you didn't want to punch yourself in the face.Too bad Brady has only played well in 3 playoff game since their last super bowl win, 2 firstvrd games against overmatched jaguars and the Tebows last year. Otherwise Ints and ducking from lineman both real and ghosts (jests loss few years ago).
Please reread what you wrote. After you do come back and try to tell me you didn't want to punch yourself in the face.Too bad Brady has only played well in 3 playoff game since their last super bowl win, 2 firstvrd games against overmatched jaguars and the Tebows last year. Otherwise Ints and ducking from lineman both real and ghosts (jests loss few years ago).
You do realize this is a team sport, correct? You can choose to penalize Peyton for taking his above average teams to the playoffs so many years and getting beat by better teams if you want. I say, it speaks to his legend that those teams were even IN the playoffs. Brady hasn't won the big one since his teams defense fell off. It happens!Let me know when your team wins a meaningful game fairly. Then you can start making meaningful posts about the abilities of HOF QBs. Until then, save your criticisms. I have witnessed first hand what Peyton Manning can do with a ####ty team on his shoulders. Just because the team fell short in the playoffs, doesn't mean he is a losing playoff QB.Funny part is if you combine Eli and Peyton you probably have the best quarterback of all time and no one could argue it. Peyton is as rock solid as they come in the regular season, he wins divisions, he leads bad teams to the playoffs, and he puts up stats every year. You get to the playoffs though and he changes and gets nervous, he loses games he should win, he throws 6 picks in playoff games, instead of leading game winning drives he usually throws a pick and they lose. Eli on the other hand is as inconsistent as the come in the regular season, he shows flashes of being an elite quarterback then he loses it. The Giants start 6 - 2 and look like a lock to win the NFC and then he goes into Derek Anderson mode and turns the ball over a million times and they miss the playoffs. When Eli gets into the playoffs though look out, it is just another game to him. He goes on the road against better teams and just makes plays to win games and makes these teams look bad while doing it, as if to the say the regular season doesn't matter to him.Put them together and you get a quarterback better than Brady, who in this era seems to be the most consistent quarterback for the regular season and playoffs. (yes he has had bad games but he doesn't go into the funks that Eli does, and he has been better than Peyton in the playoffs)
If you're not counting the Seahawks maybe that is true.'Sabertooth said:No scab refs any more. And Green bay is the hottest team in the NFL.
Or the Broncos.If you're not counting the Seahawks maybe that is true.'Sabertooth said:No scab refs any more. And Green bay is the hottest team in the NFL.
Just let him go. He's rolling.Or the Broncos.If you're not counting the Seahawks maybe that is true.'Sabertooth said:No scab refs any more. And Green bay is the hottest team in the NFL.
My response is below. Last I checked, each team consists if 53 men. Manning got teams into the playoffs who otherwise had no business being there. Playoffs are another story. Brady hasn't won the SB since his defense fell off. It happens.Huh? 2005 Peyton lost to New England, I assume you mean the 2006-7 year when Peyton won the Super Bowl...Manning is one of the worst of the (best QBs) in the playoffs in NFL History.'99 - 2nd seed (0-1)'00 - 6th seed (0-1)'02 - 5th seed (0-1)'03 - 3rd seed (2-1) lost to New England'04 - 3rd seed (1-1) lost to New England'05 - 1st seed (0-1)'06 - 3rd seed (4-0) Super Bowl'07 - 2nd seed (0-1)'08 - 5th seed (0-1)'09 - 1st seed (2-1) lost in Super Bowl'10 - 3rd seed (0-1)Peyton/Marino/Hasselbeck/Moon are the only QBs with at least 10 Playoff starts to have below a .500 winning percentageshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_starting_quarterback_playoff_records'pizzatyme said:Thank you.'Sea Duck said:2005 called, it wants its fallacy back.'Chazzhawk said:I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
My bowling team won our position round about a month ago, so we will be in the roll off at the end of the year. I shot 700+ for my series. Is that good enough?You do realize this is a team sport, correct? You can choose to penalize Peyton for taking his above average teams to the playoffs so many years and getting beat by better teams if you want. I say, it speaks to his legend that those teams were even IN the playoffs. Brady hasn't won the big one since his teams defense fell off. It happens!Let me know when your team wins a meaningful game fairly. Then you can start making meaningful posts about the abilities of HOF QBs. Until then, save your criticisms. I have witnessed first hand what Peyton Manning can do with a ####ty team on his shoulders. Just because the team fell short in the playoffs, doesn't mean he is a losing playoff QB.Funny part is if you combine Eli and Peyton you probably have the best quarterback of all time and no one could argue it. Peyton is as rock solid as they come in the regular season, he wins divisions, he leads bad teams to the playoffs, and he puts up stats every year. You get to the playoffs though and he changes and gets nervous, he loses games he should win, he throws 6 picks in playoff games, instead of leading game winning drives he usually throws a pick and they lose. Eli on the other hand is as inconsistent as the come in the regular season, he shows flashes of being an elite quarterback then he loses it. The Giants start 6 - 2 and look like a lock to win the NFC and then he goes into Derek Anderson mode and turns the ball over a million times and they miss the playoffs. When Eli gets into the playoffs though look out, it is just another game to him. He goes on the road against better teams and just makes plays to win games and makes these teams look bad while doing it, as if to the say the regular season doesn't matter to him.Put them together and you get a quarterback better than Brady, who in this era seems to be the most consistent quarterback for the regular season and playoffs. (yes he has had bad games but he doesn't go into the funks that Eli does, and he has been better than Peyton in the playoffs)
You must have missed the first sentence.If you're not counting the Seahawks maybe that is true.'Sabertooth said:No scab refs any more. And Green bay is the hottest team in the NFL.
We can do this all day, Brady won Super Bowls with running backs like Antwan Smith, and receivers like Branch, Givens, and Patton. Name the last time Peyton had a starting receiver that wasn't top 10. His record speaks for itself.My response is below. Last I checked, each team consists if 53 men. Manning got teams into the playoffs who otherwise had no business being there. Playoffs are another story. Brady hasn't won the SB since his defense fell off. It happens.Huh? 2005 Peyton lost to New England, I assume you mean the 2006-7 year when Peyton won the Super Bowl...Manning is one of the worst of the (best QBs) in the playoffs in NFL History.'99 - 2nd seed (0-1)'00 - 6th seed (0-1)'02 - 5th seed (0-1)'03 - 3rd seed (2-1) lost to New England'04 - 3rd seed (1-1) lost to New England'05 - 1st seed (0-1)'06 - 3rd seed (4-0) Super Bowl'07 - 2nd seed (0-1)'08 - 5th seed (0-1)'09 - 1st seed (2-1) lost in Super Bowl'10 - 3rd seed (0-1)Peyton/Marino/Hasselbeck/Moon are the only QBs with at least 10 Playoff starts to have below a .500 winning percentageshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_starting_quarterback_playoff_records'pizzatyme said:Thank you.'Sea Duck said:2005 called, it wants its fallacy back.'Chazzhawk said:I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
Yeah that awesome!My bowling team won our position round about a month ago, so we will be in the roll off at the end of the year. I shot 700+ for my series. Is that good enough?You do realize this is a team sport, correct? You can choose to penalize Peyton for taking his above average teams to the playoffs so many years and getting beat by better teams if you want. I say, it speaks to his legend that those teams were even IN the playoffs. Brady hasn't won the big one since his teams defense fell off. It happens!Let me know when your team wins a meaningful game fairly. Then you can start making meaningful posts about the abilities of HOF QBs. Until then, save your criticisms. I have witnessed first hand what Peyton Manning can do with a ####ty team on his shoulders. Just because the team fell short in the playoffs, doesn't mean he is a losing playoff QB.Funny part is if you combine Eli and Peyton you probably have the best quarterback of all time and no one could argue it. Peyton is as rock solid as they come in the regular season, he wins divisions, he leads bad teams to the playoffs, and he puts up stats every year. You get to the playoffs though and he changes and gets nervous, he loses games he should win, he throws 6 picks in playoff games, instead of leading game winning drives he usually throws a pick and they lose. Eli on the other hand is as inconsistent as the come in the regular season, he shows flashes of being an elite quarterback then he loses it. The Giants start 6 - 2 and look like a lock to win the NFC and then he goes into Derek Anderson mode and turns the ball over a million times and they miss the playoffs. When Eli gets into the playoffs though look out, it is just another game to him. He goes on the road against better teams and just makes plays to win games and makes these teams look bad while doing it, as if to the say the regular season doesn't matter to him.Put them together and you get a quarterback better than Brady, who in this era seems to be the most consistent quarterback for the regular season and playoffs. (yes he has had bad games but he doesn't go into the funks that Eli does, and he has been better than Peyton in the playoffs)
No it doesn't. We can agree to disagree. Big Ben hasn't won a big game since his defense fell off and is out of the playoffs. Eli will be out of the playoffs and his defense fell off. Brees...sameRivers...sameThese QBs couldn't even get their teams to the playoffs to lose. Peyton had several years where he got his team there. The fact he lost doesn't make him an unsuccessful QB. Just one whose team wasn't good enough to win against better teams.We can do this all day, Brady won Super Bowls with running backs like Antwan Smith, and receivers like Branch, Givens, and Patton. Name the last time Peyton had a starting receiver that wasn't top 10. His record speaks for itself.My response is below. Last I checked, each team consists if 53 men. Manning got teams into the playoffs who otherwise had no business being there. Playoffs are another story. Brady hasn't won the SB since his defense fell off. It happens.Huh? 2005 Peyton lost to New England, I assume you mean the 2006-7 year when Peyton won the Super Bowl...Manning is one of the worst of the (best QBs) in the playoffs in NFL History.'99 - 2nd seed (0-1)'00 - 6th seed (0-1)'02 - 5th seed (0-1)'03 - 3rd seed (2-1) lost to New England'04 - 3rd seed (1-1) lost to New England'05 - 1st seed (0-1)'06 - 3rd seed (4-0) Super Bowl'07 - 2nd seed (0-1)'08 - 5th seed (0-1)'09 - 1st seed (2-1) lost in Super Bowl'10 - 3rd seed (0-1)Peyton/Marino/Hasselbeck/Moon are the only QBs with at least 10 Playoff starts to have below a .500 winning percentageshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_starting_quarterback_playoff_records'pizzatyme said:Thank you.'Sea Duck said:2005 called, it wants its fallacy back.'Chazzhawk said:I refuse to pick any Peyton Manning lead team to go to the Super Bowl. Too many choke jobs in the playoffs, I could see New England, or Houston beating them.
No I didn't, but you must have missed the last 3 weeks where the Seahawks outscored their opponents 150-30.You must have missed the first sentence.If you're not counting the Seahawks maybe that is true.'Sabertooth said:No scab refs any more. And Green bay is the hottest team in the NFL.![]()
![]()
![]()
This makes me laugh.'Sabertooth said:No scab refs any more. And Green bay is the hottest team in the NFL.