Collins Vs R.Freeman ROS, who’s your pony? Pick (1 Viewer)

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Similar ADP (both went within 3 picks of each other in both my leagues) 

I own both as my RB2/Flex (one on each of my 2 leagues) and believe they’ll both be at least flex-worthy & pay dividends down the stretch. 

But I’m trying to decide who’s got more upside & potential value. 

Freeman has Lindsay running hard ahead of him, but still gets work at the stripe & in the receiving game. 

Collons is a beast when he touches the ball, but inexplicably loses too many touches to Allen. Plus the fumbling issues. 

Assuming you could have one of these backs on your team as your flex player ROS, tell us the one you’d rather have one and explain why. Pros & cons, personal preference, maybe even (gasp!) use stats. 

go! 

 

[Arodin]

Matchup dependent imo.  Both have question marks and game script worries.  Both also have solid upside.

I expect carefully streamed choices weekly between the two would outscoreva full season of either...

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Matchup dependent imo.  Both have question marks and game script worries.  Both also have solid upside.

I expect carefully streamed choices weekly between the two would outscoreva full season of either...

You might be right, but given their ADP is identical, I’d bet most folks have one or the other.  

Kind of evades the question, too.  

 

[Stuart Ullman]

Collins, final answer.

 

[OnTheReg]

Collins. I think he ends up having a stronger season overall, whereas I really think Lindsay is going to be the RB1 in Denver. 

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

This isn’t a WSIS. I own each in separate leagues and I’m starting them both in  separate leagues. 

I was looking to see who the forum thought would be better the ROS and why since they’re similarly challenged & have almost identical ADP.

why would this be moved to the AC forum? 

Don’t bother answering - it’s not that kind of question.