What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Chris Henry (CIN) had brain damage at time of death (1 Viewer)

identikit

Footballguy
Researchers find brain trauma in Henry

By Peter Keating

ESPN The Magazine

Chris Henry, the Cincinnati Bengals wide receiver who died in a traffic accident last year, had chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) -- a form of degenerative brain damage caused by multiple hits to the head -- at the time of his death, according to scientists at the Brain Injury Research Institute, a research center affiliated with West Virginia University.

"We would have been very happy if the results had been negative, but multiple areas of Chris Henry's brain showed CTE," said Julian Bailes, Director of BIRI and chairman of neurosurgery at West Virginia. Bailes and his colleagues plan to present results of their forensic examination at a news conference Monday afternoon.

Researchers have now discovered CTE in the brains of more than 50 deceased former athletes, including more than a dozen NFL and college players, pro wrestler Chris Benoit and NHL player Reggie Fleming.

Repeated blows to the head are the only known cause of CTE, researchers say. Concussive hits can trigger a buildup of toxic tau protein within the brain, which in turn can create damaging tangles and threads in the neural fibers that connect brain tissue. Victims can lose control of their impulses, suffer depression and memory loss, and ultimately develop dementia.

While the links between CTE and behavior are still being studied, many of the former athletes diagnosed with this form of brain damage died under unusual circumstances. Ex-Steeler Justin Strzelczyk, for example, was killed in 2004 after experiencing hallucinations, leading police on a high-speed chase for 40 miles before driving his car into a tanker truck. In 2007, Benoit strangled his wife and 7-year-old son, then put Bibles next to their bodies and hanged himself. Tom McHale, a guard for three NFL teams remembered by teammates as smart and dependable, sank into depression and died of a multiple-drug overdose in 2008.

Henry, 26, died on Dec. 17, 2009, a day after he either jumped or fell from the back of a moving pickup truck being driven by his fiancee, Loleini Tonga. The two had been involved in a dispute before Tonga got into the truck and Henry jumped in. One witness told reporters that Henry said, "If you take off, I'm going to jump off the truck and kill myself."

It is still not clear whether Henry jumped or fell, but as Tonga was driving at about 19 miles per hour, Henry crashed to the ground, suffering a fractured skull and massive head injuries. Police ruled the incident an accident. No traces of alcohol were found in a toxicology report, which didn't include any other tests for drugs.No charges were filed against Tonga.

After Henry's death, his mother, Carolyn Henry Glaspy, gave BIRI permission to examine his brain in detail.

CTE can be pinpointed only by autopsy, and even under regular post-mortem analysis, its effects are invisible. But using cell-staining techniques discovered and developed by Bennet Omalu, a neuropathologist who is co-director of BIRI, scientists can see the dangerous tau proteins and telltale tangles that characterize CTE. After staining, normal brain cells are blue and uncluttered under a microscope, while Henry's brain cells were discolored, clumpy and filled with threads, according to the researchers.

Now, Bailes -- and likely Henry's family, friends and fans -- will wonder if his neural damage contributed to his emotional volatility, including whatever problems he was suffering the day he died.

"I think it did," Bailes said. "Superimposed on the acute brain injuries Chris suffered when he died, there was fairly extensive damage throughout his brain that was fully consistent with CTE. This syndrome is expressed not only as changes in the brain, but clinically, as behavioral changes. And starting with Mike Webster, we have seen common threads in these cases: emotional disturbances, depression, failed personal relationships and businesses, suicidal thoughts, sometimes alcohol or drug use."

"I'm just trying to learn what happened, and what the situation was with Chris' brain," Glaspy said. "Whatever I can do to help anyone else who is going through this, I'm willing to do."

For years, the NFL and its affiliated researchers disputed a scientific evidence linking concussions to long-term brain damage. However, referring to reports of CTE among former players, NFL Head, Neck and Spine Committee co-chair Richard Ellenbogen told The New York Times earlier this month, "They aren't assertions or hype -- they are facts."

In April, the league announced a $1-million gift to the Center for the Study of Traumatic Encephalopathy at Boston University.

Henry, a native of Belle Chasse, La., played collegiately at West Virginia and was a third-round pick by the Bengals in 2005. He played for five tumultuous seasons in the NFL; he was arrested five times during his pro career, and NFL commissioner Roger Goodell suspended him for the first half of the 2007 season for violating the league's personal conduct policy.

But after Cincinnati brought him back in 2008, Henry vowed to put his substance abuse and anger management issues behind him. And he had been succeeding, according to teammates as well as Bengals officials.

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=5333971

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Interesting report. Certainly taking some shots to the noggin isn't good for you and could have contributed to Henry's behavior. On the other hand Henry had a history of poor behavior long before he played in the NFL.

 
Interesting report. Certainly taking some shots to the noggin isn't good for you and could have contributed to Henry's behavior. On the other hand Henry had a history of poor behavior long before he played in the NFL.
Agreed. Not excusing his behavior at all.The fact that Henry had a pretty limited career (55 games played over 5 years) and played at a position with less contact than most makes it more compelling to me.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Interesting report. Certainly taking some shots to the noggin isn't good for you and could have contributed to Henry's behavior. On the other hand Henry had a history of poor behavior long before he played in the NFL.
It's certainly more violent in the NFL, however he was playing football likely since he was less than 10 years old. I wonder how much of that he carried with him into the NFL. Still, I too am skeptical as to how much this alone explains his maladjusted behavior. The Justin Strzelczyk's are still pretty rare, even in the post-NFL world. Not everyone was fed steroids in Rooneyville after all.
 
So we think that the project should now take on two additional questions: (1) do players already arrive at the NFL level with CTE?; and (2) are there any other factors that may be causing it?

Dr. Bailes seems to recognize this possibility. "I don't want to imply that this is an [NFL]-only phenomenon," Dr. Bailes tells Alan Schwarz of the New York Times. Bailes now wonders whether the foundation for CTE is laid "while the brain is young and vulnerable," and then suffers an injury.

"Players spend 17 years banging heads in the pros on every play and you think it's exposure based," Dr. Bailes said. "Now with Chris Henry being so young, we have to rethink that."
Link
 
The fact is that Henry has been hurt, suspended and really not on the field all that much for a player who has been in the NFL 5-6 years. Plus he never caught that many passes.

What about the guys who have played 10-12 years as every game starters? Troy Aikman, Emmit Smith, Steve Young? Guys like Brien Westbrook should be very concerned with this report.

All the interior lineman who take 10-20 shots to the head a game not counting practice probably have some sort of head trauma.

 
Interesting report, somehow not surprising. What about abuse as a kid, fights, others causes? I'm not saying these things happened but like was said, a back like Westbrook's brain would be swiss cheese. Or certain people are predisposed, more likely to have problems etc.. I'm guessing Evander Holyfield has a bit of this CTE.

I am wary of scientists as they tend to try to find a physical cause for behavioral problems. It does not excuse them when help is available. They're very quick to hand out MEDS without looking at some of the deeper "issues".

 
The fact is that Henry has been hurt, suspended and really not on the field all that much for a player who has been in the NFL 5-6 years. Plus he never caught that many passes.What about the guys who have played 10-12 years as every game starters? Troy Aikman, Emmit Smith, Steve Young? Guys like Brien Westbrook should be very concerned with this report.All the interior lineman who take 10-20 shots to the head a game not counting practice probably have some sort of head trauma.
:lmao: Merril Hoge was the poster boy for concussions for many years but he has managed to keep out of trouble.
 
The fact is that Henry has been hurt, suspended and really not on the field all that much for a player who has been in the NFL 5-6 years. Plus he never caught that many passes.What about the guys who have played 10-12 years as every game starters? Troy Aikman, Emmit Smith, Steve Young? Guys like Brien Westbrook should be very concerned with this report.All the interior lineman who take 10-20 shots to the head a game not counting practice probably have some sort of head trauma.
This is why Henry is an interesting case because by position, experience etc he should have been less likely to have this type trauma. Also, given that he had a history of poor, and often bizarre behavior that is associated with this trauma, how and when he got it is important.Edit: To add a couple of things 1)Not all head trauma is the same i.e. damage to different part of the brain causes different outcomes. so because ____ has brain damage and did not act weirdly does not follow here.2)The article states that the only known way that people normally have this truama is from repeated blows to the head versus one severe incident.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Interesting report, somehow not surprising. What about abuse as a kid, fights, others causes? I'm not saying these things happened but like was said, a back like Westbrook's brain would be swiss cheese. Or certain people are predisposed, more likely to have problems etc.. I'm guessing Evander Holyfield has a bit of this CTE.

I am wary of scientists as they tend to try to find a physical cause for behavioral problems. It does not excuse them when help is available. They're very quick to hand out MEDS without looking at some of the deeper "issues".
The boxer's version of this is called Dementia pugilistica:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dementia_pugilistica

 
Shtaym Syek said:
Didn't he fall out of a truck? Seems like that could cause you to hurt your head pretty bad.
Yeah, I was going to say the same. I hate to ask the obvious, but he died from a skull fracture. I assume they're able to differentiate recent, massive trauma vs what they're looking for? I didn't see it in the article, but I just skimmed.
 
Shtaym Syek said:
Didn't he fall out of a truck? Seems like that could cause you to hurt your head pretty bad.
Yeah, I was going to say the same. I hate to ask the obvious, but he died from a skull fracture. I assume they're able to differentiate recent, massive trauma vs what they're looking for? I didn't see it in the article, but I just skimmed.
From the doctor in the article: "Superimposed on the acute brain injuries Chris suffered when he died, there was fairly extensive damage throughout his brain that was fully consistent with CTE."
 
Godsbrother said:
Summer Wheat said:
The fact is that Henry has been hurt, suspended and really not on the field all that much for a player who has been in the NFL 5-6 years. Plus he never caught that many passes.What about the guys who have played 10-12 years as every game starters? Troy Aikman, Emmit Smith, Steve Young? Guys like Brien Westbrook should be very concerned with this report.All the interior lineman who take 10-20 shots to the head a game not counting practice probably have some sort of head trauma.
:lmao: Merril Hoge was the poster boy for concussions for many years but he has managed to keep out of trouble.
I don't think head injuries can be compared like this at all. The brain is far too complicated for us to know what was actually going on with Henry. Just because Hoge had concussions and stayed out of trouble doesn't mean that should be the case for all brain injuries.
 
fatness said:
So we think that the project should now take on two additional questions: (1) do players already arrive at the NFL level with CTE?; and (2) are there any other factors that may be causing it?

Dr. Bailes seems to recognize this possibility. "I don't want to imply that this is an [NFL]-only phenomenon," Dr. Bailes tells Alan Schwarz of the New York Times. Bailes now wonders whether the foundation for CTE is laid "while the brain is young and vulnerable," and then suffers an injury.

"Players spend 17 years banging heads in the pros on every play and you think it's exposure based," Dr. Bailes said. "Now with Chris Henry being so young, we have to rethink that."
Link
I think it's very important that the NFL is the most-mentioned organization with participants that had (or have) CTE, but we remember the problem goes a lot deeper. There are far more college and high school players than their are NFL players. It means we should be as concerned with the amateurs (if not more). The problem is the high-profile cases with the professional players or former pros will predominate the headlines. Safety has to begin at the Pop Warner and high school levels. This is where the least amount of care is taken, the most variation in standards likely exist, and the most vulnerable participants are.The danger here is for a public perception fueled by a phenomenon generated from media coverage. It's an unintentional event, but because the media will focus so much on NFL players the public will think it more as an NFL problem than a football problem. If you ask the average person, they will tell you that there are far more car accidents than incidents of stomach cancer, but it's actually the opposite. The public doesn't realize it because media coverage is predominantly about car accidents than stomach cancer. Car accidents are more news worthy because they are unusual and grab more reader attention.

The same will be with NFL players with CTE versus non-pros.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Are their any similarities between CTE and the effects on the brain of prenatal alcohol syndrome?

I don't know. I do recall seeing visual similarities between the head size of Henry and that of a "generic" adult born with prenatal alcohol syndrome. Striking resemblance and the PAS does have an effect on the development of the brain.

 
Is it possible Henry was abused as a child? I'm not trying to be funny in any way, just saying that maybe he was beaten by a parent, aunt/uncle, cousin, someone that could have inflicted these injuries. A few things that I don't like and make me at least proceed with caution from the story.

1. Of all the people they examined, why him and why after he was traumatized in the head? I can't dismiss the truck accident completely just because they say so and the CTE is brought into play. Why have we never gotten this type of info before? Lots of players have died long before the average age of death in this country and many were not killed in head trauma accidents so I would need to see a lot of these before I jumped to conclusions.

2. He played WR, not OL/DL/RB...maybe he sustained 8-10 tackles a game in college? In pop warner you have to play in weight class, everyone is 135 lbs let's say from the lines and on down to the specialty positions. There simply isn't enough speed and weight yet to sustain that kind of head trauma IMO. It starts to get dicey when they reach HS, then college, but again Henry was a WR and likely wasn't getting full contact every play. And to those that say "That's exactly why this is bad MOP"...just dial that back a second. Don't stop being logical just because this story was put out by ESPN, cause they never embellish a story or two, run with the ball in order to get people to tune in and watch, obviously I'm being sarcastic.

3. The helmets they play with right now are state of the art and way better than the piece of leather our fathers and grandfathers played with. There are loads of safety precautions in place. And it's football, it's a violent sport. We support it by playing FF, watching all the games, buying tix...if it bothers you then stop watching. No one is holding a gun to your head.

People that are concerned for the players would be much better advised to support weight restrictions in pro and college football. Men running up and down the field weighing 300-350 lbs when no more than about 20-25 years ago the avg OL was about 250-275, that is much more disturbing IMO. We wonder why these guys live shorter lives and perhaps some is due to head trauma but also turning the body into something it's really not designed to do should be much further up the priority list IMO.

Some of that may not be the popular POV and I understand that.

 
I'd like to hear some feedback on my last post, thanks.
I don't have much. Seems like we remain where we've been. People that get their brains knocked around sometimes end up with serious issues as a result, but usually not so much. Now what? The bottom line is that there is risk. I am a little skeptical about the nature of Henry's injuries. He just doesn't seem to be a guy that took that many big shots on the football field, so it is at least plausible that "some" of his injuries were sustained outside of football. We end up with a very small minority of former players that are affected to the point of being suicidal and/or a threat to those around them. What do we do with that? Accept it as a potential risk that is generally worth it given the amount of money these guys make doing what they love to do? Outlaw football? Is there a realistic solution? It has to be a game with some amount of hitting and violence. That is what sells, that is what the public wants....it's even what the athletes want.
 
Is it possible Henry was abused as a child? I'm not trying to be funny in any way, just saying that maybe he was beaten by a parent, aunt/uncle, cousin, someone that could have inflicted these injuries. A few things that I don't like and make me at least proceed with caution from the story.

Sure it's possible he was abused as a child, just like it's possible he got into a lot of fights as a youth growing up.

1. Of all the people they examined, why him and why after he was traumatized in the head?

Why not him? He was an athlete, he had erratic behavior, and he died (seems like a perfect fit for the BIRI study). His mother gave BIRI permission to do the examination on his brain, and I don't find that strange at all.
 
I think it's very important that the NFL is the most-mentioned organization with participants that had (or have) CTE, but we remember the problem goes a lot deeper. There are far more college and high school players than their are NFL players. It means we should be as concerned with the amateurs (if not more). The problem is the high-profile cases with the professional players or former pros will predominate the headlines. Safety has to begin at the Pop Warner and high school levels. This is where the least amount of care is taken, the most variation in standards likely exist, and the most vulnerable participants are.The danger here is for a public perception fueled by a phenomenon generated from media coverage. It's an unintentional event, but because the media will focus so much on NFL players the public will think it more as an NFL problem than a football problem. If you ask the average person, they will tell you that there are far more car accidents than incidents of stomach cancer, but it's actually the opposite. The public doesn't realize it because media coverage is predominantly about car accidents than stomach cancer. Car accidents are more news worthy because they are unusual and grab more reader attention. The same will be with NFL players with CTE versus non-pros.
I think the trap here is - to some extent - that we get obsessed by big events which spur these things on. Chris Henry's death, Big Ben's 'incidents'. It shouldn't take a tragedy to cause study.Also, riffing off some of what you said Matt - as a dad with a son who desperately wants to play football, I think that getting absorbed in the immediacy of NFL head trauma is a bad idea. In order to have a real idea as to the affects of head trauma, shouldn't we be studying players from a young age? Some may not play as long as others but by and large this is the sort of injury IMO that can only be effectively studied long term.In other words, what are the risks and at what age do they start being serious? When should I worry about my kid and how can i protect him?I don't know you can study Henry's brain and make any real conclusion without knowing when, how and how often those injuries were incurred. How can you know his assault arrest was due to a head injury if you don't know when that happened?I had a doctor once who took a - I think it was a cardiogram or an EKG - of me so that he could later look back and see if there were any changes, maybe as warning signs, maybe to see what was cause for concern vs whatwas normal.One would thimk studying this similiarly would make more sense than reacting with 'oh so THAT'S why' on a post mortem exam.
 
Is it possible Henry was abused as a child? I'm not trying to be funny in any way, just saying that maybe he was beaten by a parent, aunt/uncle, cousin, someone that could have inflicted these injuries. A few things that I don't like and make me at least proceed with caution from the story.1. Of all the people they examined, why him and why after he was traumatized in the head? I can't dismiss the truck accident completely just because they say so and the CTE is brought into play. Why have we never gotten this type of info before? Lots of players have died long before the average age of death in this country and many were not killed in head trauma accidents so I would need to see a lot of these before I jumped to conclusions. 2. He played WR, not OL/DL/RB...maybe he sustained 8-10 tackles a game in college? In pop warner you have to play in weight class, everyone is 135 lbs let's say from the lines and on down to the specialty positions. There simply isn't enough speed and weight yet to sustain that kind of head trauma IMO. It starts to get dicey when they reach HS, then college, but again Henry was a WR and likely wasn't getting full contact every play. And to those that say "That's exactly why this is bad MOP"...just dial that back a second. Don't stop being logical just because this story was put out by ESPN, cause they never embellish a story or two, run with the ball in order to get people to tune in and watch, obviously I'm being sarcastic. 3. The helmets they play with right now are state of the art and way better than the piece of leather our fathers and grandfathers played with. There are loads of safety precautions in place. And it's football, it's a violent sport. We support it by playing FF, watching all the games, buying tix...if it bothers you then stop watching. No one is holding a gun to your head. People that are concerned for the players would be much better advised to support weight restrictions in pro and college football. Men running up and down the field weighing 300-350 lbs when no more than about 20-25 years ago the avg OL was about 250-275, that is much more disturbing IMO. We wonder why these guys live shorter lives and perhaps some is due to head trauma but also turning the body into something it's really not designed to do should be much further up the priority list IMO. Some of that may not be the popular POV and I understand that.
It is very possible that he could have been abused as a child. Brain injuries are very much under reported and there is an extremely high correlation between people on death row and TBI (some studies have found 100% positive link between TBI and death row inmates, but that is a whole different conversation). There is a large difference between a traumatic brain injury suffered in a car accident and Chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Just like a doctor could tell the difference between someone who suffered from chronic alcoholism and a person who died in from 1 night of binge drinking. The signs are very different. We have been getting this information as there have been several former NFL players who have had their brains examined after death and found to display CTE.Why would you better understand the amount of force required to cause a brain injury than doctors who study them? There are studies that having nothing to do with ESPN that have shown years of subconcussive blows can cause brain damage. Finally, I don't see ESPN wanting to damage the cash cow that is the NFL by exaggerating stories like this. The helmets are state of the art and that is part of the solution and part of the problem. The equipment makes players feel indestructible. The speed at which they are willing to lower their heads and collide with each other is amazing and far beyond what it was before the "state of the art" equipment.
 
Andrew Garda said:
I think it's very important that the NFL is the most-mentioned organization with participants that had (or have) CTE, but we remember the problem goes a lot deeper. There are far more college and high school players than their are NFL players. It means we should be as concerned with the amateurs (if not more). The problem is the high-profile cases with the professional players or former pros will predominate the headlines. Safety has to begin at the Pop Warner and high school levels. This is where the least amount of care is taken, the most variation in standards likely exist, and the most vulnerable participants are.The danger here is for a public perception fueled by a phenomenon generated from media coverage. It's an unintentional event, but because the media will focus so much on NFL players the public will think it more as an NFL problem than a football problem. If you ask the average person, they will tell you that there are far more car accidents than incidents of stomach cancer, but it's actually the opposite. The public doesn't realize it because media coverage is predominantly about car accidents than stomach cancer. Car accidents are more news worthy because they are unusual and grab more reader attention. The same will be with NFL players with CTE versus non-pros.
I think the trap here is - to some extent - that we get obsessed by big events which spur these things on. Chris Henry's death, Big Ben's 'incidents'. It shouldn't take a tragedy to cause study.Also, riffing off some of what you said Matt - as a dad with a son who desperately wants to play football, I think that getting absorbed in the immediacy of NFL head trauma is a bad idea. In order to have a real idea as to the affects of head trauma, shouldn't we be studying players from a young age? Some may not play as long as others but by and large this is the sort of injury IMO that can only be effectively studied long term.In other words, what are the risks and at what age do they start being serious? When should I worry about my kid and how can i protect him?I don't know you can study Henry's brain and make any real conclusion without knowing when, how and how often those injuries were incurred. How can you know his assault arrest was due to a head injury if you don't know when that happened?I had a doctor once who took a - I think it was a cardiogram or an EKG - of me so that he could later look back and see if there were any changes, maybe as warning signs, maybe to see what was cause for concern vs whatwas normal.One would thimk studying this similiarly would make more sense than reacting with 'oh so THAT'S why' on a post mortem exam.
The problem is that CTE currently can not been seen, tracked, or monitored until after death.
 
The problem is that CTE currently can not been seen, tracked, or monitored until after death.
Yipes - didn't know that, thanks.That makes this particular research really difficult then (someone probably just went 'well, duh'). It's hard to categorize the affect of something when you can't see when it happened so ou can begin attaching actions or a shift in personality to an injury.
 
The problem is that CTE currently can not been seen, tracked, or monitored until after death.
Yipes - didn't know that, thanks.That makes this particular research really difficult then (someone probably just went 'well, duh'). It's hard to categorize the affect of something when you can't see when it happened so ou can begin attaching actions or a shift in personality to an injury.
There are other brain injuries that can be detected, monitored and tracked though. Using that information and our understanding of the roles of certain parts of the brain, we do have some idea how CTE impacts people. However, it is impossible to diagnose a living person. Also, CTE doesn't "happen" in the sense a TBI from a car accident happens. It develops over a long period of time from a sequence of concussive and subconcussive blows. So we can never really put a time on when someone gets a CTE. Again, it is like putting a date on when someone became an alcoholic or when someone got Type 2 diabetes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Men running up and down the field weighing 300-350 lbs when no more than about 20-25 years ago the avg OL was about 250-275, that is much more disturbing IMO.
Moreso than serious brain injury? How do you figure?
It is likely that the increase in size has played some role in the increase in head injuries. Also, the damage to the cardiovascular system and the joints is significant for athletes striving to maintain extreme weights. However, brain injuries are incredibly serious and even worse, difficult to detect and treat. This is the number 1 health issue facing football.
 
3. The helmets they play with right now are state of the art and way better than the piece of leather our fathers and grandfathers played with.
That may be exactly why more players suffer head trauma these days (if they do). Somebody linked to an article in the Shark Pool on that very topic a few months ago. I'll search for it in a minute.If you have a leather helmet, you avoid helmet-to-helmet contact like the plague. Tackling form becomes completely different. (This is similar to the idea that seat belts increase the number of car accidents. See: Risk compensation.)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
3. The helmets they play with right now are state of the art and way better than the piece of leather our fathers and grandfathers played with.
That may be exactly why more players suffer head trauma these days (if they do). Somebody linked to an article in the Shark Pool on that very topic a few months ago. I'll search for it in a minute.If you have a leather helmet, you avoid helmet-to-helmet contact like the plague. Tackling form becomes completely different. (This is similar to the idea that seat belts increase the number of car accidents. See: Risk compensation.)
I may have been thinking of this post, but I thought I remembered seeing an external link to an article as well. Maybe not.
 
Same thing may be true in boxing:

Do gloves make boxing more dangerous?

Promotional posters for boxing matches in the 19th century followed a formula: the two adversaries would be depicted squaring up to each other, with heads tilted slightly backwards and their fists held low, the knuckles pointing out and upwards. The pose looks comical nowadays, as if they are actors in a silent movie rather than pugilists.

The stance and guard were low because bare-knuckle boxing consisted largely of striking the opponent's body. The skull is an extremely hard object, and a full-force punch to an opponent's head could easily result in a broken hand. This is why so many bar-room brawls end after one punch. The "boxer's fracture" a break behind the knuckle of the little finger is regularly seen in hospital casualty departments at weekends.

The Marquess of Queensberry rules took off not because society viewed the new sport as more civilised than the old, but because fights conducted under the new guidelines attracted more spectators. Audiences wanted to see repeated blows to the head and dramatic knockouts.

By contrast, the last bare-knuckle heavyweight contest in the US in 1897 dragged on into the 75th round. Since gloves spread the impact of a blow, the recipient of a punch is less likely to be blinded, have their teeth knocked out or their jaw broken. However, gloves do not lessen the force applied to the brain as it rattles inside the skull from a heavy blow. In fact, they make matters worse by adding 10oz to the weight of the fist.

A full-force punch to the head is comparable to being hit with a 12lb padded wooden mallet travelling at 20mph. Gerald McClellan took around 40 such blows over the course of his world title fight against Nigel Benn in 1995. Even the most hardened spectators were shocked by its brutality.

Neither fighter made any great attempts to defend himself. Instead, the two stood toe to toe, trading punches. As a result, McClellan suffered brain damage that left him blind, 80 per cent deaf and paralysed.

As the bare-knuckle campaigner Dr Alan J Ryan pointed out: "In 100 years of bare-knuckle fighting in the United States, which terminated around 1897 with a John L Sullivan heavyweight championship fight, there wasn't a single ring fatality." Today, there are three or four every year in the US, and around 15 per cent of professional fighters suffer some form of permanent brain damage during their career. Worldwide, there have been over 400 boxing deaths in the last 50 years alone. The total would be far higher were it not for the advances in medical care that saved the lives of fighters such as McClellan and Michael Watson. A return to bare knuckles would be bloodier and less acceptable to mass television audiences, but one has to ask whether wheelchairs and life-support machines are any easier on one's conscience.
Link. (That whole article is pretty interesting. It also argues, for example, that Muhammad Ali would have p\/\/n3d Bruce Lee.)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Chris Henry had enough people making excuses for him while he was alive...let's not continue it in his death too.

His history of stupid acts had nothing to do with the physical act of playing football and everything to do with his upbringing, years of enabling, and lack of personal responsibility.

 
The problem is that CTE currently can not been seen, tracked, or monitored until after death.
Yipes - didn't know that, thanks.That makes this particular research really difficult then (someone probably just went 'well, duh'). It's hard to categorize the affect of something when you can't see when it happened so ou can begin attaching actions or a shift in personality to an injury.
There are other brain injuries that can be detected, monitored and tracked though. Using that information and our understanding of the roles of certain parts of the brain, we do have some idea how CTE impacts people. However, it is impossible to diagnose a living person. Also, CTE doesn't "happen" in the sense a TBI from a car accident happens. It develops over a long period of time from a sequence of concussive and subconcussive blows. So we can never really put a time on when someone gets a CTE. Again, it is like putting a date on when someone became an alcoholic or when someone got Type 2 diabetes.
Again, I'd want to qualify this insomuch as we don't really know the mechanisms behind CTE. Currently, this is the thinking in the few neuroscience communities studying it. But, the problem is we don't have a very good brain autopsy database for this. We don't know the genetic factors mediating or moderating the development of CTE, either.Fact is, we don't know much about it at all (as of last year, there were only approximately 50 case studies). The brain bank will continue to grow and from a geeky neuroscience perspective it's really intriguing. But, I see a few folks (particularly in the lay media) taking hold of this and running with theories on which don't have any foundation whatsoever. In the discussions I've had with patients who raise this issue, as well as just casual conversations, my tact has been to proceed cautiously and really emphasize the point that we don't know a whole lot about how/why certain individuals' brains respond in such a way as to develop tauopathies (which really is the crux of what we think CTE is all about).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top