What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

College Savings - other than 529's? (1 Viewer)

Can you explain how this works for out of state universities. If you contributed 50K to this plan or whatever the price is and your kid goes to Harvard which runs 200k, the state picks up the difference?
Wouldn't that be nice! No, the plan would pay the equivalent of the in-state Florida (or whatever state you use) tuition/fees and you would have to come up with the difference. Same goes for private institutions in-state.

 
Can you explain how this works for out of state universities. If you contributed 50K to this plan or whatever the price is and your kid goes to Harvard which runs 200k, the state picks up the difference?
Wouldn't that be nice! No, the plan would pay the equivalent of the in-state Florida (or whatever state you use) tuition/fees and you would have to come up with the difference. Same goes for private institutions in-state.
:oldunsure:

I'd take some time to read up. Every state can be completely different.

Mass uses pre paid certificates for a majority of the 200+ Public/Private College/University in state . Assume Harvard is $50K a year and Salem State U is $12.5K in 2014 for non-residents. If you send in a check for $50 this year you either get 4 years of Salem State or 1 year of Harvard at some point in the future.

The Florida plan only public university and colleges. They have 2 plans one for college and one for university and each one has it's own price.

Like I said - each prepaid can be vastly different so you need to read up Esp if one offers it for out of state.

 
Can you explain how this works for out of state universities. If you contributed 50K to this plan or whatever the price is and your kid goes to Harvard which runs 200k, the state picks up the difference?
Wouldn't that be nice! No, the plan would pay the equivalent of the in-state Florida (or whatever state you use) tuition/fees and you would have to come up with the difference. Same goes for private institutions in-state.
:oldunsure:

I'd take some time to read up. Every state can be completely different.

Mass uses pre paid certificates for a majority of the 200+ Public/Private College/University in state . Assume Harvard is $50K a year and Salem State U is $12.5K in 2014 for non-residents. If you send in a check for $50 this year you either get 4 years of Salem State or 1 year of Harvard at some point in the future.

The Florida plan only public university and colleges. They have 2 plans one for college and one for university and each one has it's own price.

Like I said - each prepaid can be vastly different so you need to read up Esp if one offers it for out of state.
I was keeping it simple, yes the plans do vary some, but the point is no plan is going to pay the difference between what you paid for and Harvard. As you said, in Mass you'll get either 4 years of state or 1 year of Harvard for the $50K (give or take). You pay for a plan that covers certain things, and if you go outside of those things they'll apply the equivalent of what you paid for.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can you explain how this works for out of state universities. If you contributed 50K to this plan or whatever the price is and your kid goes to Harvard which runs 200k, the state picks up the difference?
Wouldn't that be nice! No, the plan would pay the equivalent of the in-state Florida (or whatever state you use) tuition/fees and you would have to come up with the difference. Same goes for private institutions in-state.
:oldunsure:

I'd take some time to read up. Every state can be completely different.

Mass uses pre paid certificates for a majority of the 200+ Public/Private College/University in state . Assume Harvard is $50K a year and Salem State U is $12.5K in 2014 for non-residents. If you send in a check for $50 this year you either get 4 years of Salem State or 1 year of Harvard at some point in the future.

The Florida plan only public university and colleges. They have 2 plans one for college and one for university and each one has it's own price.

Like I said - each prepaid can be vastly different so you need to read up Esp if one offers it for out of state.
So if you go with the Florida plan, your kid can't go to Harvard?

 
So if you go with the Florida plan, your kid can't go to Harvard?
Seriously, take a look at that website, it has tons of info. and you can pull up each state to see what plans they offer, what rules they have, etc.

For Florida, you can't do the pre-paid plan if you aren't a resident. If you are a resident, yes your kid can go to Harvard, but not for free (unless they get scholarships or Harvard drops their tuition/fees to the same level as Florida in-state rates).

 
I use 7% inflation for my clients if they want to be totally covered. Count me in the group that thinks this bubble will burst eventually. I feel like trade schools will increase over the next 20 years. It's ridiculous the amount of school debt people have for jobs paying 40-60k.

 
Random said:
Here is some basic info about using an IRA for college, in general, the tax issue (529's are tax free) makes the IRA not as good a vehiclehttp://www.bankrate.com/brm/news/529/20060515a1.asp
Are you referring to Traditional IRAs here? In my brief research it seems to be treated identical to a Roth. No?
Yes I was talking about traditionals. The income restriction on Roths always removes that choice from my mind. Of course if you do qualify for a Roth, make sure you are saving enough for retirement before saving for college.

A very very rough rule of thumb is that if you don't have a pension, you should try and save 20% of your household gross income before saving for college.

This is a good breakdown of using Roth vs 529 for education.

http://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/investing/2013/roth-ira-vs-529-plan-best-college-savings/

 
Last edited by a moderator:
ROTH income limit is just a technicality, contribute lump sum to a traditional, don't take the deduction, no growth so no taxes due and do a ROTH conversion.

 
ROTH income limit is just a technicality, contribute lump sum to a traditional, don't take the deduction, no growth so no taxes due and do a ROTH conversion.
Yeah the backdoor Roth is sweet as lng as you don't already have money in a traditional IRA (if memory serves that is the only downside).

How many years have people been using the Roth backdoor? Has it been around forvever? I feel like I have only heard about it the last few years.

 
I had originally set up 529s, but am having a change of heart now. First deposit isnt set up to go in until tomorrow. I think I'm going to change it to go in to our Roths, simply for the diversity of what those accounts can be used for.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top