sho nuff
Footballguy
Not as much giving him a pass (and he should be criticized for that loss)...but just think he was legitimately a great coach. I don't think McCarthy was...obviously Sherman and Rhodes were not. LaFleur the jury is still out.CletiusMaximus said:No reason to give Holmgren a pass. He managed to lose a Superbowl as an 11 point favorite. In terms of Packer coaching failures during the Favre/Rodgers run, nothing comes close to XXXII.
Other than the last couple McCarthy seasons, one of which he played with Brett Hundley at QB, I think its hard to pin the lack of Superbowls on the head coaches. One year of Ray Rhodes was probably one too many. Mike Sherman doesn't bring back fond memories, but he won pretty consistently other than that disastrous final year. I really just think its hard to win Superbowls and especially hard to win 2 or more. There's a long list of great QB's who played long careers and only won 1 or none. The Packers have consistently been there at the end of the season many times. I think we have to acknowledge that many of the great Packer seasons over the last 25 years have ended because our HOF QB had a bad day.
I think that Holmgren's need for more front office power ended what could have been a crazy good run by that team with Favre at the helm.